Joining the Renewable Heating Hub forums is completely free and only takes a minute. By registering you’ll be able to ask questions, join discussions, follow topics you’re interested in, bookmark useful threads and receive notifications when someone replies. Non-registered members also do not have access to our AI features. When choosing your username, please note that it cannot be changed later, so we recommend avoiding brand or product names. Before registering, please take a moment to read the Forum Rules & Terms of Use so we can keep the community helpful, respectful and informative for everyone. Thanks for joining!
Then the above comment caught my attention because theres several instances of LFP batteries causing fires or explosions.
I'll certainly look into it, but from past experience (the Gayton marina fire) Pat tends to run rather fast and loose with the facts. The video in the link you posted had so far as I could tell no hard facts at all on the cause of the fire. That said, videos are a PITA to evaluate, especially talking heads, but the search transcript function has some use:
I think the transcript is AI generated and so might (will) have errors, but even so it on first looks that LFP video doesn't mention LFP batteries...
They earn their income by providing training and consultancy on dealing with all manner of faults, fires and explosions. That's bound to provide a bias in their approach.
Indeed, and it is not a trivial bias. It's called wet your pants, or fear based marketing. His treatment of the Gayton narrow boat fire was nothing if not sensational EXPLOSIVE:
I'm going to have a look at his treatment of Will Prowse's alleged latest conclusions, and what Prowse's actual latest conclusions are. Â
Midea 14kW (for now...) ASHP heating both building and DHW
This is why I said "I think the transcript is AI generated and so might (will) have errors".
This page claims to describe how youtube captions (which I think includes transcripts) are generated, and yes, AI is involved, so of course the transcripts must be accurate. At the same time, we have all seen captions/transcripts where there have been tedious, silly and comic errors.
Midea 14kW (for now...) ASHP heating both building and DHW
Indeed, and it is not a trivial bias. It's called wet your pants, or fear based marketing. His treatment of the Gayton narrow boat fire was nothing if not sensational EXPLOSIVE:
I gave up listening to this sort of stuff years ago. Its obvious that people selling fire related services (training, extinguishers, risk assessments, consultancy etc) will talk up the risk of fire, picking on any new situation they can to 'highlight' the 'problem'. Its become a major industry that, so far as I can see, continually looks for new ways to make money. The latest I have heard is that fire doors now need to come with a 'fire rated frame' (so, for a retrofit, you have to replace both the door and the frame). How convenient!Â
I do, however, listen to what fire brigades say, because they are not selling services.Â
You might levy the criticism of 'looking for new ways to make money' at the electrical industry except that the regulations clearly state that equipment that is not to latest regs only has to be replaced when work is anyway being done on that equipment, so my plastic encased CU is fine until I do major work on it, as are the countless fuse boxes that are doubtless still out there.
But clearly these batteries came into the market without much safety related research being carried out.
This simply isn't true. Lithium ion batteries in general and LiFePO4 batteries in particular have be subject to very severe stress testing, and for the latter, no one, so far as I know, has ever got one to spontaneously ignite or explode. They have even been seen to survive, albeit badly scorched, at the epicentre of a fire/explosion. Â
I was looking for any feedback on the Eleven batteries and Watson brought up this thread. Then the above comment caught my attention because theres several instances of LFP batteries causing fires or explosions.
We have to be very clear about what we are saying here. Take my sentence:
Lithium ion batteries in general and LiFePO4 batteries in particular have be subject to very severe stress testing, and for the latter, no one, so far as I know, has ever got one to spontaneously ignite or explode.
Breaking it down into two sentences/paragraphs we get:
Lithium ion batteries in general and LiFePO4 batteries in particular have be subject to very severe stress testing.
For LiFePO4, no one, so far as I know, has ever got one to spontaneously ignite or explode.
or to make it less clumsy:
No one, so far as I know, has ever got a LiFePO4 to spontaneously ignite or explode.
Now I think that is still the case. But let's look in more detail.Â
Will Prowse (who I have a lot of respect for) says there are '4 Recorded Cases of Explosion' (NB this is just explosions, not fires and explosions) and this is the transcript from the relevant youtube video (at around 7 minutes in):
Now, I'm pretty sure I've seen every single LFP video for fire or explosion on YouTube because everyone sends them to me. And when it comes to explosion in the fire studies, I've only seen about four and that's out of tens of millions of installations.
So, it's crazy that this doesn't happen more often. These create hydrogen and we have ignition sources everywhere. So, why aren't these things exploding more? And how does Underwriters Laboratory and CEC approve stuff not have explosive mitigators? Maybe the standards need to be revised or maybe it's just such a low risk that they admit it. I really don't know. I don't know how fire standards are created.
Now, when there is an explosion caused by LFP, it is catastrophic. The first example is this one in Germany where a house completely blew up.
Next one happened last year in a small electric boat. And this one had a lot of media coverage. The cells vented and then it accumulated and then it exploded and it blew all the windows and doors off the boat.
And the last example is one that was mentioned a lot last week from Stashd D training. It was a small shed outside of a house and they had nice Discover batteries. And in that instance, after investigators ruled out all other possible causes, they blamed the batteries. And it kind of makes sense with how it exploded. You can see what's going on here.
Now, the fourth and last example is the CL subsidiary factory explosion in 2021. But in that one, they say the explosion was caused by a low temperature and equipment issue which raised the pressure of an exhaust tower and led to a valve failure, which doesn't seem like an LFP explosion, but it's an LFP battery factory. So, there was a failure and it caused an explosion.
So, those are my four examples. I haven't found any others.
Now, four out of tens of millions is not a lot, and furthermore, as he himself points out, he is likely to get to know of incidents. Maybe there are others, maybe (probably) not.
I will look into the four known incidents, and post my findings here when I have them.