British Gas versus Octopus: Two possible heat pump routes - how to evaluate them?
@lucia just seen your message. Well the octopus saga continues as I have just had to have a resurvey as they were concerned about the pipe run not having enough drop, no explanation as to why but I presume this is so the system drains properly? And no proposal as yet though Stu said he would note my request for 45C. However he then talked about the volumiser having water at 60C!! (Seriously!) I said "oh has it an immersion then? " He must have realised what he had said and changed the subject!
Daikin 6Kw ASHP.
MG4 EV
1926 Semi with loft and wall cavity insulation, all radiator.
Posted by: @jancoldwill upgrade more radiators myself so I can run way cooler than 50C.
Why pay an installer company to rip you off and hide behind a grant. Then pretend they are giving you a great deal. You can DIY an ASHP install for around £4k with a couple of new radiators, obviously more if changing them all and the plumbing.
Posted by: @AnonymousWhy pay an installer company to rip you off and hide behind a grant. Then pretend they are giving you a great deal. You can DIY an ASHP install for around £4k with a couple of new radiators, obviously more if changing them all and the plumbing.
I would think this would be beyond the skills of most householders. My install just finished and it took them about 25 person-days and having observed what they did there is no way I could possibly have dreamed of doing this myself. You may be right that they are charging handsomely for their work, but at the moment the supply of the necessary skills is far lower than the demand, so they are naturally pricing their skills accordingly. I'm not happy about the price I paid, but the solution is a massive increase in the number of people who know how to design and fit ASHPs. I suspect it is only the likes of BG, Octopus and Aira that are going to make that happen.
@johnmo It appears you do not value expertise or experience. Do you put your own fillings in your teeth? I think not, you pay an exorbitant rate for a few pence worth of filling material and get an expert to install it 😊
It takes a lot of work to design, size, and select the correct equipment for the installation. All this has to be paid for but is unseen.
Director at Heacol | Expert Heat Pump Consultant | Book a one-to-one consultation for pre- and post-installation advice, troubleshooting and system optimisation.
Posted by: @heacolIt takes a lot of work to design, size, and select the correct equipment for the installation. All this has to be paid for but is unseen.
While what you say is true Brendon, I would agree with @johnmo,, that with a decent science background, research and a few practical diy skills, a sucessful heat pump install isnt beyond a person. this I can vouch for myself as can Glyn Hudson with his excellent youtube videos.
When you weigh that against the lottery of finding a good installer, it doesnt sound so crazy, and then if anything goes amiss in the future you are in an excellent position to sort things out yourself and save even more.
I've lost count of the money I have saved, doing the things that are normally considered outside the realms of the ordinary person and done them very successfully too as evidenced by professionals/tradesmen complementing me on them (even offering me a job!).
House-2 bed partial stone bungalow, 5kW Samsung Gen 6 ASHP (Self install)
6.9 kWp of PV
5kWh DC coupled battery
Blog: https://thegreeningofrosecottage.weebly.com/
Heatpump Stats: http://heatpumpmonitor.org/system/view?id=60
However he then talked about the volumiser having water at 60C!! (Seriously!)
Lol.... he's talking nonsense. 😂
I'm looking forward to hearing about what they come up with.
I'm still going round in a few circles comparing the Octopus radiator spec with the Centre Radiators spec from Wolsley. They don't seem to tally. It's quite possibly me getting confused so will post the two in a bit. I'm just trying to make sure there's enough wiggle room for dropping the flow temp later.
I had top-up loft insulation installed yesterday - good - and had trickle vents and extractor fans forced upon me - new building regs for retrofitting.... 😏
Posted by: @heacol@johnmo It appears you do not value experience or experience. Do you put your own fillings in your teeth? I think not, you pay an exorbitant rate for a few pence worth of filling material and get an expert to install it 😊
It takes a lot of work to design, size, and select the correct equipment for the installation. All this has to be paid for but is unseen.
But sorry I am not buying it. We are not talking rocket science here. Matching a heat source to heat demand isn't hard (yet many companies still oversize heat pumps a lot). Matching emitters to room heat loss isn't hard. Yes it takes some time. Piping design requires looking at and may require some fundamental changes.
But when people are being asked to pay several thousand on top of a £7500 grant, for a system that runs at 50 degrees, so the installer doesn't have to change radiators or do much in the way of piping design, it's taking the Micky.
Yes I value expertise, but it's nothing to do with filling teeth, you don't need 7 years degree level and above education, to design a domestic heating system to work at low temperatures. Compare apples with apples.
Posted by: @heacol@johnmo It appears you do not value experience or experience. Do you put your own fillings in your teeth? I think not, you pay an exorbitant rate for a few pence worth of filling material and get an expert to install it 😊
It takes a lot of work to design, size, and select the correct equipment for the installation. All this has to be paid for but is unseen.
It takes a lot of work to design a Power Station or something similar, whereas a domestic heating system is not beyond the bounds of a reasonable DIY'er, and would probably be done with greater care and attention.
After the first few systems, any decent installer should have a very good assessment of what equipment is required, without the need to spend hours in the design and specification process.
Perhaps it would help to distinguish expertise from experience. Expertise is valuable in most circumstances. Experience is only valuable if coupled with a degree of expertise and both analytical and critical faculties, in particular the ability to be self critical and challenge the norms, particularly when technology transitions are taking place. In the absence of these necessary complementary factors, experience is a drag on productive development.
Unfortunately the heat pump industry seems to be significantly lacking in expertise. Of course that's a gross generalisation and there clearly are many good guys out there who have taken the time to upskill and question the practices that have become embedded, but there are far too many reports of installations which have been botched for predictable reasons, and of proposals for system designs which defy rational analysis.
Even more unfortunately the heat pump industry has a crutch in the shape of MCS, the existence of which (in its current form) means that, so long as the design by numbers 'rules' are followed, the installer appears to be more or less bomb proof however poor the performance and overpriced the product.
If the good guys want the industry to lose its current poor reputation, they need to build expertise, eliminate the crutch, and become dominant by reputation.
Of course there will always be DiYers who, like @johnmo (and me if I could be bothered, a position I may yet be forced into by the industry) are entirely capable of designing a system for themselves as well, if not better, than many of those currently in the industry. The industry should embrace those, not be frightened by them. They will contribute ideas, perform experiments, and are not in any way a threat, because they represent a small minority. Better still they will enthusiastically advocate for the technology and, if the industry got its act in order, the industry itself. But instead of embracing the competent DiY ers, the industry (by which I principally mean MCS) excludes them by writing planning regulations which demand MCS as a condition of PD rights!
This could, in the currently early adopter phase, be a win-win both for those who wish to and have the capability to do 'DiY', and for an emerging industry. Sadly its currently a lose-lose.
What is getting in the way of growing up? Once we identify it, it needs to be massively reformed or eliminated.
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
Posted by: @AnonymousYou can DIY an ASHP install for around £4k with a couple of new radiators, obviously more if changing them all and the plumbing.
I agree. There are several heat pump DIYers here on the forums who have done an outstanding job with their ASHP installations. It’s definitely doable for some, and they’ve saved quite a lot of money in the process and have very efficient systems. However, the reality is that many people simply don’t have the required skillset or the confidence to take on such a large project. Personally, I struggle to change a kitchen tap, let alone tackle plumbing an entire heating system.
Buy Bodge Buster – Homeowner Air Source Heat Pump Installation Guide: https://amzn.to/3NVndlU
From Zero to Heat Pump Hero: https://amzn.to/4bWkPFb
Subscribe and follow our Homeowners’ Q&A heat pump podcast
Posted by: @jancoldMy octopus survey has just been completed and he has put a note on my survey that I requested a 45C design temp so they are listening? Out of interest his heat loss calc was 5.25 kW as BG was 3.46 kW! and Heatpunk gave me 4.9 Kw.
Have Octopus recommended a unit yet?
Buy Bodge Buster – Homeowner Air Source Heat Pump Installation Guide: https://amzn.to/3NVndlU
From Zero to Heat Pump Hero: https://amzn.to/4bWkPFb
Subscribe and follow our Homeowners’ Q&A heat pump podcast
-
Vaillant arotherm plus heat pump frost protection
4 months ago
-
Daikin Octopus installation update - I saw my first defrost. 😍😂
4 months ago
-
Daikin Error Code 7H05
6 months ago
-
Vaillant aroTHERM plus not level or flat - what base is best under an external unit?
6 months ago
-
Vaillant Arotherm monobloc error f.788 - ASHP is not working!
7 months ago
- 22 Forums
- 2,073 Topics
- 45.5 K Posts
- 66 Online
- 3,353 Members
Join Us!
Trusted Installers
Struggling to find a reliable heat pump installer? A poor installation can lead to inefficiencies and high running costs. We now connect homeowners with top-rated installers who deliver quality work and excellent service.
✅ Verified, trusted & experienced installers
✅ Nationwide coverage expanding
✅ Special offers available
Latest Posts
-
RE: Solar Power Output – Let’s Compare Generation Figures
Well we finished this month with an all time record! Ev...
By Andris , 7 hours ago
-
RE: 5 Star Service from Havenwise
Oh good! I was wondering when/if you might pick them ...
By Transparent , 9 hours ago
-
RE: Air Changes per Hour - ACH and the MCS requirement
update - my old installer insisted on a heat loss of 11...
By MatWin , 10 hours ago
-
I agree it's not very helpful. Generally, the max heat ...
By Old_Scientist , 12 hours ago
-
RE: Commencing on an ASHP Installation Process
I think therein lies the problem. Ratio of quotes to i...
By JamesPa , 1 day ago
-
RE: Why Your MCS-Certified Installer Might Not Be As Competent As You Think
Hive and most other smart thermostats don't play well w...
By JamesPa , 1 day ago
-
RE: Enabling WiFi: Samsung ASHP on Smart Things App
Thanks for the input. I've been running various experim...
By Grahamh-uk , 1 day ago
-
RE: Radiators downstairs are cooler at the bottom after ASHP install
@melonbuffet Hi, this sounds great is you are getting 5...
By ASHP-BOBBA , 2 days ago
-
RE: Ripped Off: How UK Homeowners Are Paying Gas Prices for Wind Energy
I believe there's another reason that network upgrades ...
By Transparent , 2 days ago
-
RE: What’s the modern take on advised types of insulation?
@jeff I am sorry @jeff if I have misunderstood what you...
By Toodles , 2 days ago
-
RE: Getting the best out of a heat pump - is Homely a possible answer?
@editor Cobbler’s Mantra that!
By Toodles , 3 days ago
-
RE: Renewables & Heat Pumps in the News
Australia Blue, the first wind farm in Western Victoria...
By Morgan , 3 days ago
-
RE: Flow rate discrepancy between ASHP and manifold
That's useful thanks, I hadn't seen that table before. ...
By AshRolls , 4 days ago
-
In principle I agree, @johnmo, but with provisos. The...
By Majordennisbloodnok , 4 days ago
-
RE: Heat pump installation and BUS Grant timings
@jamespa Thats how I understood it too. 🙂
By ASHP-BOBBA , 4 days ago
-
RE: Antifreeze top up for my heat pump - is this a rip off?
@sallyl That sounds about right if they are re-filling ...
By Brendon Uys , 5 days ago
-
I wouldn't be so sure about that. Heat pump designers ...
By JamesPa , 5 days ago
-
RE: Jokes and fun posts about heat pumps and renewables
@toodles they're a rowdy bunch!
By Mars , 6 days ago
-
RE: Home energy storage & battery register
@jamespa To a certain extent, by exporting to the grid ...
By Toodles , 6 days ago
Members Online
No online members at the moment