Question about Ecodan's Room Autoadapt mode
Hi, I’m after some advice from anyone with experience and knowledge of the Ecodan ‘Room Autoadapt’ function.
I have an Ecodan 5kW ASHP and UFH in an old granite farmhouse. We did our best to internally insulate the ground floor walls, but I imagine it’s still a bit leaky. The installer fitted 3rd party (Heatmiser) stats and commissioned it to run according to the stat setting. I didn’t like this, and wanted to avoid the stop-start and high flow temperatures, so I set the stats to 21C as a temperature limiter, and slowly calibrated the weather compensation curve. We’re in far west Cornwall where it almost never freezes, and I ended-up setting the curve at 32C flow temp @ 0C outside) and 21C flow temp @ 15C outside. This maintained the internal temperature at between 19 and 20C (in Jan Feb and March), and if the energy monitoring on the FTC6 can be believed, the COP was over 6, which I was vey pleased with.
I wanted to be able to control the Ecodan remotely, and have the option of adjusting the curve so that the house was at say 15C when unoccupied, and adjusting it back up a few days before going down there. I thought that I might be able to do this with Melcloud, but disappointingly the curve cannot be adjusted with Melcloud. The only option was to use the Room Autoadapt mode, which can be adjusted remotely via Melcloud. I understand that this control system automatically adjusts the curve to supply a weather appropriate flow temperature in order to achieve the set room temperature.
I duly set this up (it involved me having to buy and fit a remote temp sensor and receiver, and a Wifi adapter, which to my astonishment I manged to do!). Autoadapt seems to work as advertised, i.e. it fixes the room temp at the value I set it to be (19.5C, as before) but I am puzzled to note that the flow temperatures are now between 30 and 35C (when outside temp is about 9C), way higher than when I was running on the ‘manual curve’.
In my manual curve, the pump ran low and slow, and for much of the time. Now, it seems ot run hotter and for shorter periods (we’ve had a lot of solar gain recently which has shut it off). This doesn’t sound like a very efficient way to run it, and I doubt I’ll be getting a COP of >6 like before. Should I abandon Autoadapt and go back to manual curve, or is this normal and acceptable?
Thanks for any advice,
In short yes auto adapt works very well but will sacrifice efficiency as you have noted, it runs hotter as it’s trying to achieve the room temp set as fast as possible unlike weather compensation that doesn’t care what the room temp is.
Thanks Gary for that succinct reply to my rambling question. I'll try it for a bit and see how it goes. It's a shame their isn't an option for either 'tight' or 'relaxed' set-point control. But hey ho! At least I now have a remote control option.
Posted by: @afarmeryThanks Gary for that succinct reply to my rambling question. I'll try it for a bit and see how it goes. It's a shame their isn't an option for either 'tight' or 'relaxed' set-point control. But hey ho! At least I now have a remote control option.
There is a time interval adjustment that I believe does have an effect upon the rate of response.
Posted by: @afarmeryThanks. If you're able to point me to where I can do this in the app, I'd be grateful.
A.
I'm not certain if you can access this setting via an app, you may need to use the menu in the controller.
If you look in the manual under 'Operation settings > Heating operation > Room temp. control > Interval'.
Thanks Derek, I managed to download a manual where it states that the 'interval' default is 10 minutes, but can be increased to a max of 60 minutes. It says it can be adjusted to suit the emitter type (radiator, thin concrete, thick concrete, wood) but it fails to state exactly which interval is suited to which emitter type. Intuitively I'd guess that rads might require it set to 10 mins, and UFH with thick concrete might require a longer setting, but it would have been helpful if they'd have spelled this out unabiguously (and this is true for pretty much every other poorly explained thing in the manual!)
@afarmery I would start by setting it to 60mins and if the controller isn't reacting quick enough to maintain the desired room temperature keep lowering it until you are happy.
I may be long but the longer interval you can get away with the more efficiently it will run as it won't react to aggressively.
I have mine on 60mins with radiators but the radiator in the room with the main controller is quite a distance away and it is in the hallway open to the stairs so a large space to heat up.
@ajdunlop Thanks for this. I'll give it a try. At around the same location in the menu there's the option to alter the min and max flow temperature too. Defaults are 30 and 50C respectively. Do these need tweaking too (I've got UFH)?
I have mine set to 25C (although I doubt my system can really do much at that temperature due to undersized radiators) and 45 degrees (as much above that and efficiency really suffers).
If you have UFH it is likely you will need lower temperatures. Is there any blending valves at your manifolds. I wouldn't have thought there was any point the max being much higher than the temperature they are limiting to. Others would know better as my system is all rads.
Thanks. Not sure about mixing valves. But when I ran my system on the manually set curve, I had it at 32C when outside temp was 0, and 21C was outside was 15, and that kept the house at about 19.5C., so I reckon I can go down on the temps in autoadapt mode too. It's worth a try.
If you really were getting a COP of 6 in Feb using WC mode then I'd be wondering if there is any benefit to changing to AA mode if it proves to be less effecient for your particular setup. AA mode is an auto-learning mode so it needs time and a range of temperature operations to learn from – it should increase its efficiency eventually, but we have not had a lot of cold weather since Jan so it is likely to be missing that part of its records for the moment.
I found when I changed from WC to AA that it was more efficient overall, but I do see a choppier graph as the unit tends to push the flow temp up before it switches off for a period and just circulates the water (I get such cycling when its above 4° outside).
You can set flow temps as low as 20° in the settings - but if yours is still the default 30° then that might suggest that your curve is not actually setting the flow temps in the way you think it has been! You need a temperature gradient of a few degrees to enable transfer of heat into the slab and the heat pump is also going to raise the temperature of the return flow by 3–5° so a target flow of 21° is not realistic for a room temperature of 19-20°, the differences are too small.
Where a target flow of 20° might be useful is in holiday mode. This can be switched on and off in the app so perhaps this is a better way of reducing running time and energy consumption when the house is unoccupied. I have struggled a bit with holiday mode myself and it has not quite done what I was expecting so I can only offer ill-informed opinion here, but as the target room temp is ignored in WC mode I presume the target flow temp is the one that would prevail. Whether 20° is best is a matter of trial and error but your figures suggest it might.
Mitsubishi EcoDan 8.5 kW ASHP - radiators on a single loop
210l Mitsubishi solar tank
Solar thermal
3.94kW of PV
- 21 Forums
- 1,811 Topics
- 39 K Posts
- 92 Online
- 2,123 Members
Join Us!
Latest Posts
-
ASHP for small garage and workshop
Hello everyone, Just joined the forum and have chipped ...
By BobTSkutter , 8 minutes ago
-
@lucia It would be interesting to know the volume of yo...
By BobTSkutter , 28 minutes ago
-
RE: Is My Midea Heat Pump Inherently Defective?
Sadly I think you are right, until someone develops a c...
By JamesPa , 1 hour ago
-
RE: Is it crucial to get flow temperatures with heat pumps right?
... in theory! If they are all (close to ) perfectly ...
By JamesPa , 1 hour ago
-
RE: How much radiator capacity do I need for an air source heat pump?
Follow-up: it occurs to me that the difference between ...
By Simonwhiteley , 2 hours ago
-
RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan ASHP general set-up and efficiency
@gary Agreed, installer needs to look. I did up the op...
By ngillam , 2 hours ago
-
RE: Can you work an ASHP too hard?
I agree - I think a heat pump is more of a marine diese...
By cathodeRay , 3 hours ago
-
RE: Adding data centre electricity costs to domestic energy bills?
Meant to add this but have been buried under piles of w...
By Lucia , 5 hours ago
-
RE: The Definitive Guide to Weather Compensation and Curves for Air Source Heat Pumps
@judith thanks…. Every day a school day. tomorrows le...
By SUNandAIR , 5 hours ago
-
RE: The good, the bad and the not that great – my heat pump installation
at the bottom of our installers invoice it said we were...
By NetDonkey , 6 hours ago
-
RE: Samsung E911 intermittent issue
Just a quick update. It looks like it may be the actua...
By NetDonkey , 10 hours ago
-
RE: What to Expect During Your First Winter with a Heat Pump
I wish I had known about you before I had the pump fitt...
By Richard Smith , 11 hours ago
-
RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan 8.5kW Monobloc (FTC5) Defrost Mode
@cold123456 appreciated this thread dates from a while ...
By AlsoCold123456 , 12 hours ago
-
RE: Controversial opinions - pure weather compensation, buffer tank, heat loss, oversized heat pumps
That is really interesting what you mentioned about con...
By benson , 12 hours ago
-
RE: R290 install location and future of R32
@toodles thanks for that toodles. I was hoping you migh...
By SUNandAIR , 1 day ago
-
RE: Totally bewildered with my ECO4 heat pump installation
Do you have a Sensocomfort? it looks like
By Judith , 1 day ago
-
RE: Say hello and introduce yourself
Mars hello there. I plan to go air to water and then i...
By BobTSkutter , 1 day ago
-
@transparent We had one chappie from SGN call at the do...
By Toodles , 1 day ago
-
RE: Reusing existing radiators
@chandykris just give them a good wash out before fitti...
By bontwoody , 1 day ago
Latest Topics
-
ASHP for small garage and workshop
By BobTSkutter 8 minutes ago
-
By ChandyKris 1 day ago
-
Nibe heatpump comms error when freezing
By Toody 2 days ago
-
Is this normal behaviour for my samsung ashp
By wawyed 3 days ago
-
Can you work an ASHP too hard?
By Simonwhiteley 3 days ago
-
By IRMartini 3 days ago
-
R290 install location and future of R32
By AndrewJ 4 days ago
-
hum/whine from Wilo circulation pump
By grumpidoc 5 days ago