ASHP insulated pipe under/up through concrete beam & block floor?
I am considering replacing my Viessmann Vitodens 200-W gas system boiler with a Vitocal 200-A Monobloc ASHP. The indoor unit of the ASHP is almost identical in size to the gas boiler. Much of the electronic and plumbing connections should be able to be reused. Great!
Problem: The boiler is in the kitchen at the front of the house and the outdoor unit of the ASHP would need to go in the back garden. How to connect them with Uponor Ecoflex Thermo Twin HP, a large diameter insulated pipe for hydraulic, electrical and electronic connections?
The house was built in 1995 and has a concrete beam & block ground floor. My ideal solution would be to run the pipe under the house and up through a core-drilled hole in the kitchen floor. There is a kitchen unit close to the boiler and if it surfaced under that it would be almost invisible except for possibly some boxing at the back of a cupboard.
The excellent technical support at Uponor suggest that it is technically feasible but cannot identify a contractor that could do the work. They are only aware of contractors that undertake commercial/industrial projects.
The core drilling is feasible (although I don't know the Building Regulations aspects). I know that builders have put basements and wine cellars under existing houses. Others have sprayed thermal insulation under suspended floors. If a drain under my house broke I imaging there would be somebody that could fix it.
I really want to avoid the disruption of moving out furniture, ripping up carpets and floorboards and running large bore, insulated pipes up the outside and through the fabric of the house. If I can't avoid that aggravation I might just scrap the whole project!
With heat pumps set to become a common replacement for gas boilers, insulated pipe connections under the ground floors of houses without basements doesn't seem such an outrageous solution.
Has anyone achieved something similar?
PS. I have asked the same question on Green Building Forum where there have been a few replies. Suggestions for other forums where this question could be answered would be appreciated.
At the risk of not answering the question asked, what is the power output of the proposed heat pump, and how far is it between the external and internal unit? That will (somewhat) determine the diameter of flow and return pipes.
The Uponor pipes look rather bulky (and has a bend radius of 0.5m), with water pipe internal diameter of 25mm (or 26.2mm as it is unclear whether pipe 1 or pipe 2 is for water); that implies a power rating of 3.14*(2.5cm/2)^2 * 80 cm/s * 5 degrees C * 4.2 J/cm^3 = 8200W, or else 9050W assuming a delta-T of 5 degrees C and a desire to keep water speed to 0.8m/s.
I've been thinking about a split system as the best place to site a heat pump is about 15m away from the indoor unit, through a convoluted route. Have you considered a split system? I wonder if having refrigerant lines running through the house itself might be less obtrusive. For instance a 5kW Panasonic generation K bi-bloc heat pump requires 1/4" - 5/8" lines. An additional benefit of a split system is that you don't have to think about anti-freeze valves or (performance reducing) anti-freeze in the pipes.
Posted by: @chickenbigAt the risk of not answering the question asked, what is the power output of the proposed heat pump, and how far is it between the external and internal unit? That will (somewhat) determine the diameter of flow and return pipes.
The Uponor pipes look rather bulky (and has a bend radius of 0.5m), with water pipe internal diameter of 25mm (or 26.2mm as it is unclear whether pipe 1 or pipe 2 is for water); that implies a power rating of 3.14*(2.5cm/2)^2 * 80 cm/s * 5 degrees C * 4.2 J/cm^3 = 8200W, or else 9050W assuming a delta-T of 5 degrees C and a desire to keep water speed to 0.8m/s.
Nominally, 6kW output. Linear distance would be around 4.5m outdoor, 7.5m under house not including bends up and down.
Viessmann branded quattro connection line (2x40x3.7-1x32x?.?-1x25x?.?/160): diameter 160mm; bend radius 600mn; core hole ?.
Uponor Ecoflex Thermo Twin HP (2x40x3,7-2x32x3,5/175): diameter 175mm; bend radius 700mm; core hole 250mm.
Uponor Ecoflex Thermo Twin HP (2x32x2,9-2x32x3,5/140): diameter 140mm; bend radius 500mm; core hole 200mm.
Posted by: @john-connettViessmann branded quattro connection line (2x40x3.7-1x32x?.?-1x25x?.?/160): diameter 160mm; bend radius 600mn; core hole ?.
Uponor Ecoflex Thermo Twin HP (2x40x3,7-2x32x3,5/175): diameter 175mm; bend radius 700mm; core hole 250mm.
Uponor Ecoflex Thermo Twin HP (2x32x2,9-2x32x3,5/140): diameter 140mm; bend radius 500mm; core hole 200mm.There is also:
Uponor Ecoflex Thermo Mini (32x2,9/68): diameter 68mm; bend radius 250mm; core hole 125mm.Another possibility is to run the large pipe to the house wall then run two smaller pipes under the house. Smaller holes, tighter bend radius.
Using common sense alone, I don't like the suggestion of using a core drill through a beam & block floor slab to take any of these pipe sizes. A standard block is 215mm wide. Even if the hole position just happened to be spanning evenly across two adjacent blocks, you're removing half of the material from each.
And in the worst case you actually end up drilling right across the width of a single block, thereby causing it to fall. It would no longer span between the two beams.
Consider also that the void beneath the beam/block layer must remain inaccessible to vermin.
Not only is that a requirement of Building Regs, but you can certain that any self-respecting rodent would first strip the insulation from around your pipes.
Save energy... recycle electrons!
Posted by: @transparentUsing common sense alone, I don't like the suggestion of using a core drill through a beam & block floor slab to take any of these pipe sizes. A standard block is 215mm wide. Even if the hole position just happened to be spanning evenly across two adjacent blocks, you're removing half of the material from each.
And in the worst case you actually end up drilling right across the width of a single block, thereby causing it to fall. It would no longer span between the two beams.
Common sense is a good starting point but not a full solution. I suspect that a lightweight concrete floor block may lack the structural strength to maintain a core hole and an expanding ring seal. A possible approach would be to replace a floor block with something of sufficient structural strength that was consistent with the floor beam point loading limits. Using 2 x 68mm pipes rather that a 140mm pipe might give more design flexibility. There is also the question of how the pipe(s) would be anchored. Would an expanding ring seal give sufficient support? Pipe expansion would also need to be considered. There are questions that probably need answers from a beam and block expert and someone with experience working with these pipes.
Posted by: @transparentConsider also that the void beneath the beam/block layer must remain inaccessible to vermin.
Not only is that a requirement of Building Regs, but you can certain that any self-respecting rodent would first strip the insulation from around your pipes.
According to What size hole can a rat get through? an adult rat will need 12mm in a horizontal gap and a round hole of 25mm diameter and young rats will bring those measurements down to 8mm and 20mm diameter. Any practical solution to this challenge is likely to be rodent resistant. Pipe seals will be designed with this in mind. My house is fairly airtight and any thermal bridging should be kept to a minimum.
Any solution would need to comply with Building Regulations.
Thanks for your comments.
Posted by: @chickenbigAt the risk of not answering the question asked, what is the power output of the proposed heat pump, and how far is it between the external and internal unit? That will (somewhat) determine the diameter of flow and return pipes.
The Uponor pipes look rather bulky (and has a bend radius of 0.5m), with water pipe internal diameter of 25mm (or 26.2mm as it is unclear whether pipe 1 or pipe 2 is for water); that implies a power rating of 3.14*(2.5cm/2)^2 * 80 cm/s * 5 degrees C * 4.2 J/cm^3 = 8200W, or else 9050W assuming a delta-T of 5 degrees C and a desire to keep water speed to 0.8m/s.
The Viessmann branded pipe is 2x40x3.7 with an internal diameter of 32.6mm which is suggested for all of the Vitocal 200-A range (six models from 2.3 to 11.8kW (EN 14511 A2/W35, spread 5K)). Using your calculation gives a power rating of 14022W. The largest of the range claims a maximum output of 14.3kW (EN 14511 A7/W35, spread 5K) which seems appropriate.
Looks like the Ecoflex 2x32x2,9 would be adequate for the 5.7kW model.
Where does the 80 cm/s come from? I think I understand the rest of the calculation.
Thanks for the comment.
Yes, I like the idea of replacing a block in the sub-floor to provide a more robust entry point into the house.
Sleeving the pipe(s) with corrugated PVC/PE conduit and pouring a barrow-load of concrete around the entry point would suffice,
but it's not 'elegant'.
I wasn't concerned about rodents entering the house, but rather having access to the 7.5m length below the block & beam layer.
You wouldn't be able to see what damage they did to the pipe insulation below the house.
There needs to be a rodent-resistant zone around the point where the pipes enter that under-house void.
A barrow of sharp chippings would do it if you can somehow ensure that it provides sufficient depth of material that a mouse/vole/shrew would give up before penetrating the stone.
Save energy... recycle electrons!
Posted by: @john-connettWhere does the 80 cm/s come from?
It is a rule of thumb to keep water flow within reasonable limits (not making too much noise or eroding the pipe). I am struggling to find references on the internet; https://www.heatweb.co.uk/w/index.php?title=Pipework_Calculations recommends a peak speed at design load greater than about 0.75 m/s (to move debris around) but less than 1.5 m/s. That page collates somewhat conflicting advice.
I second chickenbig. When I did the research for my system, I found a lot of information suggesting that, when the connection between the outdoor unit and inside is long and/or complicated, that is a pointer towards a split system design - refrigerant pipes can be longer + thinner, doesn't need such enormous insulation, to achieve the same performance.
There's a presentation (on this forum) here https://renewableheatinghub.co.uk/what-is-the-difference-between-a-split-and-a-monobloc-heat-pump
might be worth you looking at some split system specs?
My octopus signup link https://share.octopus.energy/ebony-deer-230
210m2 house, Samsung 16kw Gen6 ASHP Self installed: Single circulation loop , PWM modulating pump.
My public ASHP stats: https://heatpumpmonitor.org/system/view?id=45
11.9kWp of PV
41kWh of Battery storage (3x Powerwall 2)
2x BEVs
Posted by: @chickenbiga peak speed at design load greater than about 0.75 m/s (to move debris around) but less than 1.5 m/s.
A second reference, https://www.h2xengineering.com/heat-pump-ebook-lp/ page 29, recommends a maximum speed of 1 m/s. Graham Hendra's book "50 things heating professionals need to know about Heatpumps" section 67 states "The problem is if you push too fast the pipes become noisy. So, the rule is to never let the water move at more than 1.5 meres per second"
- 21 Forums
- 1,760 Topics
- 37.6 K Posts
- 82 Online
- 2,052 Members
Join Us!
Latest Posts
-
RE: Samsung E911 intermittent issue
I've just been unscrewing the little plastic cap and ai...
By NetDonkey , 8 seconds ago
-
RE: Samsung ASHP scheduling help
All this is far too complicated for most of us. Surely ...
By Broadsman , 25 minutes ago
-
RE: Fitting heat pump plumbing and pipes in advance?
One more thought if you are doing a bathroom refurb and...
By JamesPa , 51 minutes ago
-
RE: Fitting emitters with output greater than room heat loss.
The proof, of course, will be in the heating! My ASH...
By JamesPa , 56 minutes ago
-
RE: Which system is most efficient...
OK. Im not going to be able to answer the question, bu...
By JamesPa , 1 hour ago
-
-
RE: Noise problems with newly installed Samsung 8kW ASHP
@lokisam I am following this with interest as I also ha...
By Odynsfee , 11 hours ago
-
RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan 11kw Defrosting Issue.
@thundermink can you give us an update on your tests?
By Mars , 13 hours ago
-
RE: Smart meter installation – seamless or a potential nightmare?
That's a very useful photo @jancoldIt provides me with ...
By Transparent , 14 hours ago
-
RE: Aira Heat Pump: Stylish Scandinavian Heating
@editor Yes, it's their "Aira Generation 1" 8kW model: ...
By trungdong , 15 hours ago
-
RE: Samsung heat pump has arrived with damaged fins – do I accept it or send it back?
Hi guys thanks for the replies. So it seems when the...
By AdamC001 , 17 hours ago
-
RE: Reducing heat pump vibrations through flat roof
@patrickvito Hi Patrick, thanks so much for taking the ...
By sten_super , 23 hours ago
-
RE: Noise Issues with our Ecodan 8.5kW WM85VAA air source heat pump
@athlonoc Its unlikely the FTC is controlling a 3rd par...
By ASHP-BOBBA , 1 day ago
-
RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan Produced energy showing 'INVALID'
Hello! I tried your idea and disabled the cooling funct...
By sorin , 1 day ago
-
RE: Battery...Full house back up
@saenergy I have recently installed a 12Kwh heat pump a...
By Broadsman , 1 day ago
-
RE: What should we do with our Aga?
@RobinBennett We also have an AGA. Oil fired that we...
By Morgan , 1 day ago
-
RE: Heat Pump Books For Beginners – Bodge Buster & From Zero To Heat Pump Hero
@editor Many thanks Mars, this will be my Christmas rea...
By Odd_Lion , 1 day ago
-
RE: Anyone have experience with Clivet (Midea?)? And monoblocks vs Splits?
@benson Good to hear!
By bigvibes , 2 days ago
-
RE: Very noisy Daikin Altherma
@editor I did not find a solution, and have pretty much...
By Zogy , 2 days ago
-
RE: Getting the best out of a heat pump - is Homely a possible answer?
@profzarkov Hi, the problem I had when fitting my Homel...
By Potatoman , 2 days ago
Latest Topics
-
By Jeff 2 hours ago
-
Which system is most efficient...
By bigvibes 2 days ago
-
What should we do with our Aga?
By RobinBennett 2 days ago
-
Reducing heat pump vibrations through flat roof
By sten_super 2 days ago
-
Fitting heat pump plumbing and pipes in advance?
By RobinBennett 2 days ago
-
By Broadsman 2 days ago
-
How to Clean a Y-Strainer Filter
By Mars 2 days ago