Heat Pump sizing - Further adventures of a boiler owner
A couple of weeks ago I posted a graph of the gas consumption of my boiler versus heating degree day (HDD) that I created over eighteen months ago (here). Since I’ve learned quite a bit in the period since I originally created the graph, I decided to repeat the process for intervening years. I changed my approach this time, creating a separate plot covering the whole of each heating season rather than for a calendar year. I used weather data from my weather station to calculate local HDD data using the method detailed at degreeday.net using a base temperature of 15.5°C as derived by degreeday.net’s regression tool (which use my local airport’s HDD data). To validate my newly-calculated data and methods, I repeated my earlier plot. The trend lines were almost identical - y=12.784x+13.485 and R2=0.9237 this time against y=12.822x+13.658 and R2=0.9236 previously. My other new plots are as follows
It can be seen that 2021-22 was a relatively mild winter with the daily average temperature barely clipping 0°C on a couple of occasions. This was not the case in 2022-23; the second week of December and the third week of January being particularly cold (several degrees below zero). 2023-24 also had its share of cold days, although not quite as bad as the previous year. The boiler struggled this year as I had downrated the boiler and reduced the flow temperature at the beginning of the heating season. I was also playing with pump speeds and monitoring flow temperatures but was unable to come to any conclusions; I suspect the TRVs were affecting the situation. I also experimented with having no overnight setbacks last year.
My interpretation of the plots and trendline equations:
- It looks like I may have turned-down my DHW thermostat in 2022.
- There was quite a cold spell when I was away on holiday in October last year (Heating and DHW turned off). On checking, daily average temperatures dipped into single figures during my time away.
- It’s not clear that my experiments at turning-down the boiler have been successful in monetary terms. Comparing the trendlines for 2021-22 and 2023-24 (cf y=mx + c), m is greater for the later year but I don’t believe it is fully offset by the reduced value of c.
- It appears as though I need a 10-11kW heat source - but only for 2-3 weeks per year. A 7kW source would suffice at other times
Bearing in mind the disadvantages of a 10-1kW ASHP (in particular, the size), are there other viable options that merit consideration? Two smaller ASHPs? A gas hybrid heating system? How would radiator requirements be determined for a hybrid system?
I have seen suggestions of using auxiliary electric heaters when it is only a matter of perhaps 10 - 15 days during a full winter season. Might this cover your needs?
Thanks to failures of British Gas to orchestrate prompt repairs when we were still heating with gas, we have two very compact 1 or 2 kW fan heaters plus a convection heater we bought years back. These all stand by in readiness for such occasions - though the Daikin 8 kW keeps us cosy at -7 or -8 degrees as we experienced last Nov/Dec for a few days. Regards, Toodles.
Toodles, he heats his home with cold draughts and cooks his food with magnets.
@ianmk13 Perhaps have a word with @davidalgarve 😉 Perhaps he could put you up! Though I should avoid Valencia area at the moment - they seem to have some flow problems.Toodles.
Toodles, he heats his home with cold draughts and cooks his food with magnets.
@toodles Are you going into competition with Booking.com? What are your commission rates?
I am rather occupied at the moment, with a big Birthday, a hip replacement operation and a cataract operation due. Otherwise OK!
@davidalgarve I’ve done several ‘big birthdays’ had cataract surgery (and much more too!) but still have my original hips! My commission rates are (behind hand in front of mouth - mumble mumble.)😉 Toodles.
Toodles, he heats his home with cold draughts and cooks his food with magnets.
Posted by: @toodlesI have seen suggestions of using auxiliary electric heaters when it is only a matter of perhaps 10 - 15 days during a full winter season. Might this cover your needs?
There is sometimes quite a good argument for this and many heat pumps do have the capability to drive electric heaters inline. Check actual specs at design temp & FT, eg Vaillant 7kW is actually 8.6 at -2 and 45, but quite a few heat pumps only give their rated output at a rather restricted range of conditions.
That said the Mitsi 11.2kW R32 unit (and the R290 when they release it doubtless) or the Samsung 12kW unit arent much bigger than eg a Vaillant 7kW so consider these (or other manufacturers ) if they fit in space/noise envelope. Ideal also do single fan higher capacity pumps, sourced I think from Midea (the R290 ones anyway).
Remember the BUS requires that the unit can cover the entire heat load, but it seems that 'the unit' includes (at least according to the interpretation of some installers) any linked backup heater.
Finally how are you estimating your boiler efficiency. It could be more than 100% (up to 110%) if its actually condensing (most don't because FT is set too high) or 75% if its very old. This makes quite a difference to the conclusion.
2xheat pumps is of course possible, but you wont get it in under permitted development and it will cost a lot in ancillary kit which installers will want to put in, and there will be installers that wont touch it. Personally I wouldn't go there at 10-12kW, there are some perfectly good reasonably sized (ie single fan) solutions in this range.
Put these into the mix and you should be able to find a comfort spot. Feel free to ask more particularly as you move towards a conclusion. Then of course you have to persuade an installer to take notice of real measurements, which many wont (but some will).
As a word of warning - there are those (perhaps the majority if you include installers) who dismiss the 'what does my boiler use' method due to the uncertainties in boiler efficiency and how the boiler is used. MCS only formally recognises the fabric spreadsheet (although I do somewhere have an email from MCS recognising that it has limitations for retrofits). So you are a bit out on a limb relying on boiler measurements. That said its what I am doing for my install (which, following 2 years of hassle with planning, is now hopefully going to happen in the next couple of months).
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
-
Installing your own ASHP - DIY
5 days ago
-
ASHP install contract and BUS grant money
2 months ago
-
High air source heat pump running costs – Vaillant AroTherm Plus
2 months ago
-
Savings - using Weather Compensation & Time of Use Tariffs
2 months ago
-
Heat Pump starting current
3 months ago
- 22 Forums
- 2,043 Topics
- 44.5 K Posts
- 59 Online
- 3,264 Members
Join Us!
Trusted Installers
Struggling to find a reliable heat pump installer? A poor installation can lead to inefficiencies and high running costs. We now connect homeowners with top-rated installers who deliver quality work and excellent service.
✅ Verified, trusted & experienced installers
✅ Nationwide coverage expanding
✅ Special offers available
Latest Posts
-
Here is an analysis of the rads proposed excluding the ...
By JamesPa , 7 hours ago
-
RE: Massive Electricity Cost for Running My Air Source Heat Pump
I agree @mark-h The Building Regs are now very readable...
By Transparent , 11 hours ago
-
RE: Help me understand my Mitsubishi Ecodan system
@carpenterstation When changing settings in the ser...
By RobS , 11 hours ago
-
RE: Getting the best out of a heat pump - is Homely a possible answer?
Cynically I would suggest its there to protect the inst...
By JamesPa , 18 hours ago
-
RE: Ecodan Legionella cycle - immersion heater problem
Thanks for letting us know @clockworks I admire your ...
By Transparent , 1 day ago
-
@fillib what a wonderful result, both for you personall...
By Judith , 2 days ago
-
RE: Revised version of MCS-020 (noise standards for heat pumps)
As you say this is no change, which I personally think ...
By JamesPa , 2 days ago
-
RE: What happens when the outside temperature exceeds the upper WC point?
@editor not via the WC curve but as @old_scientist ment...
By bontwoody , 2 days ago
-
RE: MHHS and Heat Pump compatibility
@toodles to be clear I don't know if there will be a re...
By Scalextrix , 2 days ago
-
I did not know this concept, although others might. I...
By Morgan , 3 days ago
-
RE: Help me keep the faith with my air source heat pump installation
@adamk it's probably filtering different providers in t...
By Mars , 3 days ago
-
RE: why solar diverters for HW instead of the heat pump?
I should probably add to my comments above that, whilst...
By JamesPa , 3 days ago
-
RE: Commencing on an ASHP Installation Process
Lots of reading and questioning which the background ma...
By JamesPa , 4 days ago
-
RE: The Great British Heat Pump Quiz
Not sure how that happened 🤣 I suspect that it ...
By Mars , 4 days ago
-
RE: Help with understanding my Mitsubishi Ecodan air source heat pump
@patch I think @ashp-bobba gave you some great pointers...
By SUNandAIR , 4 days ago
-
RE: Installing your own ASHP - DIY
Hi @tomasmcguinness, how are you progressing with this?...
By Ashfp , 5 days ago
-
RE: Say hello and introduce yourself
Welcome to the forum. If you are new to ASHPs I sug...
By JamesPa , 5 days ago
-
RE: The Rise and Fall of Europe’s Most Generous Green Subsidy
This is where the cold water storage tank was situated;...
By Dwynwen , 6 days ago
-
RE: Air Source Heat Pump - Side Alley Suitability
Thats probably fair enough. The degree-days calculatio...
By JamesPa , 6 days ago