Ecodan Minimum Run Time, Flow & COP
We have an 11.2KW Ecodan with an FTC6, installed 2022 with a 300l HW tank and 10 circuits of Wundasmart underfloor heating in around 120 sqm, installer (who was generally great) left every circuit thermostatically controlled.
We spent a lot of time learning about the system over the last year, and one quirk of the Ecodan is a minimum run time which it imposes on itself and the impact on flow temperatures. After conversations with Mitsubishi, this is called the Compressor On Guard Strategy, which enforces a 20 minute minimum runtime, unless the Superheat has been >10C for 10 minutes. It took us a long time to find out from Mitsubishi that this existed.
It doesn't matter a lot what the above means, but the effect - a minimum run time - is interesting. Normally if the pump's minimum heat delivery is higher than the demand, then during low flow conditions (e.g. only a few thermostats calling for heat) the flow temp rises and the pump will turn itself off when flow exceeds 5C above the compensation curve set temperature. In our case, with flow around 27C that might be when flow hits 32C, cunsuming around 1KW of energy.
However the Ecodan will prioritise the importance of keeping on running over halting when exceeding the flow temperature, and will keep trying to heat the water while it keeps running. The compressor runs harder and harder as the temp spirals and we were recording 55C flows at which point it turned off. This incurred very high energy consumption (3KW or more).
This had a huge impact on the COP, dropped below 3 during mild weather. During cold weather it's never a problem, there's always enough flow because so many circuits are calling for heat and minimum runtimes are over 20mins anyway.
We contemplated adding a buffer (cost around £1K installed) but instead trialled removing all thermostatic control in all rooms except the coldest one and using full system volume all the time with the compensation curve driving the system. The result in mild weather is dramatic: we can keep flow temps at 23C above 13C outside, the pump cycles twice an hour with max flow never exceeding 5C above set flow temp, Melcloud-reported COP is regularly over 5 and often over 6, it appears to be phenomenally efficient, borne out by much lower daily energy usage in mild weather.
We do have some small challenges with some warmer rooms getting a couple of degrees C above what we'd prefer but it is cheaper to just live with the extra heat, cost goes up if we re-introduce any thermostatically control rooms, because the volume reduced and pump works harder as above. Our Wundasmart manifolds use automatic balancing valves which set the circuit flow dependant on flow/return temps and can't be manually adjusted down, which is an unfortunate side-effect of an automated system.
The lesson learned is that Ecodans and lots of thermostats really don't work well in mild weather and it's much cheaper (and generally nicer) to go to the effort of working out the right compensation curve and running low flow temps against your full system volume.
Might be useful to anyone with an Ecodan, lots of thermostats and seeing big spikes in flow temps and energy consumption several times an hour during mild weather.
Rod
Posted by: @rodMight be useful to anyone with an Ecodan, lots of thermostats and seeing big spikes in flow temps and energy consumption several times an hour during mild weather.
Rod
Welcome to the forum and thank you for the detailed report. I must admit that I was not aware of the Compressor On Guard Strategy, which I don't believe is mentioned in the manual.
Your findings about thermostats is not only relevant to Ecodan owners, but probably all heat pump owners.
Very interesting. My (14kW) ASHP can definitely run the compressor in bursts of less than 20 minutes when in heating mode. It doesn't do it very often and only when in WC mode and mild conditions. It never heats to more than one or two degrees above WC set point though, although I have only two zones, which means the ASHP is heating at least half my house at any one time. Interestingly, although the compressor stops after less than 20 minutes, I don't think it is ever in heating mode for less than 20 minutes. That is, it spends some time in heating mode while delivering no energy.
This is heating you're talking about btw - the label on the graph on your attachment mentions DHW?
I've never heard of Compressor on guard or Superheat; it's not mentioned on the manuals afaik.
@derek-m if you skim through this Samsung doc, you will see details how a double compressor "heat pump"/AC works, some of this data is pointless to anyone but the engineers that need to look(improve/make a new model) at the machine beyond checking the refrigerant charge.
@kev-m Yes, it's in heating mode. For reasons I still don't understand the HP can spin up to do a DHW cycle when the tank temp is very close to setpoint and cut out immediately the set point is reached without entering the On Guard strategy, even if it's only a couple of mins long. Mitsubishi could not explain why the strategy is used for heating but not for water.
This stuff definitely isn't in the manual and isn't generally known to the support teams, it was only when I pressed them that this appeared.
Thanks fazel, much appreciated.
I suspect that the training manual is for industrial type units, since the smallest compressor of a twin compressor unit is rated at roughly 19kW, and each compressor in the main unit is rated at 25kW. I don't think that it would get planning permission. 😋
Nevertheless the manual appears to give a good description of the inner workings of a heat pump, which is very similar, if not exactly the same, as a domestic sized unit.
- 22 Forums
- 2,047 Topics
- 44.6 K Posts
- 44 Online
- 3,274 Members
Join Us!
Trusted Installers
Struggling to find a reliable heat pump installer? A poor installation can lead to inefficiencies and high running costs. We now connect homeowners with top-rated installers who deliver quality work and excellent service.
✅ Verified, trusted & experienced installers
✅ Nationwide coverage expanding
✅ Special offers available
Latest Posts
-
RE: Solar Power Output – Let’s Compare Generation Figures
@andris This April was better than the previous two Apr...
By Toodles , 49 minutes ago
-
RE: ASHP Ecodan L9 error - No Heating but Hot Water
@phoenix15, @heacol cover your area… I’d strongly recom...
By Mars , 1 hour ago
-
RE: Warm weather and heat pumps.
@editor Oh nothing right now because $ needed for struc...
By Lucia , 12 hours ago
-
RE: Yes, the "zoning with ASHP" topic again...
@ccap as an aside, I think you pose some interesting qu...
By Mars , 12 hours ago
-
Maybe you could do a video on it please? Ask all the ma...
By Lucia , 12 hours ago
-
RE: Renewables & Heat Pumps in the News
This is from data provided by a serious researcher with...
By Lucia , 12 hours ago
-
@iantelescope - I do appreciate I am becoming something...
By cathodeRay , 15 hours ago
-
RE: Potentially more choice including air to air heat pump grants
@jeff Such documents are far too wordy for my ‘daily re...
By Toodles , 17 hours ago
-
RE: Getting the best out of a heat pump - is Homely a possible answer?
@grahaml I cannot agree that it is a small percentage o...
By benson , 1 day ago
-
RE: Commencing on an ASHP Installation Process
In that case treating it as a separate space seems emin...
By JamesPa , 2 days ago
-
RE: Samsung Gen6 16kW tribulations
@emceed, can you please give us an update on your syste...
By Mars , 3 days ago
-
What's the problem you are trying to solve. The answer...
By JamesPa , 5 days ago
-
Good luck. For what it is worth my system was very def...
By JamesPa , 5 days ago
-
RE: Massive Electricity Cost for Running My Air Source Heat Pump
I agree @mark-h The Building Regs are now very readable...
By Transparent , 6 days ago
-
RE: Help me understand my Mitsubishi Ecodan system
@carpenterstation When changing settings in the ser...
By RobS , 6 days ago
-
RE: Ecodan Legionella cycle - immersion heater problem
Thanks for letting us know @clockworks I admire your ...
By Transparent , 7 days ago
-
RE: Revised version of MCS-020 (noise standards for heat pumps)
As you say this is no change, which I personally think ...
By JamesPa , 1 week ago
-
RE: What happens when the outside temperature exceeds the upper WC point?
@editor not via the WC curve but as @old_scientist ment...
By bontwoody , 1 week ago
-
RE: MHHS and Heat Pump compatibility
@toodles to be clear I don't know if there will be a re...
By Scalextrix , 1 week ago