17 year old ASHP needs replacement, should I go back to gas boiler?
Hi,
I bought a property with an old ASHP 6 months ago, which I had to get serviced many times already and the engineer said it’s end of its lifetime (NIBE fighter 2005). Currently we have no working heating, if we only use it for hot water it works fine. it’s an older cottage with OK but not great insulation.
I applied for the government replacement loan with 40% cashback and they were really helpful, I’m at the stage of putting in quotes I received from installers
My issue is that the quotes I got for replacing a few radiators and replacing the old heat pump with the new one are around 13.5k, as opposed to what the government says (10k max). Even if I’d receive a cashback of 4k, I’d end up with a 6k loan and I’d have to pay 3.5k cash
I really enjoy the carbon neutral part, but without 75% cashback it seems like a financial suicide as I could get a top boiler installed (we still have mains gas) for a lot less and because of the type of the property my bills would be less with gas than with electricity. 
Even with the older heat pump running to heat water, my daily electricity price is ridiculously high just for hot water as opposed to what I had with a gas boiler in my flat
has anyone been in this situation before? Is my math correct that even with a 4k cashback, if I need to put 9.5k towards a replacement I’ll never see that 6k difference back in bills compared to a top of the range gas boiler?
Thanks
David
Hi David, welcome to the forum.
So you are suffering the age old problem of trying to decide what to do for the best.
First of all I would question why you are being quoted £13.5k for changing a few radiators and replacing an old ASHP with a new one. Do you have a breakdown that you could share? Dependent upon size and type, standard radiators are normally in the few hundred pounds each range. Check out the Screwfix website for prices. You could consider buying them and getting a local Plumber to install, or even do it yourself. I do believe a reasonable size ASHP is in the region of £4k to buy.
What is the rating of your present heat pump? What is the heat loss of your cottage?
I suppose the alternatives are, question the quotes for a replacement heat pump until you get one that is more reasonable, or as you say, have a new gas boiler installed at a much lower cost.
As far as running costs are concerned, both now and in the future, we can only speculate. I know that our present electricity price has gone up by 300% over the past year or so, and the price for gas has gone up 500%. What will happen to the prices if sanity should return to the World I don't know, but I doubt that prices will return to their pre-crises levels.
One thing that I would recommend is improve the insulation as much as possible.
Wait, so your heat pump works for dhw but doesn’t work for CH?
If indeed the ashp is heating your hot water cylinder fine, then it can just as easily heat your central heating circuit.
Are you sure your dhw isn’t now on the immersion instead?
Just for comparison, my 9kW inverter heat pump was £3100 delivered…. An plumber could install in in a day.
Off grid on the isle of purbeck
2.4kW solar, 15kWh Seplos Mason, Outback power systems 3kW inverter/charger, solid fuel heating with air/air for shoulder months, 10 acres of heathland/woods.
My wife’s house: 1946 3 bed end of terrace in Somerset, ASHP with rads + UFH, triple glazed, retrofit IWI in troublesome rooms, small rear extension.
Posted by: @davidsHi,
I bought a property with an old ASHP 6 months ago, which I had to get serviced many times already and the engineer said it’s end of its lifetime (NIBE fighter 2005). Currently we have no working heating, if we only use it for hot water it works fine. it’s an older cottage with OK but not great insulation.I applied for the government replacement loan with 40% cashback and they were really helpful, I’m at the stage of putting in quotes I received from installers
My issue is that the quotes I got for replacing a few radiators and replacing the old heat pump with the new one are around 13.5k, as opposed to what the government says (10k max). Even if I’d receive a cashback of 4k, I’d end up with a 6k loan and I’d have to pay 3.5k cash
I really enjoy the carbon neutral part, but without 75% cashback it seems like a financial suicide as I could get a top boiler installed (we still have mains gas) for a lot less and because of the type of the property my bills would be less with gas than with electricity.
Even with the older heat pump running to heat water, my daily electricity price is ridiculously high just for hot water as opposed to what I had with a gas boiler in my flathas anyone been in this situation before? Is my math correct that even with a 4k cashback, if I need to put 9.5k towards a replacement I’ll never see that 6k difference back in bills compared to a top of the range gas boiler?
Thanks
David
Did you ever proceed with the heat pump?
Get a copy of The Ultimate Guide to Heat Pumps
Subscribe and follow our Homeowners’ Q&A heat pump podcast
- 26 Forums
- 2,255 Topics
- 50.3 K Posts
- 905 Online
- 5,918 Members
Join Us!
Podcast Picks
Latest Posts
- 
                        RE: Daikin Altherma 3 / HomeAssistant I don’t have a Shelly EM on my heatpump, so only see th... By DCSH , 59 minutes ago 
- 
                        RE: Help me keep the faith with my air source heat pump installation have you got an ebus adapter on yours? By AdamK , 1 hour ago 
- 
                        RE: When will fusion be producing energy? From the time I was a physics undergraduate it’s been 2... By Judith , 2 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Is it mad to think there should be a minimum SCOP for UK heat pump installs? Sadly I think it is mad. If the BUS is not granted for ... By Judith , 2 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Who has a V2G EV installation Perfect, @agentgeorge. I’m always up for some edificati... By Majordennisbloodnok , 2 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: My experience with 3 heat pump surveys: Heat Geek, British Gas & Octopus Yes but... The evidence is that many heat loss survey... By JamesPa , 3 hours ago 
- 
                          What Adam Chapman gets up to in his Spare Time. Ok, so this just appeared on YouTube (don’t blame me th... By Toodles , 3 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Radiator Sizing Dilemma: Vertical vs Type 33 for Low-Temperature Heat Pump Systems That's my main concern too. On top of that, I ... By DREI , 5 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Are We Sleepwalking Into Another Race to the Bottom? Also it embeds a complex system, almost taking the home... By JamesPa , 5 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Grant 13kW Aerona3 - issues getting zones to temp Thanks, patience is something I’m trying to ma... By Crimson , 7 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Solar Power Output – Let’s Compare Generation Figures 2025 - now a record year of Solar PV Generation. Octobe... By AllyFish , 10 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Midea ASHP – how to set weather compensation @pash44pump - AI may have its uses (and I sort of allow... By cathodeRay , 12 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan R290 10kW performance Totally agree that any system is reliant on the ability... By Sheriff Fatman , 12 hours ago 
- 
                        British Gas Heat Pump Installation Complaint In 2024, my wife and I thought that we would try to do ... By BGNO , 13 hours ago 
- 
                          Erm... no we can't! The issue first raised by the OP ... By Transparent , 14 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Testing new controls/monitoring for Midea Clone ASHP Thx, but Sven did the hardware development. My role (as... By Mosibi , 1 day ago 
- 
                        RE: PV Panels on roof in Conservation Area @majordennisbloodnok Fnaargh, I was thinking about try... By colinc , 1 day ago 
- 
                        RE: Electricity price predictions @jamespa Ah, you mean MPs that have not pro... By Batpred , 1 day ago 
- 
                        RE: Buying large amp bidirectional RCD and RCBO Exactly @transparent , this type of RCBOs are not easil... By Batpred , 1 day ago 


 
                        
 
                                 
                                 
                                 
                                 
                                
