Notifications

Clear all

Minimum ASHP outputs?

tomasmcguinness · 2024-10-15T15:13:59Z

As I'm getting closer to my own ASHP installation, I've started looking at particular models, which I think will be the most suitable. My heat loss is around 312W/k or 7.5kW at -3. Outside temp did hit -5 this winter, so a little head room would be nice, but nothing we couldn't weather (pardon the pun). Heating needs to go on when it's 12 or less outside. My gas boiler can keep the house warm with a 30 ish flow when it's that temp outside. Might work with an even lower flow temp, but due to the boiler being stupidly oversized, it would just cycle like crazy. That means I'm looking for a modulation range of around 2.8kW to 7.5kW. I'm really struggling to find a source for that information. Plenty about *max* outputs, but not a whole lot about minimum outputs. Mick Wall shared some Polish documents on the Vaillant aroTHERM:It shows that a 35/30 flow would result in a min output of 3.5 when it's 12 outside. As the flow temp increases the min output lowers and at 55/47 it's 2.6. The COP drops a lot of course. I can't seem to find anything about minimum outputs for the Samsung Gen 7 for example. Would anyone have an experience with that kind of modulation range, willing to recommend a particular heat pump?

Page 3 / 3 Prev

Air Source Heat Pumps (ASHPs)

Last Post by SUNandAIR 11 months ago

28 Posts

12 Users

9 Reactions

3,529 Views

RSS

IanMK13

(@ianmk13)

Reputable Member Member

Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 194

23/10/2024 4:31 pm

Posted by: @sunandair

↑

So to summarise:- Of the 365 days of the year our heat pumps will try to operate for 160 days at less than 20% capacity. (If they can cope with the modulation, that is.)

On the other side of the coin - although not the subject of this topic - the heat pump will operate at greater than 80% capacity on only 12 days. Although an installer can be expected to design a system capable of meeting the heating requirements on these days, other influences are likely to lead to over-specification. Without over-specification, the customer may be prepared to accept a handful of days when heat pump is struggling (e.g. to avoid a planning application, avoid a double-fan unit, avoid radiator replacement, etc). This is a variant of the '80/20 rule' - 80% of what you want for 80% fewer issues.

ReplyQuote

RobS

(@robs)

Estimable Member Member

Joined: 11 months ago

Posts: 55

23/10/2024 5:32 pm

Posted by: @sunandair

↑

Posted by: @robs

↑

What was the total output capacity of your radiators at a flow temperature of 30C? Is it less than the minimum output of your heat pump at 30C flow temperature?

At a 21kw combined rad load

30c LWT = 1.785kw total output

35c LWT = 3.47kw total output

The first issue I recall, was to notice that the manufacturers correction charts do not go down low enough or fine enough to take account of 5c circuit DT (temp drop) and 30c LWT.

...

So after a bit of trial and error I was left thinking the 30c outlet temperature at under 2 kw output it was the reason for the cycling we encountered.

Yes, your figures correlate well with your heat pump having a minimum output of about 3kW at these outside temperatures. Have you tried your heat pump at a 34C flow temperature?

ReplyQuote

SUNandAIR

(@sunandair)

Noble Member Member

Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 501

23/10/2024 8:38 pm

Posted by: @robs

↑

your figures correlate well with your heat pump having a minimum output of about 3kW at these outside temperatures. Have you tried your heat pump at a 34C flow temperature?

At first I tried 32c for about 10days. It was ok but still cycling a bit too much. So I took it straight to 35c.

But you make a valid point. A small reduced flow temp, by 1 or 2 degrees, may give improved efficiency without increased cycling.

I will do this and let you know how I get on. Thanks for your useful observations.

ReplyQuote

SUNandAIR

(@sunandair)

Noble Member Member

Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 501

25/10/2024 9:48 am

Behaviour of compressor is subtly different as flow temperature is dropped to 34 and 33c. The original lowest flow temp of 35c as set on weather compensation which was the set flow temp for all outdoor Ambients 10c and above.

At 34c the cycling increases to 4 per hour with short 5 minute pauses.

At 33c the cycling drops to 3 per hour but the temperature drop appears to be done by creating longer pauses of 10 minutes.

In all cases the flow temperature still registers 35 or 36c. It appears to use variable pauses in operation to reduce the average energy input to 33c.

This operation seems to still be within acceptable Mitsubishi operating tolerances.

To clarify, these graphs are from a radiator only system with a total RAD DT50 capacity of 21kw. Which is greatly reduced to 3.4kw when operating at flow temp 35c. These graphs are specific to our setup and not necessarily typical.

This post was modified 11 months ago 2 times by SUNandAIR

ReplyQuote

Page 3 / 3 Prev