why solar diverters for HW instead of the heat pump?
am i missing something? was watching this podcast and they started suggesting solar diverters for HW even with a Heat Pump. why? heat with heat pump get maybe 1-3 ratio? or us immersion and get 1-1 ratio.
The argument I can think of is that solar diverters precisely match the power draw to the available excess solar power, which heat pumps cannot do. This means that with a heat pump you may be importing some or most of the power consumed, whereas with a solar diverter you are guaranteed not to be importing any.
The financial equation depends also on your import/export rates so if, for example, you are not getting paid for export then a solar diverter may well make sense even if you have a heat pump.
One approach favoured by many is to time DHW heating at say noon, when you are likely to have solar (in the season) and also the heat pump is likely to be efficient because its likely to be warm. If, alternatively, you have a night time import tariff which is less than your export tariff it makes sense (at least when there is any export available) to do it on the heat pump at night!
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
Spot on, @adamk. This is exactly why, when our diverter failed, we chose not to replace it. It was a bit of a lightbulb moment for me, and part of what led to me creating this calculator:
@jamespa raises some valid points too, and it’s always good to look at the wider picture, but in our case, it’s hard to ignore the numbers. To heat our 300-litre tank to 45C, our heat pump uses around 5.81kWh (on a 2.7 COP). The diverter, by comparison, would use 15.7kWh. That kind of efficiency gap makes the choice pretty straightforward for us.
Get a copy of The Ultimate Guide to Heat Pumps
Subscribe and follow our Homeowners’ Q&A heat pump podcast
I should probably add to my comments above that, whilst I can definitely see an argument for using a solar diverter in some cases - most particularly if you get no payment for export, I removed mine once I got the ASHP. I currently get paid 15p for export and only pay 7p at night for import, so my cheapest option by far is to heat DHW at night on the ASHP, and export by day if there is excess solar available.
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
Posted by: @adamkam i missing something? was watching this podcast and they started suggesting solar diverters for HW even with a Heat Pump. why? heat with heat pump get maybe 1-3 ratio? or us immersion and get 1-1 ratio.
For me there are few factors why you may want to heat water via excess PV.
1. You don't get any money for export.
2. You do get money, but because you don't or can't have a smart meter you will only get 4.5p kWh
3. I generally get a CoP of 3 or less doing DHW, so it costs me on my tariff more than either 4.3p or 10p to heat water per kWh of actual heating.
4. If you run legionella cycles you get them for free, mostly, with a diverter.
So for me, I have smart meter, but it cannot communicate due to poor signal area. We have self installed PV so don't get paid for export. Prefer to have cylinder heated to 70 degs whenever it's free to do so. Then night time (cheap rate) heating of cylinder doesn't occur, as cylinder is still hot enough, this saves a few pennies each time. Our cylinder today is still at 64 degs from being heated yesterday, so unlikely to need heating by heat pump today. Normal routine is heat twice per day, so no heat pump heating yesterday or today from one good solar day. 4 cycles of heat pump live saved. Do that 6 months of the year, you add a further year or two on the overall life of the ASHP.
If you have a battery a diverter isn't the most efficient, as battery has to full and excess energy going to grid. I prefer to use a big relay controlled by home assistant to leverage battery capacity just prior to battery being full and divert the full 3kW at the immersion. This ensures nothing goes to grid, if there is work to be done in the house.
- 26 Forums
- 2,255 Topics
- 50.3 K Posts
- 847 Online
- 5,918 Members
Join Us!
Podcast Picks
Latest Posts
- 
                        RE: Daikin Altherma 3 / HomeAssistant @majordennisbloodnok Thanks for your input. This i... By Ubert767 , 49 minutes ago 
- 
                        RE: Are We Sleepwalking Into Another Race to the Bottom? Alright, I concede that the Toyotas are, as you say a v... By JamesPa , 58 minutes ago 
- 
                        RE: Help me keep the faith with my air source heat pump installation No. OK so the integration is installed. Good. Via... By JamesPa , 1 hour ago 
- 
                        RE: Midea ASHP – how to set weather compensation @cathoderay comments duly noted. I don't disagree with ... By pash44pump , 4 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: When will fusion be producing energy? From the time I was a physics undergraduate it’s been 2... By Judith , 12 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Is it mad to think there should be a minimum SCOP for UK heat pump installs? Sadly I think it is mad. If the BUS is not granted for ... By Judith , 13 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Who has a V2G EV installation Perfect, @agentgeorge. I’m always up for some edificati... By Majordennisbloodnok , 13 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: My experience with 3 heat pump surveys: Heat Geek, British Gas & Octopus Yes but... The evidence is that many heat loss survey... By JamesPa , 14 hours ago 
- 
                          What Adam Chapman gets up to in his Spare Time. Ok, so this just appeared on YouTube (don’t blame me th... By Toodles , 14 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Radiator Sizing Dilemma: Vertical vs Type 33 for Low-Temperature Heat Pump Systems That's my main concern too. On top of that, I ... By DREI , 16 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Grant 13kW Aerona3 - issues getting zones to temp Thanks, patience is something I’m trying to ma... By Crimson , 18 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Solar Power Output – Let’s Compare Generation Figures 2025 - now a record year of Solar PV Generation. Octobe... By AllyFish , 21 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan R290 10kW performance Totally agree that any system is reliant on the ability... By Sheriff Fatman , 22 hours ago 
- 
                        British Gas Heat Pump Installation Complaint In 2024, my wife and I thought that we would try to do ... By BGNO , 1 day ago 
- 
                          Erm... no we can't! The issue first raised by the OP ... By Transparent , 1 day ago 
- 
                        RE: Testing new controls/monitoring for Midea Clone ASHP Thx, but Sven did the hardware development. My role (as... By Mosibi , 2 days ago 
- 
                        RE: PV Panels on roof in Conservation Area @majordennisbloodnok Fnaargh, I was thinking about try... By colinc , 2 days ago 
- 
                        RE: Electricity price predictions @jamespa Ah, you mean MPs that have not pro... By Batpred , 2 days ago 
- 
                        RE: Buying large amp bidirectional RCD and RCBO Exactly @transparent , this type of RCBOs are not easil... By Batpred , 2 days ago 


 
                        
 
                                 
                                 
                                 
                                
