Legionella cycle: Heat Pump or Immersion Heater?
Hi,
I've had my Grant ASHP for about 6 months now, and am slowly adjusting the set-up to hopefully more reasonable values.
Initially, DHW was set to temp of 55°C to run at 05:00, 11:00, and 15:00 (each for 1 hour), with a separate immersion heater element also running for an hour each Monday at 01:00 (for legionella sterilisation I assumed).
I've gradually reduced this until now I have it running from 15:00 to 16:00 only, set to 45°C, with the legionella cycle now running at 16:00 on Monday, directly after the ASHP has finished heating the water to 45°C.
My thinking now is that the immersion heater element runs at COP of 1 (at best); and the HP runs at COP of 1 (at the very worst) so it actually makes more sense for the HP to do all of the legionella work i.e. on Mondays set the DHW to 60°C (the maximum it will permit) for 1 hour at 15:00, and no longer use the immersion heater at all.
Does this seem reasonable? I also think that 60°C is possibly too high, and something like 58°C would be fine. At the moment the HW is at about 58°C by 17:00 on Monday, and stays above 55°C until almost midnight. That seems more than adequate to kill legionella (over 55°C for 7 hours).
Grant Aerona 3 10kW
Posted by: @mikeflMy thinking now is that the immersion heater element runs at COP of 1 (at best); and the HP runs at COP of 1 (at the very worst) so it actually makes more sense for the HP to do all of the legionella work i.e. on Mondays set the DHW to 60°C (the maximum it will permit) for 1 hour at 15:00, and no longer use the immersion heater at all.
Does this seem reasonable? I also think that 60°C is possibly too high, and something like 58°C would be fine. At the moment the HW is at about 58°C by 17:00 on Monday, and stays above 55°C until almost midnight. That seems more than adequate to kill legionella (over 55°C for 7 hours).
When I was looking at legionella cycles a while back, I found a lot of variation in opinion regarding how often to run the cycle. Regs say one thing, others point out that the bottom of traditional cylinders rarely if ever reaches the required temperature. The actual temperature and duration required to kill the bacteria though was pretty much consistent.
If you can reach the required temperature using your heat pump then yes it makes a lot more sense to use it rather than the immersion coil. The only exception I can think of to this is if you have solar panels and a diverter, which essentially will do it for free (or a loss of export)
House-2 bed partial stone bungalow, 5kW Samsung Gen 6 ASHP (Self install)
6.9 kWp of PV
5kWh DC coupled battery
Blog: https://thegreeningofrosecottage.weebly.com/
Heatpump Stats: http://heatpumpmonitor.org/system/view?id=60
Posted by: @bontwoodyIf you can reach the required temperature using your heat pump then yes it makes a lot more sense to use it rather than the immersion coil. The only exception I can think of to this is if you have solar panels and a diverter, which essentially will do it for free (or a loss of export)
For what its worth Vaillant R290 heat pumps (I discovered a few weeks ago) are designed to do the legionella cycle in the heat pump only, and appear (unlike many other HPs) not even to be capable of controlling the immersion. So thats the decision Vaillant made once they got to the point of having a FT high enough.
I have a Grant ASHP and have the HW output from it set at 60degC for 75 minutes daily. This will charge my 250litre pre-plumb Grant cylinder to 55degC usually within 1hr, and it maintains this temperature for many hours if no hot water is drawn off. It's more thorough at heating the cylinder than the built in 3kW immersion. If I use the immersion the built in immersion thermostat starts to cycle on and off but the tank content thermostat never reaches above 54degC. The immersion stat is set to it's highest setting, supposedly 65degC.
Also, the tank contents cool much more quickly with no hot water drawn off compared to when I heat using the ASHP. That to me proves that the immersion heating is not very thorough. I have more faith in the ASHP providing better Legionella protection daily to 55degC than the 3kW immersion weekly to 54degC! The ASHP heating coil is lower down than the immersion element and a much larger surface area.
The ASHP will give a CoP of 2-2.5 in heating, so is much more energy efficient than the immersion. I have solar PV+battery and a diverter. Initially I thought using the diverter would be most cost effective, but charging the battery using solar, and then using it to power the ASHP is more economical. I'm using less than half kWh than direct immersion, and can export more surplus PV that way at 15p/kWh. 'Every little helps!' 😀
-
HOT TIP - DHW Cylinder Thermostat
10 months ago
-
Why run a disinfectant cycle ?
2 years ago
- 24 Forums
- 1,419 Topics
- 29.8 K Posts
- 44 Online
- 1,205 Members
Join Us!
Latest Posts
-
RE: Noise problems with newly installed Samsung 8kW ASHP
Thanks for all the responses. The general consensus see...
By Lokisam , 1 min ago
-
RE: No-code, plug-and-play monitoring for your heat pump
Thanks for highlighting this product, @editor. It's an ...
By Majordennisbloodnok , 3 mins ago
-
RE: Ecodan software update. Real or scam?
@Morgan then that looks legit to me, because the people...
By Mars , 10 mins ago
-
RE: Say hello and introduce yourself
@irmartini Oh! That’s a great shame.😳 Toodles.
By Toodles , 38 mins ago
-
RE: Is this a bad installation and is there something wrong with my Samsung heat pump?
@david999 On the subject of isolation after the battery...
By HughF , 6 hours ago
-
RE: Bivalent (or even trivalent!) system design options for a new GSHP installation
As it's DC, then it's already rectified 😉 So...
By Transparent , 15 hours ago
-
RE: New Fogstar 15.5kWh upright solution
@robl I've added the screens. Li-Bms screen is accur...
By GGW , 17 hours ago
-
RE: SCOP and seasonal variations
I’ve had a long chat with Aaron from Homely Technical S...
By Toodles , 20 hours ago
-
RE: Gas Combi to ASHP - Making sense of survey results and proposal.
Many thanks to everyone who has helped with advice and ...
By IRMartini , 1 day ago
-
RE: What is Wrong with our Heat Pump Installation?
With BESS the ASHP is best. Charge battery for free fro...
By AllyFish , 1 day ago
-
@hubb84 Try looking at powerflushassociation.com. They ...
By Toodles , 2 days ago
-
Central heating inhibitor with ASHPs
Have you seen the Heat Geek article and video?
By ChickenBig , 2 days ago
-
RE: Advice on potential HW Cylinder size
@jwilliams89 I would imagine that the MCS would insist ...
By bontwoody , 2 days ago
-
RE: Creating a second zone on Mitsubishi Ecodan ASHP
Had another go at this, the morning. With SW2-7 ON it ...
By BryanB , 2 days ago
-
RE: Samsung ASHP scheduling help
@morh Your post was music to my ears! I am getting a ...
By Elgreco69 , 3 days ago
-
RE: Issues with Vaillant connectivity via the MyCONNECT gateway
@drew-pa I have given up on the app - right now it is s...
By dr_dongle , 3 days ago
-
RE: ASHP Advice: High Temperature vs. Low Temperature Heat Pump For Microbore
Hi - we have a Daikin 16kW HT ASHP installed which was ...
By Marzipan71 , 3 days ago
-
RE: Question about Ecodan's Room Autoadapt mode
@gary Thanks. I'm emboldened to give it a go!
By afarmery , 4 days ago
-
RE: My ASHP is not performing as well as I’d hoped: COP just over 2
@toodles No. But I wasn't forced there either and The K...
By Morgan , 4 days ago
-
RE: Viessmann Vitocal 250-A in the UK
We have a 10Kw Viessmann 200A it SCOP is currently 5.2,...
By MikeF , 4 days ago
Latest Topics
-
Ecodan software update. Real or scam?
By Morgan 3 hours ago
-
Noise problems with newly installed Samsung 8kW ASHP
By Lokisam 2 days ago
-
Central heating inhibitor with ASHPs
By IRMartini 2 days ago
-
Advice on potential HW Cylinder size
By JWilliams89 3 days ago
-
By Graeme 4 days ago
-
Interesting heat pumps installations
By Mars 7 days ago