I've been running the system now on weather compensation only for a few weeks and as I said before, it's working well for us. Some of that time I've had the heating running 24/7 and some off for 5 hours 12-5am. I've messed around a bit with the HW but we use so little at the moment (electric showers and dishwasher) it should make little difference. This is the story so far
Blue is running the ASHP 24 hrs a day, red is 5am to midnight. I removed a couple of early outliers from when I was experimenting. An exponential trend is the best fit. You can see that at the colder end, it makes a difference with the heating off at night; at the warmer end less so. I think this is because when it's cold, having the ASHP off for 5 hours makes a big dent in overall consumption. This is offset a bit by a big peak at 5am to heat the flow from cold but not completely. When it's warmer the overnight consumption is low, so not so much saved and at 5am the ASHP still has to raise the flow from room temperature to its target.
The other thing to bear in mind is that I don't force the house to warm up; it does it as and when with the weather compensation flows. If I were using auto adaptation I think the flow temp would increase until the house warmed up, which would give me a warmer house but lessen any saving from having the 12-5am break. We're happy with this as we don't want the house too warm at night. (We also have TRVs on the bedroom radiators that we can adjust if we want.)
What I'm going to do next is try something I've never done, which is to use a fixed flow temperature of 45C and control the house via the thermostats. This is something a lot of people do with ASHPs and how some suppliers set up new installations. The next week or so looks quite benign for weather so an ideal time. I'm willing to experiment but don't want to bankrupt myself. I'll set both my zones for 21C constantly and I'll leave the heating off 12-5am as I've been doing most recently. I'll put the thermostats where the temperature is most stable, i.e. not in the hall/kitchen. I'll plot the results on the chart above and see what I get.
Any predictions? Mine is that it will cost me more! My average flow temp is about 35C to bumping it to 45C is going to make a difference. What I'm not sure about is the effect of the thermostat switching the ASHP on and off but we'll see.
Posted by: @kev-mAny predictions? Mine is that it will cost me more! My average flow temp is about 35C to bumping it to 45C is going to make a difference. What I'm not sure about is the effect of the thermostat switching the ASHP on and off but we'll see.
I did a similar experiment but using a 50ºC flow. That used 930kWh over 30 days vs 855kWh using the compensation curve. Both 30 day periods had an average 6.4ºC ambient outside temp.
Posted by: @kev-mAny predictions? Mine is that it will cost me more!
I would agree. Also, thanks for keeping this thread updated, very useful data.
I wonder what your current weather compensation curve is set to?
Doesn't seem to making a huge difference. Couple of kW?
Here are the results of my experiment to compare (1) Weather compensation only and (2) Constant flow temp and thermostats. Both methods kept the house at c. 21C and switched the heating off 12-5am.
The weather compensation method seems to use less energy. If you look at some detail, you can see why.
The weather compensation energy use is very steady, apart from a blip due to HW. The thermostat energy use is much more variable. The flow is allowed to cool several times and it takes a lot of energy to raise the temperature. 100 on the left scale corresponds to 6kW.
In terms of 'feel'; the thermostat method results in noticeable rises and falls in room temperature with radiators varying between hot and cold whereas with weather compensation the room is more constant and the radiators are always warm.
The house warms up in the morning a little quicker using the thermostats. However, my previous experiment showed that I could leave the weather compensation method running all night at very little increased cost.
In terms of COP, my actual COP is showing as 7.1 (weather comp) and 5.4 (thermostats). I don't believe these numbers (someone is coming today to investigate) but their relative sizes are probably right. If I said 3.55 and 2.7 that might be believable.
Anyway, I'm convinced by weather compensation and I've now gone back.
Any requests for further experiments? 😉 I may try bumping up the weather compensation curve a couple of degrees and letting the thermostats limit the room temperature as a bit of a compromise.
I have one of those and still await delivery of the Mitsubishi wireless receiver unit. When i arrives the intention is to swap out the Heatmiser Neostat the installer thought was preferable.
Retrofitted 11.2kw Mitsubishi Ecodan to new radiators commissioned November 2021.
I thought you were getting the full monty wireless controller. This is just a room thermistor. I have to wire this in to the main FTC6 control box and mount it in the living area. I can then use the wired in controller in the airing cupboard to control the temperature. This is the cheap (£16.99) version!
- 25 Forums
- 1,513 Topics
- 31.8 K Posts
- 24 Online
- 1,283 Members
Join Us!
Latest Posts
-
RE: Additional Battery v Wind Turbine v Ripple
I should add, being an investment, the value of your in...
By Old_Scientist , 7 hours ago
-
RE: Ecodan - flow rates, sensors, settings
Achieving an accurate flow measurement is probably the ...
By Derek M , 11 hours ago
-
RE: Ecodan ASHP - How to optimise my set up?
Again, thank you for another thorough post, @derek-m - ...
By rhh2348 , 13 hours ago
-
RE: Delivering a smart and secure electricity system: government consultation
@Transparent.Now that I am represented by a new MP I th...
By IanMK13 , 15 hours ago
-
RE: Vaillant aroTHERM plus not level or flat - what base is best under an external unit?
Similar thread here
By Johnmo , 15 hours ago
-
RE: VDI 2035 heating water specification
Been looking and it seems a good little project. Ever...
By Johnmo , 2 days ago
-
RE: Do I accept an ASHP and Solar Panel retrofit under the HUG 2 scheme?
Will do. I'm currently waiting for another survey / vis...
By dssr , 2 days ago
-
The company that did the borehole were expecting us to ...
By Johnmo , 2 days ago
-
-
RE: The Misquote That Ruined the Heating Industry
@abernyte manufacturer training is pretty average. They...
By Mars , 2 days ago
-
-
RE: ECO4 Scheme and EPC ratings
@mellow Thanks. Given there is a scheme requirement to ...
By Old_Scientist , 3 days ago
-
RE: Do I just go with the lowest quote for my heat pump?
@jancold To me its a no-brainer then, a max 40C flow te...
By bontwoody , 4 days ago
-
-
RE: Heat Pump Books Beginners – Bodge Buster & From Zero To Heat Pump Hero
@editor Presumably he had some good weather Compensatio...
By Toodles , 4 days ago
-
RE: New Vaillant 7kW aroTherm ASHP or oil boiler dilemma/decision??
Storage capacity really is dependent on storage tempera...
By Johnmo , 4 days ago
-
RE: HP Cycling, Expected or Undesirable
Just a little update. I ordered a longer shielded twin ...
By bontwoody , 4 days ago
-
RE: Domestic hot water timer doing crazy things on my Grant Aerona3 10kW air source heat pump
Thanks @allyfish for the pics and info. Spoke to the in...
By Mellow , 4 days ago
-
RE: Aira Heat Pump: Stylish Scandinavian Heating
It's been a busy day for calls and emails from Aira. I ...
By MikeH , 5 days ago
-
RE: Heat Pump Servicing & Maintenance – Good Value or Rip-Off?
Hmm. A bit of a nuanced answer, methinks. As I've alr...
By Majordennisbloodnok , 5 days ago
Latest Topics
-
Ecodan - flow rates, sensors, settings
By rhh2348 13 hours ago
-
Replacing mains water with well water
By Johnmo 2 days ago
-
Additional Battery v Wind Turbine v Ripple
By bontwoody 2 days ago
-
By jamespipe 3 days ago
-
VDI 2035 heating water specification
By Johnmo 3 days ago
-
Do I just go with the lowest quote for my heat pump?
By Jancold 5 days ago
-
The Misquote That Ruined the Heating Industry
By Alec Morrow 6 days ago
-
Battery Storage Wiring Gauge Question
By Puff 6 days ago