Heat Pump Truth or Myth#2 - Cycling uses a lot of power and ruins your COP

Kev M · 2022-12-29T05:52:32Z

Heat pump cycling is one of these topics where a lot of people seem to have an opinion but no actual data to back it up. Cycling is blamed a lot for poor ASHP performance and it seems to be generally accepted that cycling or even <gasp> short-cycling is a “Really Bad Thing”. I do have data so I decided to have a look at it. This is a graph of my 14kW Ecodan over a few hours on a recent mild winter’s day. After the morning startup, it runs for an hour or so without cycling. As the ambient rises it starts to cycle. And because cycling is a Really Bad Thing, it's now going to use more power and my COP will be really poor, right? Let’s see. This is a comparison of two periods after the initial warm up; not cycling (5-6am) and cycling (6am-1pm) time energy consumed Wh energy delivered Wh Ave Ambient deg average power consumed W average power delivered W ave flow temp COP 5-6am 1082 4246 8.9 1082 4246 36.1 3.9 6am-5pm 6112 27578 10.3 777 3506 35.9 4.5 During the cycling period, the COP is better and the power consumed is less. Surely that can’t be right? That’s not meant to happen; the power used should be much more and the COP should have plummeted. So what happened? Well what you’d expect really. The COP is better because it’s warmer outside and the average flow temp is nearly the same. The average power consumed is less because the heat demand is less and the COP is better. The bit that might be surprising, is that cycling hasn’t made a big difference to consumption or efficiency. Why not? I think it’s because the widely touted theory that starting up an ASHP and warming up the flow a bit uses an excessive amount of energy is a load of cobblers. There are no large peaks in power. And, at the risk of stating the bleeding obvious, between peaks there are troughs, empty ones. I am sure the cycling does make some difference and a smaller ASHP delivering 3.5kW without cycling will do it a bit more efficiently. If I look at the next size of ASHP down from mine, it can modulate down to around 3.5kW and it looks to have a 10-15% better COP at this output than I got with my cycling. Let’s say 15%. That means that I’d be saving around 120W of power, or about £1 per day over 24 hours at today’s prices. I know there is more to it than this and there are a lot more extreme examples of cycling out there but I think cycling sometimes gets a bit of a bum rap for being the cause of all heat pumps’ ills. And I’d rather have a heat pump that cycles a bit when it’s warmer and cheaper to run than be inside shivering when it’s freezing outside, the ASHP is defrosting every hour and running flat out trying to match the number on its badge. I’d be interested if anyone else has done any similar analyses. Or even just has an opinion. 😉

Page 2 / 2 Prev

Air Source Heat Pumps (ASHPs)

Last Post by Derek M 1 year ago

13 Posts

7 Users

12 Reactions

7,092 Views

RSS

Derek M

(@derek-m)

Illustrious Member Member

Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 4429

06/05/2024 7:34 pm

Posted by: @jamespa

↑

I understand that A2A heat pumps have better turndown than A2W thus sizing is less critical. I haven't seen the proof that this is true however.

I cannot state that I have noticed that our A2A heat pump can modulate to a lower output, but it can certainly respond much faster than an A2W heat pump and also may be more efficient, since it is cutting out at least one stage in the process.

👍

ReplyQuote

Page 2 / 2 Prev

22 Forums
2,057 Topics
44.9 K Posts
22 Online
3,299 Members

Forum Icons: Forum contains no unread posts Forum contains unread posts

Topic Icons: Not Replied Replied Active Hot Sticky Unapproved Solved Private Closed

RE: Heat Pump Manufacturers Recommending Buffer Tanks

@editor it’s a defrost buffer, it uses an Esbe 4 way ...

By Damon Blakemore , 7 hours ago
RE: Rate the quality of your heat pump design and installation

@davesoa very good to know... I'll convey this to Clayt...

By Mars , 9 hours ago
RE: IVT Greenline high pressure switch and electrical cassette errors

OK, so when the HP comes on it becomes obvious.It's on ...

By tdudgeon , 13 hours ago
RE: Is Your 6kW Air Source Heat Pump Really a 6kW?

@johnmo I think we’ve been trudging through the same...

By SUNandAIR , 13 hours ago
RE: How To Balance Radiators & the Role of the Lockshield Valve: A Homeowner's Guide

Good luck, I hope it all works out!

By JamesPa , 2 days ago
RE: Struggling to Find a Top Heat Pump Installer? We Can Connect You With the Best Installers in the UK

@johnd it's a difficult one, because we've seen instanc...

By Mars , 2 days ago
RE: Is your heat pump insured?

@johnmo sorry it comes across like that. The post is au...

By KevinPotts , 2 days ago
RE: Getting the best out of a heat pump - is Homely a possible answer?

@johnmo Perhaps a little detail might explain my reason...

By Toodles , 2 days ago
Win a 6-panel PV courtesy of egg and Renewable Heating Hub

Our epic giveaway just went live! Want to win a 6-pan...

By Mars , 2 days ago
RE: Yes, the "zoning with ASHP" topic again...

James, thanks again for your thoughtful and persistent ...

By HarryRea , 2 days ago
RE: Is this normal? Click of the DHW returning to space heating

So the Lone Ranger returned today! Even though we thoro...

By Grantmethestrength , 2 days ago
RE: Vaillant & OVO partner up to offer Heat Pump Plus

Hopefully iv done the right thing today by signing up t...

By Westkent , 3 days ago
RE: Battery sizing - How low can you go!

My own experience with connecting four batteries to thr...

By Transparent , 3 days ago
RE: Plate heat exchanger considerations

Work on 2-3 percent per degree. This is a reasonable e...

By JamesPa , 3 days ago
RE: Advice for ground source heat pump in new build with PV and batteries

The useful bit is the bit that specifies the heat loss ...

By JamesPa , 3 days ago
RE: Volumisers in Heat Pump Systems: Does Placement Matter?

You’re absolutely right that during defrost the refrige...

By Mars , 3 days ago
RE: Ecodan UD 0-0 error

@editor thanks Mars that’s the same table I found in th...

By Gary , 4 days ago
RE: Tariff and charging strategy advice please

They haven't asked me to prove that I have an EV (I do)...

By JamesPa , 4 days ago
RE: Solar Power Output – Let’s Compare Generation Figures

Took a while to find on the OFGEN site: ”The FIT sche...

By AgentGeorge , 4 days ago

Forums

Heat Pump Truth or Myth#2 - Cycling uses a lot of power and ruins your COP

Join Us!

Trusted Installers

Latest Posts

Members Online