Joining the Renewable Heating Hub forums is completely free and only takes a minute. By registering you’ll be able to ask questions, join discussions, follow topics you’re interested in, bookmark useful threads and receive notifications when someone replies. Non-registered members also do not have access to our AI features. When choosing your username, please note that it cannot be changed later, so we recommend avoiding brand or product names. Before registering, please take a moment to read the Forum Rules & Terms of Use so we can keep the community helpful, respectful and informative for everyone. Thanks for joining!
Seriously considering switching to an ASHP but...
Back in early 2024 I adapted my central heating system to see how feasible an ASHP would be as a boiler replacement. That's how long I've been sat on the fence for.
We live in a 200m2 detached 4-bed property built in 1997 to our own specifications. All of our radiators are K2 types (apart from one in a utility room) and are quite well sized because (as usual) the contractor didn't have a clue and, as I was paying for it, just over-spec'd everything. This has allowed me to bring the flow temperature down to a weather compensated range of 30C-50C and comfortably maintain a delta of 20K at absolute worst-case through two-and-a-bit winters so far. It's a recently sealed-system boiler with a DHW storage cylinder but unfortunately that's still vented. I converted the pipework from Y plan to S plan and use a priority DHW program so I've also been able to monitor and log energy usage independently from DHW. Long term analysis of heating energy vs. deltaT gives the house a Heat Transfer Coefficient of 320W/K so even with (to my mind a silly) 23K design temperature, an ASHP of 7.4kW would be required. Indeed, the boiler has been range rated down from 30kW to 10kW and is never on at over 70% duty factor so confidence in this is high.
However, so much for the empirical testing...
1) If I build my house again with Heat Punk, with living room temperatures set to 20C, and with the MCS postcode lookup, the design for -3C (at the 99%ile) calls for 8kW and flags half our radiators as undersized. This means I'm likely to disagree with a 'professional' survey which is not a good start.
2) Then there's the (nearly new) vented DHW cylinder. It's likely to be given the chop in any ASHP design on account of the reheat time although the Coil Rating of 23 kW doesn't sound like a problem to me. But I see no sensible way of routing a PRV discharge without surface mounting pipework through bedrooms. This also keeps me awake at night in one of those rooms. Along with...
3) The whole strategy of merging zones and eliminating individual TRV's in ASHP designs: While my own heating regime is to keep the house at one fixed temperature, with no night setback, I do use smart TRVs to keep bedrooms a degree or two cooler during the day so that it's only 18C at bedtime but 20C first thing in the morning. If it was fixed at 18C like the designs seem to recommend then 'quality of life issues' would soon emerge.
4) Similarly I have a 20m2 garden room built on the end of the house in 2022 which, while being a fully-insulated warm-roof design (fully double low-E glazed), the three exterior 'walls' are constructed entirely from a mix of sliding patio doors and floor-to-ceiling fixed glazing units. While built better than some conservatories it still leaks 2kW at sub-zero temperatures. This room has our one-and-only underfloor heating zone which can be zoned off if I to choose to do so now and then. I may be wrong but I don't think this fits in with the ASHP philosophy (the room is fully outside the main insulated building envelope and closed-off with the original DG patio doors so isn't necessarily an energy burden - except for keeping it frost free). I can see a MCS compliant ASHP design bringing this permanently in-circuit. Which also goes wrong in the other direction of solar gain in the shoulder months when I most certainly have to zone off the floor while the rest of the house is being heated (partly from the garden room!).
5) One of the main sticking points has to do with energy tariff: I already make good use Octopus of Cosy to run some A/C units in ancillary buildings and time-shift all building electricity consumption by recharging 10kWh worth of batteries from both Solar PV when available and from AC as often as three times a day in winter. This is way too little capacity to have an ASHP as an additional battery load so would need to be blinded from the inverter but leaves the full spark-gap for the equivalent of more than 2/3rds of the day. Given that the current gas heating is running asynchronously, I can't see how a similarly sized ASHP could operate without taking us into the penalty payment zone (4PM-7PM). I find this a particularly difficult thing to model.
6) And then there's the gambling aspect: Who seriously would have imagined the UK with 40C summers a decade or two ago? Maybe the climate researchers - but that's not my point. The climate has empirically demonstrated that it can move fast when it wants to. Eyes are also on the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) and how rapidly that might alter the climate in Northern Europe and the UK in the opposite direction. With ASHP, the design tolerances are exceptionally tight with penalties stacked-up for both under and over sizing. No such constraints apply to the fossil burning alternatives (particularly the ones that can do 10:1 modulation).
7) And this leads me onto my final, off the top of my head, observation: Any realistic cost for the installation of an ASHP in my house in addition to the BUS grant is going to be somewhere in the £3k-£6K region. A figure that I think compares closely with a replacement gas boiler. But the big difference is that with the grant, we're looking at a capital investment well North of 10K. Now if that chunk of money is sat out in the rain 24/7 it's going to have to keep it's end of the bargain for a very significant length of time. As a retired couple, finding the full unsubsidised replacement cost would probably signal the end of a lovely life in this house. And that worries me a lot.
I cordially invite any feedback on any of these points that might help us make a decision and sleep better at night.
-
7.5kW Heat Loss, But Quoted a 10kW Midea. No Re-Pipe, No Buffer Tank. Does This Add Up?
7 months ago
-
Bosch CS5800i 5kW - Experience So Far
10 months ago
-
My Octopus Cosy 6 Heat Pump Journey: From Quote to Completion
1 year ago
-
Yes, the "zoning with ASHP" topic again...
2 years ago
-
My British Gas – Heat Force ASHP Installation: A Frustrating Experience
2 years ago
- 27 Forums
- 2,825 Topics
- 67.1 K Posts
- 1,690 Online
- 7,244 Members


