Joining the Renewable Heating Hub forums is completely free and only takes a minute. By registering you’ll be able to ask questions, join discussions, follow topics you’re interested in, bookmark useful threads and receive notifications when someone replies. Non-registered members also do not have access to our AI features. When choosing your username, please note that it cannot be changed later, so we recommend avoiding brand or product names. Before registering, please take a moment to read the Forum Rules & Terms of Use so we can keep the community helpful, respectful and informative for everyone. Thanks for joining!
Aerotherm and weather compensation
Hi everyone. I know this is not a new topic with lots written but finding a clear explanation related to our situation eludes me. The AI tool certainly helps. If anyone can refer me to a prior post, that would be appreciated.
Our 3.5 Vaillant Aerotherm is going well with the system permanently on and controlled with WC using a 0.4 heat curve. We have 19C as our desired temperature using the thermostat in the wireless controller. During the afternoon and evening we use a wood burner to boost the temperature (we have a no cost wood supply) and as the wood generated heat dissipates overnight the HP takes over the heating.
In the morning, the temperature is normally about 18.5 and system is running. What I don’t understand is the flow temperature is always below that which I expect from the heat curve - normally by about 2 degrees. I recall something about hysteresis and Vaillant not wanting the temperature to overshoot. My experience is it never seems to actually reach temperature unless there is solar gain or the stove goes on. Can anyone explain what is happening?
Posted by: @davidb. We have 19C as our desired temperature using the thermostat in the wireless controller.
Posted by: @davidbWhat I don’t understand is the flow temperature is always below that which I expect from the heat curve - normally by about 2 degrees.
These are likely inked.
The basic explanation is that the heat curve, in addition to being adjusted according to the set slope, is also modified according to temperature set on the wireless thermostat. This is explained in the manual for the sensocomfort (page 4 in this version)
If you think about it too deeply it initially takes a bit of getting your head around. For most people, who wont compare FT to the curve, its not necessary to think about it at all! Is is actually very sensible for several reasons which I can go into if you wish. The easiest way I have found to rationalise it is that the slope setting (0.4 in your case) adjusts the curve to fit your house, whilst the set temperature on the sensocomfort adjusts the curve to your desired room temperature.
The set temperature setting on the sensocomfort has some other effects depending on whether the 'room temp mod' parameter is set to inactive, active or expanded. One of these could also be in play. If your 'room temp mod' is set to active and the setting of 0.4 is, in fact, slightly too high for your house, the autoadapt function will kick in and tweak the FT down.
Hope that helps explain the ft discrepancy, feel free to ask more questions, you have a good piece of kit with lots of functionality, but of course functionality and complexity go hand in hand.
If you are also concerned that the room temperature never reaches 19, then one of your settings is probably slightly out. If that is the case please post back and I will ask some questions to ferret out which. Alternatively just adjust the set temperature until you feel comfortable (also consider tweaking the weather curve again during a cold period, when its easier to do.)
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
Thanks JamesPa. You have reminded me to review the manual and the section on p17 of my sensocomfort manual.
I am fairly confident I understand the flow temp / thermostat temp relationship. I have adjusted the HC down considerably since my system was installed last year. The 0.4 is generally perfectly ok. 18.5C rather than 19 makes little difference to the comfort. My interest is principally academic.
i have my system set on expanded so the system cuts out if the room temperature exceeds the set temperature. This happens every day at the moment due to solar gain and putting on a wood stove later in the day. The HP turns off as other heat sources takeover with the HP coming on again as soon as the temp drops to the set temperature -3/16K. I just expect the FT to be at the temp set by the HC until the set temperature is reached. I just don’t understand why the FT is below the HC when the RT hasn’t been reached.
An associated uncertainty in my mind is our hybrid use of the system. I know the low and slow adage. Our house never drops below 18C, day and night and ramps up later in the day when the stove goes on to provided greater comfort when the TV is on etc. Clearly the HP turns off and all the water drops to room temperature until a little after midnight when the heat build up from the stove is lost from the fabric. I am not clear how “inefficient” this mode of operation is in practice. Any views on this would be appreciated.
Posted by: @davidbI am not clear how “inefficient” this mode of operation is in practice. Any views on this would be appreciated.
The principal cause of inefficiency if a heat pump is not on all the time is that the heat pump must run at a higher temperature, so that sufficient energy is released from radiators to house in the shorter period, in order to match the house loss. In your case this is not occurring, because the energy is instead being supplied from your free wood. Thus I don't see it will cause a material inefficiency.
Posted by: @davidbI just expect the FT to be at the temp set by the HC until the set temperature is reached. I just don’t understand why the FT is below the HC when the RT hasn’t been reached.
I would too, but reverse engineering the behaviour of a fairly sophisticated control loop can be tricky. Can you give some actual readings by way of example and how are you collecting the data?
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
@jamespa I replied yesterday with detailed readings which seemed to illustrate what is happening. Sadly the post doesn’t seem to have uploaded so I have lost the detail info. I am pretty sure I hit the right buttons - but apparently not. Very frustrating. I will try again when I get a moment. Part of this message is to check it uploads and doesn’t “disappear” as per yesterday.
one easy point to clarify is that all my data / observations come from Vaillant using their app and an iPad. I have done come cross checks against stand alone digital thermometers and the sensocomfort RT reading is very close to my stand alone thermometers.
- 27 Forums
- 2,827 Topics
- 67.1 K Posts
- 1,184 Online
- 7,246 Members


