Advice on ASHP choice needed
Hi all
first time poster . I’m really getting very confused about my ASHP choice.
I live in 2016 build EPC B detached house , quite sizeable 220m2, just north of London.
i went through the very long journey of getting an octopus quote , they did 2 surveys and recommended a 8kw daikin. Heat losses c 6.4kw based on 2 surveys. Various people warned me about them (too small heat pump mainly, inexperienced installers) so got cold feet.
I then switched to Aira - heat lossss also 6.2kw , they recommended their 12kw unit which looked great and seemed to fit the bill. Long survey but 30 mins into the install has to be aborted as various things missed in the survey (like changing internal pipework).
Now have a local recommended installer coming up with much higher heat losses (11kw) and therefore speccing and LG therma v monobloc 12kw. Really ugly unit double fans.
I am really confused as to how the heat losses can differ so much - the last guy said ocotpus will be overestimating my U values and working the machine too hard. Not sure what to think of that.
My main 2 questions are : should I be concerned that the LG 12kw monobloc will be too large ? as I’ve read stories of oversizing being expensive to run if top big.
And 2 is there any other way to benchmark my heat losses ? For instance my total kWh gas usage in 2023 was 11300 kWh, does that help?
thanks!
The short answer is yes, there are other ways to check your heat loss estimate. I will post a link tomorrow when I’m at my pc. I would not be surprised if your 6.2-6.4 kW wasn’t far off. The 11kW is the outlier and sounds large based on the type of house.
House-2 bed partial stone bungalow, 5kW Samsung Gen 6 ASHP (Self install)
6.9 kWp of PV
5kWh DC coupled battery
Blog: https://thegreeningofrosecottage.weebly.com/
Heatpump Stats: http://heatpumpmonitor.org/system/view?id=60
Would recommend asking another opinion. The 11 kW heat loss seems high indeed if 2 others came up almost half of that.
I'm also surprised Aira would install a 12 kW heat pump in a property with 6.2 kW heat loss. That's way oversized.
On Octopus, you mention a concern about too small heat pump. An 8 kW Daikin for 6.2 kW heat loss is not too small so that shouldn't be a worry.
CEO and co-founder at HavenWise
@pie_eater welcome to the forums. If you have any Heat Geeks near you, it might be worth them coming out to do a survey too.
Buy Bodge Buster – Homeowner Air Source Heat Pump Installation Guide: https://amzn.to/3NVndlU
From Zero to Heat Pump Hero: https://amzn.to/4bWkPFb
Subscribe and follow our Homeowners’ Q&A heat pump podcast
I did a review of the assumptions of the heat losses and a decent part of it is down to design temp, for Octopus and Aira they use 19 for hallways and bedrooms and 21 bathooms whereas the local company uses 21 everywhere and 22 for bathrooms.
My main question is, how inefficient would the LG 12KW be if heat losses turned out to be 6-7kw ? Would it cost me a lot extra per year or just marginal?
The installers seems to really like the LG 12KW, perhaps because of low noise. Not entirely sure why but he rattled of a range of unsuitable alternatives.
He tells me not to worry it will modulate down as its "inverter driven"
The trouble with heat pumps manufacturer use different criteria for naming the heat pump size. So for actual sizing you need to look at running curves and data.
We spend a very small fraction of the heating season at or below the design heat loss, and a lot at about 6-7 degs which is generally half the heat load. So your 6kW is really nearly 3kW most the year, plus DHW heating. I would allow 3 hrs for DHW heating.
So take you design heat loss of 6.4 and multiply by 24 that becomes 154kWh. Now due to DHW heating you only 21 hrs for house heating, 154 / 21 becomes 7.3kW. So you need a heat pump that can do 7.3kW at -3. But also turn down (min output) ideally to 3.2kW at 7 degs.
My house is a similar size but EPC A, our heat load is 3kW so with your B circa 6kW is way more realistic than 11kW.
Here is the link I mentioned, it contains various methods of calculating heat loss. It depends how accurate you want to go.
Using two very simple examples given:
The Heat Geek cheat sheet estimates your heat loss to be between 4.4 and 8.8 kW
Michael Podesta's quick and dirty method gives it as 4.7 kW (-3C OT to 21C IT) using your annual gas figure (assuming that is all heating and not hot water, it would be less if you use gas to heat you hot water).
I certainly would not consider a heat pump of more than 8kW for your property and might well be looking at one in the 5-6 kW range depending on how more detailed calculations come in.
As mentioned before, its important to double check the badged output on heat pumps as that can be misleading and also check how low they can modulate down, Im currently using about 2kW to heat my home (of similar heat loss) and Im starting to cycle.
House-2 bed partial stone bungalow, 5kW Samsung Gen 6 ASHP (Self install)
6.9 kWp of PV
5kWh DC coupled battery
Blog: https://thegreeningofrosecottage.weebly.com/
Heatpump Stats: http://heatpumpmonitor.org/system/view?id=60
ooh that’s a great one thanks. Lots of geeky things to dig into
@pie_eater LOL, you are going to love this forum then! 🤣
House-2 bed partial stone bungalow, 5kW Samsung Gen 6 ASHP (Self install)
6.9 kWp of PV
5kWh DC coupled battery
Blog: https://thegreeningofrosecottage.weebly.com/
Heatpump Stats: http://heatpumpmonitor.org/system/view?id=60
Each installer/designer can have their own idiocies
one wouldnt count our cavity wall insulation because we couldn’t prove it was still working after 40 years (of course not!) so said we needed a12kW Midea NO!
Another used default air leakage despite us having a pressure door test result (said MCS insisted) so recommended a 12kW Daikin NO
I’ve used both heatpunk
and PHPP and my own spreadsheet and it comes out as ~7kW HP needed (yep nerd!)
That corresponds with Podesta rule of thumb well (see link from energy stats above) with our gas usage.
If you ran your gas continuously at the lowest possible temperature you could be sure the gas usage would correspond well.
A heat geek guy did agree that 7kW is what we needed, but even he had to play around with the software since our MVHR system could only be included if the house was built after 2006. Wierd! So that came out as the 7kW Vaillant, so guess which installer we’re going with?
2kW + Growatt & 4kW +Sunnyboy PV on south-facing roof Solar thermal. 9.5kWh Givenergy battery with AC3. MVHR. Vaillant 7kW ASHP (very pleased with it) open system operating on WC
- 26 Forums
- 2,102 Topics
- 46.2 K Posts
- 104 Online
- 3,388 Members
Latest Posts
-
RE: Compressor attempts start but fails - Nibe Fighter 2005 8kW
"To tell you the truth, I don't know if HAL is homicida...
By Scalextrix , 10 minutes ago
-
RE: Ecodan consuming 100kwh per day in new build!!!
@jamespa Hi James , I have just spoken to the dev...
By anca1808 , 32 minutes ago
-
RE: Plug and play solar. Thoughts?
And we have it: DESNZ are now investigating the feasi...
By Lucia , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Location of hot water isolation valve on cylinder
@rossowheels if you isolate the water supply in it will...
By ASHP-BOBBA , 16 hours ago
-
The Importance of Radiator Balancing for Efficient Heating: Introducing the Flow Regulating Valve
It’s fascinating to watch how low-temperature heating i...
By Mars , 1 day ago
-
@heacol, if you're around, can you please provide some ...
By Mars , 1 day ago
-
RE: Servicing Hitachi HP in rural Somerset
I'd give GreenGenUK a call or email them: sales@greenge...
By Mars , 1 day ago
-
RE: Heating coming on when not required
I played with a max heating temp but there is a world o...
By JamesPa , 2 days ago
-
RE: Pressure drop Primary circuit
I've always regarded topping up heating systems as my j...
By JamesPa , 2 days ago
-
RE: Heat pump solutions and/or installer recommendations for France
I’d travel to France for work if you were struggling wi...
By Damon Blakemore , 2 days ago
-
RE: 5 Star Service from Havenwise
That's always a danger with any new good idea, @morgan....
By Majordennisbloodnok , 2 days ago
-
Have your say in the Renewable Heating Hub Awards
It’s time to celebrate the best (and call out the worst...
By Mars , 3 days ago
-
-
RE: Mitsubishi cycling while on chilled water output
@iaack yes there's no denying that cold air sinks! I s...
By downfield , 3 days ago
-
RE: Weather compensated secondary circuits with Biomass
@andycoo that flooring sounds ideal. Extra volume is ...
By Sune , 3 days ago
-
If you are thinking of heating on the immersion conside...
By JamesPa , 4 days ago