Notifications

Clear all

Ecodan Melcloud temperature control with compensation curve

marth · 2023-01-29T18:32:24Z

I’ve installed MAC-587IF-E on my Ecodan. When I open the Melcloud app, it shows my Room Temperature -39C. Can anyone suggest where this data comes from? I guess I’m missing a room sensor? As I live in an area where it’s often subzero temperatures outside, I was hoping I could monitor my house temperature via Melcloud when I’m away for extended period. Another disappointment is that Melcloud app seems to only support underfloor heating adjustments when not using “Curve” (weather compensation). When Curve is activated, I still see the slider set at 20C and no matter where I slide it, it doesn’t trigger change to Ecodan. When I change it to Room, the slider works fine and sends the data through. My system is installed with one zone which heats both floors and rooms are manually adjusted by thermostats. Everything works fine and I’m happy with the efficiency. It’s just the lack of control via app. Any advice is much appreciated.

Page 2 / 2 Prev

Air Source Heat Pumps (ASHPs)

Last Post by Morgan 2 years ago

18 Posts

7 Users

2 Reactions

5,414 Views

RSS

Kev M

(@kev-m)

Famed Member Member

Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 1276

12/02/2023 7:39 pm

Posted by: @morgan

↑

Oh @kev-m you star you 😘🤣

@dotty9943 I’m glad you’re on the up 👍

I was fed up of Derek getting all the plaudits, this is just the start for me!! 😆

👍

ReplyQuote

Derek M

(@derek-m)

Illustrious Member Member

Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 4427

12/02/2023 7:43 pm

Posted by: @dotty9943

↑

d. Our radiators were rebalanced last week

Who re-balanced the radiators? Was it done using the lockshield valves? Do you have any TRV's fitted?

e. We have set weather compensation so that flow temperature is at the recommended level

What are the settings of the WC curve?

f. The heat loss study confirmed that our 14 kw is big enough to heat our. House and compensate for the heat loss

What are the heat loss calculations for your home? What type and size is your home?

My web researches don’t suggest any other explanation for poor efficiency so can any one come up with new ideas? Failing that I don’t know what to do short of taking our heat pump out and starting again with an efficient combi boiler

Low efficiency can be caused by incorrect WC settings, also using on - off type thermostats. Having a buffer tank, low loss header or plate heat exchanger can also have a detrimental affect. Do you have any of the above installed?

This post was modified 2 years ago by Derek M

ReplyQuote

Derek M

(@derek-m)

Illustrious Member Member

Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 4427

12/02/2023 7:49 pm

Posted by: @kev-m

↑

Posted by: @morgan

↑

Oh @kev-m you star you 😘🤣

@dotty9943 I’m glad you’re on the up 👍

I was fed up of Derek getting all the plaudits, this is just the start for me!! 😆

I am devastated. 😪

It would appear the 'peasant's are revolting', but then they always have been. Have you been 'eating cake' again? 😋

👍

ReplyQuote

Kev M

(@kev-m)

Famed Member Member

Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 1276

12/02/2023 8:02 pm

Posted by: @dotty9943

↑

@kev-m Now that you have solved the problem of temperature readings, this has enabled me to move on to the next stage of my attempts to find out why my heat pump is achieving such poor COP scores (They are about 2.3 when the predicted score is 3.2 and better. We have done the following without much progress

a. On the basis of the Ecodan recommendations following a heat loss study, we have up graded all our radiators

b. We have replaced doors and windows so that all our doors and windows are now double glazed

c. We have put new thicker insulation in our loft

c. We have put throttles in our chimneys

d. Our radiators were rebalanced last week

e. We have set weather compensation so that flow temperature is at the recommended level

f. The heat loss study confirmed that our 14 kw is big enough to heat our. House and compensate for the heat loss

G. The system was serviced in December, when the filters were cleaned.

My web researches don’t suggest any other explanation for poor efficiency so can any one come up with new ideas? Failing that I don’t know what to do short of taking our heat pump out and starting again with an efficient combi boiler

This is much harder now! A few questions:

Are you letting WC control room temperature or are you using thermostats; either Mitsubishi or 3rd party? Is the ASHP running all the time or is off/cooler some of the time

What sort of flow temps do you have at, say 0 and 5 degrees outside?

Are you including HW in your numbers? If so, how hot and do you use a lot?

Do you have different zones in the house that are on and off at different times, or do you use TRVs a lot?

Do you have a buffer or low loss header?

I have a 14kW Ecodan and my January COP for heating and HW is about 3.1 so far. 2.3 is a bit low but it depends how you are using it.

ReplyQuote

Dotty9943

(@dotty9943)

New Member Member

Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 4

12/02/2023 8:18 pm

@derek-m thanks. The balancing was done by an accredited (by Ecodan) air source heating engineer. I am not sure what a lock shield valve is) but if it is fitted at one end of the radiator, yes. We have TRV valves. The WC curve settings are 45 c/30c

The heat loss calculation was 12KW, since when we have improved insulation

Our House is a 4 bedroom detached house on two storeys, built in about 1920. The floor area is about 240 sq metres, so quite big

ReplyQuote