Observations on my Ecodan's estimates of energy consumed and delivered

glpinxit · 2024-04-03T15:08:28Z

Comments I made in the thread 'Electricity use for heat pumps - comparing homes and consumption' seemed to merit a thread of their own. So here it is, after a short break while I stripped out the bathroom (and then waited for March data). The short version is that my Ecodan invariably overestimates its electricity consumption. But it does this inconsistently which leads me to assume it's estimates of energy delivered may also be unreliable. So unless it's estimates of energy consumed and delivered are inaccurate but consistent with each other, any Coefficient of Performance derived from either or both of them is probably also inaccurate. I've read plenty of people observing this inaccuracy. Here I'm quantifying it (in terms of energy consumed but not delivered). I'd be interested in the experience of other Ecodan owners- especially if they have third party measurement of energy consumed and delivered. The long version is that my 11.2kW Ecodan was installed in the Summer of 2022 with an FTC6 controller. At the planning stage I specified that I wanted a separate meter installed so I could monitor energy consumed. In February 2023 I started keeping comprehensive daily records to help me judge whether changes I made led to any improvement in performance efficiency. Up to that point I had only kept a note of the figures from the consumption meter (which is accessible- unlike the FTC6 which entails burrowing at the back of the airing cupboard to read). My daily records since then cover energy consumed and delivered as 'measured' by the FTC6 controller, consumption measured by the meter and daily maximum and minimum outside temperatures (from my home weather station which is broadly consistent with the Ecodan/Melcloud OAT reading). The attached table only gives the % difference between the energy consumed month-by-month as measured by the meter and by the Ecodan. In every month the Ecodan overestimates consumption. I'm not sharing energy delivered in this thread as I don't want it to become a 'how to improve efficiency' discussion- we've already got plenty of those! And I lack confidence in the accuracy of the energy delivered figures reported by the controller. Given the widely varying difference between my two sources of energy consumption data any CoP figures derived are unlikely to be reliable or accurate. Note that energy consumed by the immersion heater isn't included in these figures. Observations and thoughts: consistent over-reading: Viewed at the monthly level, the Ecodan figures always overstate energy consumed. At the daily level the picture isn't so absolutely consistent but there were only 35 occasions in time covered by this data-set when the metered energy consumed exceeded the Ecodan estimate. data factors: The consumption meter gives figures to two decimal places while the Ecodan forecasts are all whole numbers. It naturally follows that 'if' the Ecodan rounds its forecasts (as opposed to only ever counting in whole numbers) then there will be a degree of inconsistency. But this would only ever be less than 0.5 kWh and even at the daily levels the inconsistency between the two data sources is usually greater than this. I turned off the heating manually for the summer. Despite this the Ecodan still 'allocated' some of its energy consumption to heating. I haven't reworked the data to explore what happens if I treat the heating consumption as zero. based on my temperature recording there is good correlation between energy consumed and OAT at the daily level. Conclusion ? The over-estimating of energy consumption is worst when consumption is low. There seem to be two main contributory factors- rounding and Ecodan estimates of consumption by the heating side when it is actually zero in the summer. The uncertainty of reported energy consumed and delivered figures make using daily CoP figures a very unreliable way to measure the effectiveness of small changes to things like a weather compensation curve. Weekly figures are a better basis. Surely things should be better than this!

Page 2 / 2 Prev

Air Source Heat Pumps (ASHPs)

Last Post by HarriUp 1 year ago

13 Posts

5 Users

2 Reactions

4,451 Views

RSS

HarriUp

(@harriup)

Reputable Member Member

Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 108

06/05/2024 11:11 pm

Posted by: @derek-m

↑

According to the wiring diagram for the cylinder unit, the power supply for all of the four water pumps is from one of the circuit boards, but since actual power consumption values can be added within the controller, it would appear that these are not being included within the power measurement system, which seems rather strange.

As it is possible for the FTC to be powered from a separate circuit, should this be the case none of its power draw, including the pumps, will be measured at the outdoor unit. It is also possible just the circulation pumps may be powered separately (UFH setups I believe). So the only way for the EcoDan to account for the power used by the pumps in either of these situations is to have a value to refer to in the settings for the periods when they are on. But the default settings assume power is delivered, and therefore measured, via the outdoor unit and so the default values are 0 (except for pump 4, for some reason).

I’ve posted before on my observations about the electrical consumption reported by my EcoDan – it is up to 3kWh per day in excess of the metered values, but that variation is spread fairly evenly across the range 0.2–3kWh, so is not a fixed value added in. And though there is a fairly loose correlation with the discrepancy tending to be higher when the actual consumption is higher, it nowhere near correlates to being a percentage of that consumption.

It is more a background random, persistent, inconsistency.

Mitsubishi EcoDan 8.5 kW ASHP - radiators on a single loop
210l Mitsubishi solar tank
Solar thermal
3.94kW of PV

ReplyQuote

Page 2 / 2 Prev

26 Forums
2,255 Topics
50.3 K Posts
460 Online
5,918 Members

Forum Icons: Forum contains no unread posts Forum contains unread posts

Topic Icons: Not Replied Replied Active Hot Sticky Unapproved Solved Private Closed

RE: Who has a V2G EV installation

My electrical knowledge isn’t a strong suit, so I may b...

By Majordennisbloodnok , 2 minutes ago
RE: My experience with 3 heat pump surveys: Heat Geek, British Gas & Octopus

Yes but... The evidence is that many heat loss survey...

By JamesPa , 5 minutes ago
RE: Help me keep the faith with my air source heat pump installation

Im presuming you have installed the MyVaillant integrat...

By JamesPa , 17 minutes ago
What Adam Chapman gets up to in his Spare Time.

Ok, so this just appeared on YouTube (don’t blame me th...

By Toodles , 19 minutes ago
RE: Daikin Altherma 3 / HomeAssistant

@dcsh, that’s a similar approach to what @jamespa was s...

By Majordennisbloodnok , 30 minutes ago
RE: Radiator Sizing Dilemma: Vertical vs Type 33 for Low-Temperature Heat Pump Systems

That's my main concern too. On top of that, I ...

By DREI , 2 hours ago
RE: Are We Sleepwalking Into Another Race to the Bottom?

Also it embeds a complex system, almost taking the home...

By JamesPa , 2 hours ago
RE: Grant 13kW Aerona3 - issues getting zones to temp

Thanks, patience is something I’m trying to ma...

By Crimson , 4 hours ago
RE: Solar Power Output – Let’s Compare Generation Figures

2025 - now a record year of Solar PV Generation. Octobe...

By AllyFish , 7 hours ago
RE: Midea ASHP – how to set weather compensation

@pash44pump - AI may have its uses (and I sort of allow...

By cathodeRay , 9 hours ago
RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan R290 10kW performance

Totally agree that any system is reliant on the ability...

By Sheriff Fatman , 9 hours ago
British Gas Heat Pump Installation Complaint

In 2024, my wife and I thought that we would try to do ...

By BGNO , 10 hours ago
RE: Battery disconnected

Erm... no we can't! The issue first raised by the OP ...

By Transparent , 11 hours ago
RE: Is it mad to think there should be a minimum SCOP for UK heat pump installs?

This wouldn't solve the problem @mars is trying to solv...

By JamesPa , 11 hours ago
RE: Testing new controls/monitoring for Midea Clone ASHP

Thx, but Sven did the hardware development. My role (as...

By Mosibi , 23 hours ago
RE: PV Panels on roof in Conservation Area

@majordennisbloodnok Fnaargh, I was thinking about try...

By colinc , 1 day ago
RE: Electricity price predictions

@jamespa Ah, you mean MPs that have not pro...

By Batpred , 1 day ago
RE: Buying large amp bidirectional RCD and RCBO

Exactly @transparent , this type of RCBOs are not easil...

By Batpred , 1 day ago
RE: Very Much Awake – Renewing the Heating Industry One Step at a Time

I feel that that attitude shared by Aadil from Heat Gee...

By Toodles , 1 day ago

Forums

Observations on my Ecodan's estimates of energy consumed and delivered

Join Us!

Podcast Picks

Latest Posts

Members Online