What is the most im...
 
Notifications
Clear all

What is the most important factor for you when choosing a heat pump brand? Poll is created on Jul 10, 2024

  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  

What is the most important factor for you when choosing a heat pump brand?

31 Posts
9 Users
32 Reactions
2,235 Views
(@elton)
Estimable Member Member
480 kWhs
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 49
 

@judith Samsung - thinking back on my post about the research I did on the "Visit a Heat Pump" site, comparing Mars's pretty reasonable estimate of the proportion of brands in circulation vs the proportion of brands folk are happy to show off. 

Samsung (which are of course mainly Gen 6s) didn't come out well. Disproportionately few owners seem to want to sing the praises of their Samsung for whatever reasons.


   
👍
1
ReplyQuote
(@judith)
Honorable Member Member
2549 kWhs
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 298
 

Posted by: @elton

@judith Samsung - thinking back on my post about the research I did on the "Visit a Heat Pump" site, comparing Mars's pretty reasonable estimate of the proportion of brands in circulation vs the proportion of brands folk are happy to show off. 

Samsung (which are of course mainly Gen 6s) didn't come out well. Disproportionately few owners seem to want to sing the praises of their Samsung for whatever reasons.

I was thinking of your analysis but I couldn’t recall who pointed it out and hence sorry I couldn’t give you credit. Sorry!

There have been other strings about more noise complaints in particular very “tuneful” (or harsh) from Samsungs too.

 

2kW + Growatt & 4kW +Sunnyboy PV on south-facing roof Solar thermal. 9.5kWh Givenergy battery with AC3. MVHR. Vaillant 7kW ASHP (very pleased with it) open system operating on WC


   
👍
1
ReplyQuote
(@johnmo)
Prominent Member Member
2299 kWhs
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 422
 

Just been looking at the vote, it is interesting that people have voted more for efficiency than almost anything else.

Why interesting?

Because nearly every heat pump on the market (R32 and R290) have almost the same CoP for like for like temperature. It's not the heat pump that makes an efficient system, it's the system design (low flow temperature) and operation (no thermostats opening closing big or small parts of the system), setbacks and having to run the system harder to catch up the next day. A heat pump, diverter valve, hot water cylinder, and a single zone (in nearly all cases) heating system is all you need. Correctly setup you can leave it to run all year with zero intervention.

Maxa i32V5 6kW ASHP (heat and cooling)
6.5kW PV
13.5kW GivEnergy AIO Battery.


   
👍
2
ReplyQuote
(@elton)
Estimable Member Member
480 kWhs
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 49
 

@judith Thanks Judith. 

Yes, as well as Samsungs (Gen 6's) featuring more in noise issues than others, and not something folk want to seem to show off. Also a heat pump engineer I spoke to said that they tend to be noisier than others.

I'm pretty sure the latest (Gen 7) models are better.

I have a two-pronged theory about Gen 6's:

1. that Gen 6's do indeed have harsh tonality. No data has been published from Samsung for tonality (it isn't required) but government and CIEH reports/guidance on noise state tonality is key issue and there is a suggestion for an adjustment (punitive) included on MCS020, which would bring it in line with BS4142 (greater alignment between MCS020 & BS4142 being essential to avoid the Planning/Env Health grey zone).

I'd favour any heat pump that isn't supplied with tonality data having +3 to 6dB(A) added to the SWL for MCS020 - it is a recognised nuisance factor.

2. that the "The highest sound power level specified" for Gen 6's - declared in manufacturer info & used in MCS020 - is not the highest sound power level.

The Welsh Govt Ph2 report and DESNZ report (and others) calls out the issue of a lack of standardisation in figures declared - that suppliers can be under-declaring SWL noise levels by as much as +8dB(A). This is more likely if the dB(A) level declared on the ErP energy label is the same as the max SWL declared & used for MCS020 (see Page 14 DESNZ report& the Annex 51 report) and this is the case for eg the Samsung AE120 - the declared dB(A) is indeed the ErP label dB(A).

Just theories. Would like to hear if anyone feels these are valid or otherwise?

 

 


   
👍
2
ReplyQuote
(@elton)
Estimable Member Member
480 kWhs
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 49
 

Just as a side note, I can see Visit a Heat Pump now has the numbers of brands on the site which is very helpful (on the right hand side of any search, and searching from any location will show all heat pumps registered on the site).

Total numbers on the site:

Mitsubishi 89

Daikin 82

Vaillant 71

LG 21

Samsung 19

Midea 18.

Samsung WELL under-represented.

Probably not unreasonable to say that Mitsubishi, Daikin and Vaillant owners are around 4x more likely to show their units off than Samsung owners. I do think it would be worth researching why.


   
👍
2
ReplyQuote
Mars
 Mars
(@editor)
Illustrious Member Admin
26280 kWhs
Veteran
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 2986
Topic starter  

@elton That’s very interesting and definitely worth delving into further. Just a general observation, I tend to see Mitsubishi, Daikin, Vaillant and Samsung as the most popular and commonly installed heat pumps in the UK. So, it is interesting to see Samsung lagging behind the others on "Visit a Heat Pump."

I’ve said this several times, but Samsung is dead to me as a brand based on our experiences with them, especially regarding our fridge, which honestly isn’t fit for purpose. Their customer service and attitude were awful. I wonder how much of that poor customer service extends to their heat pump installations and support.

Buy Bodge Buster – Homeowner Air Source Heat Pump Installation Guide: https://amzn.to/3NVndlU
From Zero to Heat Pump Hero: https://amzn.to/4bWkPFb

Subscribe and follow our Homeowners’ Q&A heat pump podcast


   
👍
1
ReplyQuote



(@elton)
Estimable Member Member
480 kWhs
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 49
 

@editor Yes. I would think it would be valuable for someone to have a serious look at this "is it Samsungs?" question. Could be potentially that they (or Gen 6's) are a weight around the ankles of national rollout, or maybe not. I think there's enough there to warrant research.

If it is verified that a disproportionate number of noise complaints and other heat pump gripes prominent in the media are more prominent in Samsungs then its something that can be fixed or worked around, rather than it acting as a drag chute on rollout, tarring all heat pumps with the same brush.


   
ReplyQuote
(@lucia)
Honorable Member Member
1646 kWhs
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 255
 

@editor @elton Er, guys correlation is not causation - in these two self-selecting public fora - visit a heat pump & open energy - the brands are meaningless. 

Even OE performance says more about the geekery and effective system design and maintenance than anything much about HP brand. 

I wouldn't draw any conclusions from them. 


   
ReplyQuote
(@elton)
Estimable Member Member
480 kWhs
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 49
 

@lucia I can't agree with that conclusion. Why can't a brand or model-based conclusion be made if the evidence stacks up? If there is an issue more prominent with one model or brand, that can quite easily be causation and correlation.

As for self-selecting fora, it is striking that so few Samsungs are present in a sample of 300+ units. Can't just be explained as irrelevant.


   
ReplyQuote
(@lucia)
Honorable Member Member
1646 kWhs
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 255
 

Correlation does not equal causation. Fundamental rule of data analysis. You can't repeat that line then argue it does, sorry. 😁

OE & Visit a Heatpump are fab resources but do not equal evidence by any valid definition of the word 'evidence'.

There is no 'evidence stacking up'. 

These things tell you nothing about brands. In fact one of the co-founders of Open Energy, Glyn Hudson, is a proud Samsung owner. That guy knows his stuff. 

There's also dozens of happy Samsung heat pump owners around the world showing off on YouTube. 

Self-selection is a huge problem for any kind of analysis. Whatever or wherever it is. 
No study of brands would be considered evidence without being undertaken under very similar conditions be that system design, installation or location. And even then you would have to have a randomised control group to actually make it valid. 

I literally stalked a guy called Matt on OE who had big problems with an over-sized Daikin. It wasn't a Daikin problem it was a system design problem. He had the HP replaced with a smaller one along with more/bigger radiators and he's now near the top of the Scops. I learned a lot from his journey but not too much about Daikin. 

I have often heard experts say that heat pump brands are more or less irrelevant with the important key factors being system design, installation and running. 


   
ReplyQuote
(@johnmo)
Prominent Member Member
2299 kWhs
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 422
 

Posted by: @elton

@lucia I can't agree with that conclusion. Why can't a brand or model-based conclusion be made if the evidence stacks up? If there is an issue more prominent with one model or brand, that can quite easily be causation and correlation.

As for self-selecting fora, it is striking that so few Samsungs are present in a sample of 300+ units. Can't just be explained as irrelevant.

Look for a Maxa heat pump you will not find one, you may find a Viessmann, but due to cost not many. But the Viessmann unit was made and designed by Maxa. I have one, it's runs well, doesn't produce much in the way of noise, has many variables you can change. It's performance is good.

But why would I want anyone I don't know coming around my house?

I agree @lucia drawing a conclusion from meaningless information in, rubbish out is a bit pointless.

 

Maxa i32V5 6kW ASHP (heat and cooling)
6.5kW PV
13.5kW GivEnergy AIO Battery.


   
ReplyQuote
(@johnmo)
Prominent Member Member
2299 kWhs
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 422
 

Posted by: @lucia

have often heard experts say that heat pump brands are more or less irrelevant with the important key factors being system design, installation and running. 

Can agree with that. Best ASHP ever made is limited but thermodynamics, so all are very similar performances wise. System design can be simple and efficient or not, that can change on every install. That is the variable.

Maxa i32V5 6kW ASHP (heat and cooling)
6.5kW PV
13.5kW GivEnergy AIO Battery.


   
👍
1
ReplyQuote



Page 2 / 3



Share:

Join Us!

Heat Pump Dramas?

Thinking about installing a heat pump but unsure where to start? Already have one but it’s not performing as expected? Or are you locked in a frustrating dispute with an installer or manufacturer? We’re here to help.

Pre-Installation Planning
Post-Installation Troubleshooting
Performance Optimisation
✅ Complaint Support (Manufacturer & Installer)

👉 Book a one-to-one consultation now.

Latest Posts

x  Powerful Protection for WordPress, from Shield Security
This Site Is Protected By
Shield Security