Search with Wattson
The Changing Jet St...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Joining the Renewable Heating Hub forums is completely free and only takes a minute. By registering you’ll be able to ask questions, join discussions, follow topics you’re interested in, bookmark useful threads and receive notifications when someone replies. Non-registered members also do not have access to our AI features. When choosing your username, please note that it cannot be changed later, so we recommend avoiding brand or product names. Before registering, please take a moment to read the Forum Rules & Terms of Use so we can keep the community helpful, respectful and informative for everyone. Thanks for joining!

The Changing Jet Stream Could Challenge UK Air Source Heat Pumps

98 Posts
17 Users
53 Reactions
10 K Views
(@rob-of-york)
Reputable Member Member
Joined: 3 months ago
Posts: 174
 

@susannasaunders
That's a serious amount of solar PV given the sqm of your house! You should be in a great position to run a heat pump of whatever flavour off of cheap electricity. That changes the equation somewhat on when to run A2A. You could conceivably run it much of the time, with the TRVs on the living room radiators stopping the GCH from heating that room. Put the thermostat for gas heating elsewhere and use a lower set point for that and the A2A could do most of the work, particularly if you effectively have the GCH off most of the night. There's definitely quite a few things that you can experiment with to get the right set up that works for you.
To avoid drafts, you can use the indoor quiet mode where the fan is barely audible and you just won't notice the airflow. The output is lower, but with the low heat loss of your house that is likely still enough to keep your living room warm. Perfera indoor units also have something called "Intelligent Eye" that detects if someone is in the room. With that feature turned on, after 20 mins of no one being there it will drop the set point by 2C to save energy, and automatically up it again when it sees someone return. It also avoids directing air at you to reduce drafts. Overnight, you can let the A2A run in auto mode, which adjusts the fan speed as necessary to reach the set point quickly. 
There are A2A systems that do hot water too. Daikin Multi+ is one, but they are bigger multi-split systems, for example 6.8kW capable of connecting to 3 indoor units.
One thing to realise with a semi-detached is that permitted development only allows for one heat pump (outdoor unit). So if you wanted A2A and A2W as separate outdoor units, then you would need planning permission. If they were sited appropriately and the noise calculations worked out fine, then there is no good reason why permission shouldn't be granted. Having to get planning permission is a PITA though that adds time and cost, and needs to be done prior to installation of the second heat pump.   
I suspect that the A2W and A2A BUS grants will be cut sometime in 2027, as the budget just took about £750 million off the overall funding for them and this financial year it looks like the total funding available (£400 million) will run out around the end of the calendar year (only £143 million left at the end of Sept, half way through the financial year). There's a whole thread here about A2W installs being expensive: https://renewableheatinghub.co.uk/forums/renewable-heating-air-source-heap-pumps-ashps/why-are-ashp-installs-so-expensive/
The swings in temperature with your gas CH are likely down to the flow temperature being higher than needed for the low heat loss of your house. This means once the thermostat switches the heating off, the room temperature tends to overshoot due to all that (too) hot water in the radiators. You can turn the flow temperature down on the boiler to alleviate this problem. You can probably run at a flow temperature of no more than about 60C (50C right now before it gets near 0C) and that would make the boiler more efficient as it would enable it to operate in condensing mode. Better still you could get weather compensation fitted to the boiler, so that it reduces the flow temperature when it is mild outside. We have this on our boiler and at present for the short times that the gas CH comes on the radiators sit at about 35-40C. This leads to very stable room temperatures and low and slow heating exactly like an A2W heat pump would do.


This post was modified 3 weeks ago by Majordennisbloodnok

   
ReplyQuote
(@rob-of-york)
Reputable Member Member
Joined: 3 months ago
Posts: 174
 

@susannasaunders 

Even with a A2W system, I'm still going to want an A2A system for the summer cooling (I can't handle the heat waves at all above 25C). 

If summer cooling is actually the #1 priority for A2A, then almost certainly it would be better installed in your upstairs hallway. Then you can open and close doors to direct cool air where you want it on hot days in summer. Since warm air rises up through the house, it's much better to have the A2A up there for cooling and let some of the cool air drift downstairs. It will still work well enough for heating and drafts from the airflow are a non-issue in a hallway. By turning down the TRVs in all the upstairs rooms, you can let the A2A effectively take care of upstairs heating and use gas CH downstairs.
My brother has a 67 sqm semi-detached 1950s house, with a good level of retrofit insulation. Heat loss is about 4.5kW. He has a Daikin Perfera 3.5kW single-split A2A system on order (£2200), to be fitted in his upstairs hallway at the recommendation of the same installer that I used last year.
The A2W option is more expensive to install even with the BUS grant, however, given the massive amount of battery capacity that you have, it may still be a good option in the long run. Given your need for cooling in summer, you could take a look at Octopus' offering (still in development) called "Octopus Cosy Cooler".
https://octopus.energy/cosy-cooler/
This is a circa £500 to £600 add on unit, a bit like a portable AC unit, but it attaches to the radiator pipework to get rid of excess heat via the heat pump rather than trailing a large flexible ducting hose out of a window. It works only in conjunction with Octopus Cosy heat pumps, so you would need a Cosy 6 heat pump, but then you would have a complete low carbon heating and cooling set up running off a single heat pump outside (no planning permission issues). Note there are no details yet on how powerful Cosy Cooler is or its efficiency, other than it says suitable for 20-30 sqm rooms.
I would recommend taking a careful look at the potential running costs for gas CH vs an A2W heat pump. Although you have a large amount of solar and batteries, the fact that you can time shift via your batteries and export at a really good export rate (e.g. 30p) means that your marginal cost of electricity is 30p. In other words, if you take some electricity to run a heat pump, then you have less that you can export and the lost export is 30p per unit, so compared to gas CH that is what your heat pump really costs you to run despite the batteries and solar PV. Given the high capital costs of A2W even after the grant, it is likely that the economics are in favour of keeping gas CH and adding A2A with no subsidy.


This post was modified 3 weeks ago by Majordennisbloodnok

   
ReplyQuote
JamesPa
(@jamespa)
Vaillant
Illustrious Member Moderator
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 5716
 

Posted by: @rob-of-york
↑

I would recommend taking a careful look at the potential running costs for gas CH vs an A2W heat pump. Although you have a large amount of solar and batteries, the fact that you can time shift via your batteries and export at a really good export rate (e.g. 30p) means that your marginal cost of electricity is 30p. In other words, if you take some electricity to run a heat pump, then you have less that you can export and the lost export is 30p per unit, so compared to gas CH that is what your heat pump really costs you to run despite the batteries and solar PV. Given the high capital costs of A2W even after the grant, it is likely that the economics are in favour of keeping gas CH and adding A2A with no subsidy.

There is a distinct risk of overthinking this, modelling these things is extremely difficult even if you have the data and ToU tarrifs vary a lot, are likely to change dramatically as we electrify and are anyway subject to political manipulation.  Thus any modelling done now is valid only for a short period of time relative to the lifetime of the kit.  Of course if you can and want to do the modelling go ahead, but otherwise I tend personally to simplify it thus: 

With an electricity to gas price ratio of 3.5-4 (which is the typical value in recent years) a reasonably well installed A2W heat pump without a battery will cost roughly the same to run as a modern, well set up gas boiler, perhaps a bit less, and should deliver a greater level of comfort with about 25% of the carbon footprint, the latter reducing year on year.  If the gas boiler being replaced is old or poorly set up, the heat pump should cost less to run and with a battery and a decent ToU tarrif you should definitely save**.  Battery or not, solar panels affect the costs of running principally in the shoulder season when we get bright days of reasonable length, but in the height of the season when its cold, for the most part dull, and the days are short they have a marginal/negligible effect.  Overall therefore possibly best ignored at this level of detail.

I accept that this is broad brush and there will be exceptions but most people dont have the time or the data to model it in detail and the uncertainty of future prices anyway cant really be factored in.  I therefore suggest that, for most, this is a sound basis for an investment decision.

 

** The exception is if you are playing arbitrage games (buying at a low price and selling at a high price) with a significant proportion of your battery capacity during the heating season then you should probably ignore the battery when considering the running costs of the heat pump, because any capacity used to power the heat pump will just reduce the capacity available for arbitrage.

 

More broadly this is an interesting discussion.

I dont think we have fully explored/fully understand A2A yet as a domestic heating solution, there have been too few installs. 

With a house that has lots of separate rooms and an existing distribution network it is difficult to see how it is going to work - this is where A2W majors.  For a relatively open plan house, particularly if its modest in size, it seems like A2A is a great fit delivering both heating and cooling is a single package at a higher efficiency than A2W.  With a decent ToU tarrif and/or solar panels, the simplest DHW solution in this case is probably an immersion heater in a tank.  Retaining a boiler, particularly if the standing charge is scrapped, is clearly also an option.  By the time you take into account maintenance costs for a boiler dedicated to DHW an immersion probably work out cheaper though!

Regarding cooling this is another area we haven't fully explored/understood and Im not sure we even have the right products yet! 

In the aforesaid open plan house the solution where A2A heating is practical the solution is perhaps obvious - just use A2A. I feel that this could be a major selling point once the industry is ready to deliver A2A in volume in domestic situations, which currently it is not.

In a more fragmented house where A2A heating is a poor fit than then fitting one or two a2a units in the upstairs hallway and perhaps the most used living room seems like a reasonable cooling option, and the same unit(s) also provide supplementary heating if required.  However (assuming we have an A2W heat pump) do we really want 2 ODUs/separate systems when we already have an A2W heat pump, and unnecessary wall units.  I certainly don't.  Nor do I want the abomination of a tube hanging out the window with a unit that sucks hot air into the house in order to cool it!  This is where the product gap lies.  The Octopus Cosy Cooler attempts to fill that gap but still leaves you with unit to store for 11 months of the year.  I dont really want that either.  What I want is a wall hung unit (replacing a radiator) that I can connect to my A2W heat pump that will both heat and cool, without having to insulate all the water pipework in my house!  Such units do (sort of) exist designed for swanky office and apartment blocks, but cost about 3K plus each.

 

 


This post was modified 3 weeks ago 4 times by JamesPa

4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.


   
ReplyQuote
Toodles
(@toodles)
Daikin
Famed Member Contributor
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 3091
 

@jamespa Ah! Thank you, I had been thinking of chipping in that the solar panel contribution when you need it most is at its’ least! I have 8.1 kWp. of solar panels and in December and January, the typical contribution totals less than 250 kWh for those two darkest months combined. Don’t get me wrong, I am very grateful for the contribution but it will not keep a heat pump running!

Regarding arbitrage: this is a game some may like to play but, I have given up on it due to several reasons including my inability to see sufficiently well to alter settings several times a day and the inflexibility of the Tesla app unless investing in the Netzero app. which in itself adds ~£6 or more per month to the game.

My battery (27 kWh) works well for me to capture all the grid energy I need in the ‘heating’ months at the lowest Octopus Cosy rate of the tariff - so I avoid using the more expensive times of the tariff. Naturally any solar contribution helps to eek out every last photon and the Powerwalls store these until required.

I have been giving thought to how things may change for us once the A2A Aircon is installed early next year primarily needed for our ever warmer summers when the solar panels will power the 4 internal and the one external unit. (I base this on the notion that if it is warm enough to need the aircon, there is probably sufficient sunlight during the extended day to power the system and using stored energy, also take care of the powering at night too.) Maybe those same units will allow us to manipulate our heating arrangements in the shoulder months, we will have to wait and see.

Looking at ‘Balance Sheet Whatiffery’, I have never been able to come up with a costing for my energy needs with any confidence. Basing things on the export rate which might raise one figure and comparing it with another figure based on consuming that energy instead of exporting it gives very different outcomes! I do know that at no time will any energy I export raise as much as the higher priced import rate costs per kWh on Octopus Outgoing Fixed and Octopus Cosy cheapest rate. Regards, Toodles. 


Toodles, heats his home with cold draughts and cooks food with magnets.


   
Like
2
ReplyQuote

JamesPa
(@jamespa)
Vaillant
Illustrious Member Moderator
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 5716
 

Posted by: @susannasaunders
↑

What are peoples general feelings about the BUS A2W and A2A grant amounts? Are they sufficient or not in your opinion, especially in light of the GCH having to be removed completely?

This is an interesting question.  For me it needs to be asked in the wider context of tarrifs and regulation because if you tweak one it can change the equation dramatically.  For example if the ratio of gas to electricity price were 2.5, then the argument for heat pumps as a pure financially driven investment (as opposed to one based on comfort and carbon footprint) becomes very strong.

My personal view is that the current 'system' (grants, tarrifs, regulations) is designed to fail.  The ratio of electricity to gas prices has risen steadily form 2.5-3 to around 4 during the period 2011-2020, as policy costs were progressively loaded onto unit prices.  Meanwhile regulation and customer protection was handed to an industry-funded body which, not surprisingly, designed the regulation to protect the industry more than it protects the customer.  The grant certainly helps with the capital cost, and increasing it to £7,500 made a difference, but does little when people do not have confidence in the product and in particular its relative running cost.  Finally the industry has not even tried to develop a way to respond to the 'failed boiler' scenario, which is the only time most people consider replacing their heating.  Furthermore (with the exception of Heat Geek) it sells based on a load of technical specs (flow temperatures etc) which few understand and ultimately none care about, rather than things (cost, comfort) which people both understand and care about.  The regulation hampers progress in fixing these!  In fairness our understanding of the practical use of the technology, and some aspects of the technology itself, have evolved immensely and thus the technological context has changed, but the underlying fundamentals remain namely a grant/tariff/regulation system that does not encourage the behaviour it is supposed(?) to support.

Whether this 'design to fail' was deliberate political choice, lack of attention to detail or just incompetence is a matter of speculation, but until its fixed things wont change materially.

The current government has signalled changes which will improve things.  The removal of some policy costs from electricity tariffs and the abolition of the gas standing charge should reduce the electricity to gas price ratio as does the removal of VAT (albeit that this may only be temporary).  There is a consultation underway the clear intent of which is to take consumer protection (for several retrofit measures) away from the industry rectifying, hopefully, the fundamental structural error in this part of the picture.  There is also talk,, but as yet no concrete proposal, of decoupling electricity from gas prices.  However these things take time and more needs to be done if we are serious about converting to electric heating and reducing our dependence on despot states.

Personally I would like to see this go a lot further.  We are currently upgrading many parts of the gas distribution network because they are dangerously old.  This is ultimately wasted capital investment and, if its possible to construct a suitable scheme, the money could instead be given to households to subsidise them to move off gas.  A determined initiative to solve the 'failed boiler' problem is essential, the technology is now at a point where its entirely reasonable to contemplate doing this.  If we could combine these measures with the current ones aimed at reducing the price ratio, the case for conversion becomes compelling at an individual level, and loans could replace grants to enable those who are less well off to make the switch. 

We could even go further and tax the carbon in fuels, recycling the money so that average fuel prices (averaged across all fuels) don't increase.  The costs, short and long term, of continuing to pour carbon into the atmosphere and our reliance of despot states for our energy have to be met somehow, and logically they should be met by those who are responsible.  Clearly this would be hugely controversial and would need to be introduced slowly over a period of many years, but there is a strong moral and intergenerational argument to support it.  Currently we are consuming what we want and foisting the costs onto future generations, a position that morally is difficult to justify!


This post was modified 3 weeks ago 13 times by JamesPa

4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.


   
ReplyQuote
(@rob-of-york)
Reputable Member Member
Joined: 3 months ago
Posts: 174
 

@jamespa
I agree with your general comments about running costs for heat pumps, including the exception if doing arbitrage. The difficulty is that the context @susannasaunders has has got to be close to the worst case for making an economic argument for a heat pump vs. gas heating.
Specifically:
Daily arbitrage of 12kWh via a 24kWh battery. While it is likely that flat export rates will drop in the not too distant future, the rate paid for export during the peak at 4-7pm is likely to stay high for a long time. Arbitrage of this sort is exactly what the grid needs and energy providers are willing to pay for. So it seems reasonable to assume this as the marginal rate i.e. the cost for the electricity used by a heat pump.
2024 new build, so a 2-year old gas boiler not in need of replacing anytime soon. Great insulation, so very low gas consumption of 6400 kWh and a modest bill for gas usage of £640 a year at 10p per unit. Combi-boiler and no space for a hot water tank. Radiators sized for gas that need a flow temperature of circa 55C to produce the heat required by the HeatPunk modelling, likely the same as required by MCS (even if we know 4kW is most likely an over estimate). 
A BUS grant compliant A2W heat pump would need a hot water tank installing, and likely multiple radiators replacing, then given the arbitrage the running costs would be about the same as the gas boiler that has been replaced.
I just can't see how the economics can work in this particular case. The install cost would be substantially more than the BUS grant, since a new hot water tank and at least some new radiators would be needed.
The unfortunately thing here is that heat pumps were not mandated for new builds in 2024 as they are now, otherwise there would be one in place, with a hot water tank and radiators of the appropriate size. 


This post was modified 3 weeks ago by Majordennisbloodnok

   
Like
3
ReplyQuote
JamesPa
(@jamespa)
Vaillant
Illustrious Member Moderator
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 5716
 

Posted by: @rob-of-york
↑

A BUS grant compliant A2W heat pump would need a hot water tank installing, and likely multiple radiators replacing, then given the arbitrage the running costs would be about the same as the gas boiler that has been replaced.

Given its a new build and the building regs changed a few years ago to mandate design for max 55C flow temp, it's quite possible rads don't need replacing.  However I believe builders can game the regs by some sort of pre registration nonsense which locks ttem in to older regs, so it may not be thus way..  In any case I agree totally with everything else you say.

From the floor plans posted earlier the house isn't particularly open plan, so any a2w heating or cooling might need several units or be limited in scope

As you say heat pumps should have been be mandatory in new hones for several years.  The big housebuilders have too much clout.


This post was modified 3 weeks ago 3 times by JamesPa

4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.


   
Like
2
ReplyQuote
(@rob-of-york)
Reputable Member Member
Joined: 3 months ago
Posts: 174
 

@toodles 

once the A2A Aircon is installed early next year primarily needed for our ever warmer summers when the solar panels will power the 4 internal and the one external unit.

I'm sure you won't have any issues on that front, your multi-split A2A will be massively efficient on cooling (SEER 8.5?).

The hottest day this year, we had to dump 36kWh of heat out of our 146 sqm house to stay 10 degrees below ambient (24C vs. 34C) the efficiency of our Daikin A2A on that day was 7.8, so 4.6 kWh needed, meanwhile the 6.56kW solar PV did 37.9kWh ...

Since you already have an A2W heat pump, there may not be that much economic gain in using A2A for heating (the SCOP for the A2A will be a little better). The main advantages are that you can choose to heat just one room with an A2A indoor unit in it, heat different rooms to different temperatures as each indoor unit is individually controllable, and do really fast warm up if you come back to a cold house for some reason. The redundancy could potentially also be useful if your A2W heat pump was out of action for some reason, and vice-versa.

First heat wave of 2027 and you will fall in love with your A2A 


This post was modified 3 weeks ago 2 times by Rob of York

   
Like
1
ReplyQuote

Toodles
(@toodles)
Daikin
Famed Member Contributor
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 3091
 

@rob-of-york Yes, these are the very reasons we feel we are making a wise decision. We can’t ‘hold back the tide’, if the ambient temperature is rising, we can at least moderate the effect on our lifestyle and keep our cool so to speak.😉 Rewards, Toodles.


This post was modified 3 weeks ago by Majordennisbloodnok

Toodles, heats his home with cold draughts and cooks food with magnets.


   
Like
1
ReplyQuote
(@etchedpixels)
Reputable Member Member
Joined: 6 months ago
Posts: 235
 

Posted by: @jamespa
↑

Given its a new build and the building regs changed a few years ago to mandate design for max 55C flow temp, it's quite possible rads don't need replacing.  However I believe builders can game the regs by some sort of pre registration nonsense which locks ttem in to older regs, so it may not be thus way..  In any case I agree totally with everything else you say.

 
You are correct that until recently the housebuilders would lay a sewage pipe or similar for each plot once they started and then used that to build all the houses over many years to the date of the sewage pipe. That scam has thankfully now been stopped.
The other two problems are
- Assuming a newbuild has insulation to the standard specified. Lots of people taking IR cameras to their home have discovered they have giant gaps in the insulation or in some cases no insulation fitted at all triggering massive mess
- Assuming the plumbing complies with the specification. You are lucky if it's water tight.
 
 


This post was modified 3 weeks ago by Majordennisbloodnok

   
Like
1
ReplyQuote
Toodles
(@toodles)
Daikin
Famed Member Contributor
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 3091
 

@etchedpixels There is a lot to be said for living in a ‘Mature Build’ home, one can move in, assume that much work needs to be done in the way of insulation, re-wiring, re-plastering and decoration etc., but at least one is for-warned that this work may be required to bring the dwelling up to an acceptable standard. The new build should have all this work already carried out but one can never be sure…


This post was modified 3 weeks ago by Toodles

Toodles, heats his home with cold draughts and cooks food with magnets.


   
Like
1
ReplyQuote
(@watcher)
Eminent Member Member
Joined: 8 months ago
Posts: 21
 

Posted by: @susannasaunders
↑

To my knowledge, no A2A system will supply hot water...

Money Saving Expert has some interesting insights.
😉
https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/6675319/daikin-multi-split-a2a-heat-pump-heating-cooling-and-hot-water/p1
 
Also, perhaps….as an interim?
https://www.midea.com/uk/air-treatment/porta-split-air-conditioner.portasplit


This post was modified 3 weeks ago by Majordennisbloodnok

   
ReplyQuote

Page 6 / 9

Share:
Click to access the login or register cheese
Protected By
Shield Security PRO