What suggestions to give to someone with a buffer tank - how best to set an unnecessary buffer tank up
We get a lot of reports here from people who are having problems with their systems, many of who have a buffer tank. I think its clear that very best advice, in most cases, would be not to have the buffer tank in the first place or to replumb it as a volumiser, however that generally isn't an option (without compromising warranty) by the time the problem is reported. The most typical scenario we see here (sadly) is a 50l dumpy tank with absolutely no control that attempts to maintain stratification.
Obviously the suggestions in any particular circumstance depends on the circumstance, but lets presume for the sake of this argument that its reasonably clear that the buffer tank is causing a loss of efficiency, which is commonly the case from what we see here. Lets also presume that the installer has, one way or another, disconnected so the householder is effectively on their own. What suggestions can we give?
Obviously one option is 'do nothing and get a professional in' but sadly that is often not realistic. Can we offer any practical suggestions to someone who will have no specialist tools?
In the circumstance above here is an outline strawman (detail can be added later) and I am inviting people who may have experienced (and maybe solved) the problem to tear it apart and rebuild in the spirit of being constructive
1. Dont panic!
take things slowly and calmly, make notes of any changes you make
2. Assess the problem
get at least 2 digital thermometers, eg from Amazon. Measure the temperature difference between flow from heat pump and flow to emitters. Be sure that the probes are well in contact with the pipes and put some insulation over them, also swap the probes over and note all four readings, so we can eliminate probe variability. Do this when its cold, or at least fairly cold, outside (say 10C or less) and the heat pump is running.
For every degree that the temperature of the flow to emitters is less than the temperature of the flow from the heat pump you are losing about 3% in efficiency.
3. If the loss above is significant, you can attempt to mitigate it
There are two possible ways to reduce this.
(a) you can reduce the deltaT across the emitters by speeding up the pump on the secondary side
(b) you can reduce mixing by ensuring that the volume flow rate on the primary side is equal to, (or, in practice, slightly more because equal to is impossible), than the volume flow rate on the secondary side, thus pushing the thermocline down the tank.
4. Here are some outline guidelines on a process
If you have more than one pump on the secondary side care will be needed to keep them in balance.
You will need to work out what adjustments are available to you. It may be possible to change the primary pump speed either in the installer menu or on the pump itself. It is very likely possible to change the pump speed on the secondary side.
At this point you should note whether the secondary pump is controlled by the heat pump or by the room stats (often via a wiring centre). If it is controlled by the heat pump note if there are two cables or one cable from heat pump to secondary pump. If the latter then its probably a PWM pump the speed of which is controlled by the heat pump in which case it is likely best to leave well alone.
Unless the above indicates leave well alone you can then try to adjust the pump speeds to improve matters. Before you start note all current settings so you can put them back. You should ideally look to maximise the secondary pump (volumetric) speed and adjust the primary to be slightly higher - you can check by minimising the temp diff flow to flow across the buffer. If you reach the max speed of the primary before it matches the secondary, turn down the secondary until you can match them. You may need to iterate.
The above will need to be done with all zone valves/TRVs fully open (which is how you should be operating anyway). It may not be possible with heat pumps (eg Daikin) which attempt to maintain a fixed deltaT flow to return by modulating the pump.
The result should be a significantly smaller difference between flow temp from heat pump and flow temp to emitters from buffer. If it is then good, if not then reset to initial conditions.
Comments from all welcome, @ashp-bobba, @pirate-rich and other professionals your comments would be particularly welcome as would @toodles who, if my memory serves me, has done this himself, but all are welcome to make constructive comments.
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
In our installation, we actually have an LLH but any difference is subtle I know; our secondary pump (Wilo Pico) is switched on/off from the Daikin control but the flow rate has separate control via the Pico’s own flow controller.
I placed sensors (from Amazon) on all four ports to / from the LLH and covered them with insulation. I had previously ‘calibrated’ all four sensors by bundling them and observing the difference in readings. By much tweaking I have been able to adjust the pump so that the difference between flow in to LLH and flow out to emitters is <0.2 degrees and similarly, the temperature from the emitters into the LLH and the out port for return flow is equally close. There are minor variations due I think to the Daikin pump ramping between ~28 lpm and 15 lpm (with occasional excursions as low as ~10 lpm), I see Wilo readings that indicate that the flow rate hovers around the 15 lpm mark with very little variation. Now I know that the temperature sensors may not be accurate themselves but I am using a relative-to-the-other probes method to compare the readings on the four ports.
As an aside, having recently replaced our late 1980’s double glazing with argon gas filled triple glazing, I note that the Homely controlled flow temperature has dropped some degrees to provide the same level of comfort. Time and winter temperatures will no doubt make any differences clearer! Regards, Toodles.
Toodles, heats his home with cold draughts and cooks food with magnets.
- 26 Forums
- 2,356 Topics
- 53.4 K Posts
- 212 Online
- 6,017 Members
Join Us!
Worth Watching
Latest Posts
-
RE: Octopus Cosy Heat Pump Owners & Discussion Thread
@andrewj Seeing they deleted both threads with the pict...
By HarrisonC , 3 hours ago
-
RE: Who's your electricity provider and what's your tariff?
@mars I think your commentary is very fair and balanc...
By JamesPa , 3 hours ago
-
RE: External pipework insulation
That's great advice @transparent... thank you. @david...
By Mars , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Advice on internal circulation pump noise
Thanks @mikefl - I'll maybe have a look at the lock-shi...
By jtg , 5 hours ago
-
RE: Heat Pump Heats the House… But It’s Not Cosy. Emitter Changes or System Tweak?
@toodles interesting suggestion, thanks. I will try to...
By GrahamF , 5 hours ago
-
RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan Auto Adaption trial to stop cycling.
The interval you talk of, i think, will be 60min for an...
By F1p , 9 hours ago
-
RE: Electricity price predictions
Does anyone have a current graphic, visual or breakdown...
By Mars , 12 hours ago
-
Agree with @majordennisbloodnok on the setbacks. We hav...
By ChandyKris , 1 day ago
-
RE: New Fogstar 15.5kWh upright solution
It is a matter of luck. 2ith Fogstar "instructions", to...
By Batpred , 1 day ago
-
RE: Speedcomfort radiator fans
@deltona the way the links were added broke the page. A...
By Mars , 1 day ago
-
RE: Setback savings - fact or fiction?
I agree! Even more so if we get an answer! But the chal...
By cathodeRay , 1 day ago
-
RE: Refrigerant R32, is it now banned in the EU from 1st Jan 2027 for monobloc ASHPs?
This has been delayed from what I believe to be this ye...
By dgclimatecontrol , 1 day ago
-
RE: Are We Sleepwalking Into Another Race to the Bottom?
this is why I provided current flow temperatures in the...
By ksim , 1 day ago
-
RE: Why Millions of UK Homes Struggle With Heat Pumps
There's many homes that would be quite a disruption for...
By dgclimatecontrol , 1 day ago
-
RE: Ecodan unable to hit legionella target temp - what's the consensus?
@rhh2348 ...maybe this option is what you want? Alter...
By benson , 1 day ago
-
RE: Free Ecoheat Heat Pump Install
@old_scientist This does make the unit smaller as the b...
By dgclimatecontrol , 1 day ago
-
RE: Ecodan - Legionella Operation Time and Target Temperature
@old_scientist hiya mate, did you ever get to the botto...
By 9jwr9 , 2 days ago
-
RE: Configuring third party dongle for Ecodan local control
@majordennisbloodnok I think the HPDHD diagnosis may be...
By Sheriff Fatman , 2 days ago


