February Results and a system update.
Good evening all,
I hope this finds you all well. So February turned out to be way warmer than we expected in the North east of Scotland. We managed to get a COP for February of over 5.2. I’m astounded!
In other news, we had our installer round today for a bit more “geeking out”. We have removed both the internal to the house pumps, and the blend valve for the underfloor heating down stairs. We are now solely using the pump within the heat pump itself. We have also removed the control connection between the ASHP controller and the underfloor heating controller, we are now fully using the Vaillant control system upstairs and down. We are also running on adaptive heat curve, not sure why Vaillant said not to use it, no issues here. The Neostat v2s bought 8 months ago are now only for temperature indication only at SWMBO request. Once Mrs P is happy I will remove these and plaster over the boxes. Fingers crossed this is the last part of the tweeting. Although I must admit I will miss it, it’s been a great learning exercise.
Drew
I am at the moment giving serious consideration to engaging the services of @heacool to run his expertise over my install. I have a feeling he will make such changes as you indicate and have my system running far more efficiently. My concern, which I am trying to get to grips with, is how his work might affect my warranty with my installer and Mitsubishi. Also if having changes made by a third party affects my RHI situation.
I'm pleased for you that your system is so efficient, you clearly are very happy. If you can achieve such progress given your northerly location I should be able to achieve similar this far further south in Derbyshire. Good luck.
Retrofitted 11.2kw Mitsubishi Ecodan to new radiators commissioned November 2021.
14 x 500w Monocrystalline solar panels.
2 ESS Smile G3 10.1 batteries.
ESS Smile G3 5kw inverter.
Posted by: @drew-paWe managed to get a COP for February of over 5.2. I’m astounded!
And so you should be!
When I get a read out on my car dashboard telling me I am getting 250 mpg I also tend to be astounded.
Given the ambient temps you have experience over the last month, is that COP credible? How does it compare to Valliant's claimed performance at those ambients and your heat pump settings (LWT etc)?
Midea 14kW (for now...) ASHP heating both building and DHW
Posted by: @cathoderayPosted by: @drew-paWe managed to get a COP for February of over 5.2. I’m astounded!
And so you should be!
When I get a read out on my car dashboard telling me I am getting 250 mpg I also tend to be astounded.
Given the ambient temps you have experience over the last month, is that COP credible? How does it compare to Valliant's claimed performance at those ambients and your heat pump settings (LWT etc)?
https://emoncms.org/app/view?name=MyHeatpump5&readkey=0c28f25dea9e38f983d9c83a6dd455c0
If you take the DHW out of the equation, maybe.
Posted by: @fazelIf you take the DHW out of the equation, maybe.
Sorry, that doesn't make sense.
The medium/long term COPs shown in that unexplained and unidentified link are around 4.2. The COPs listed on heatpumpmonitor.org range from 2.5 to 4.9, mean 3.7, median 3.9. That's why I question whether a COP of 'over 5.2' is credible in winter in Scotland.
Unless you have third party monitoring hardware that is correctly set up, you are relying on manufacturers generated data, effectively the manufacturer marking their own homework. We have no way of knowing how scrupulous they are, though we do know that certain car manufacturers have been known to mark their own homework creatively.
Midea 14kW (for now...) ASHP heating both building and DHW
Posted by: @cathoderayPosted by: @fazelIf you take the DHW out of the equation, maybe.
Sorry, that doesn't make sense.
The medium/long term COPs shown in that unexplained and unidentified link are around 4.2. The COPs listed on heatpumpmonitor.org range from 2.5 to 4.9, mean 3.7, median 3.9. That's why I question whether a COP of 'over 5.2' is credible in winter in Scotland.
Unless you have third party monitoring hardware that is correctly set up, you are relying on manufacturers generated data, effectively the manufacturer marking their own homework. We have no way of knowing how scrupulous they are, though we do know that certain car manufacturers have been known to mark their own homework creatively.
The Vaillant range is relatively new and should be at the higher end of COPs out there. However, 5.2 for February might be a tad optimistic given the Vaillant SCOPs listed below, which are measured on test rigs, not real houses.
Having said that, it sounds like @drew-pa's system is running efficiently and has made good improvements.
Posted by: @cathoderayPosted by: @fazelIf you take the DHW out of the equation, maybe.
Sorry, that doesn't make sense.
The medium/long term COPs shown in that unexplained and unidentified link are around 4.2. The COPs listed on heatpumpmonitor.org range from 2.5 to 4.9, mean 3.7, median 3.9. That's why I question whether a COP of 'over 5.2' is credible in winter in Scotland.
Unless you have third party monitoring hardware that is correctly set up, you are relying on manufacturers generated data, effectively the manufacturer marking their own homework. We have no way of knowing how scrupulous they are, though we do know that certain car manufacturers have been known to mark their own homework creatively.
The Vaillant range is relatively new and should be at the higher end of COPs out there. However, 5.2 for February might be a tad optimistic given the Vaillant SCOPs listed below, which are measured on test rigs, not real houses.
Having said that, it sounds like @drew-pa's system is running efficiently and has made good improvements.
Posted by: @kev-mHaving said that, it sounds like @drew-pa's system is running efficiently and has made good improvements.
I am sure it is running efficiently, and that is a good thing, but I think we have got to be realistic about performance figures. The 'over 5.2' COP for February is also significantly at odds with @drew-pa's previously published monthly COP figures (<=link) eg 3.85, 3.78, 2.94 for October, November and December 2022. That makes the 5.2 figure a significant outlier, and significant outliers often tell us something is wrong with the data behind the outlier.
Midea 14kW (for now...) ASHP heating both building and DHW
Evening all,
I have to say we are extremely happy with the whole package regardless of whether there are errors in the data or not. I have seen the numbers improve over the year as the changes we have made have taken effect. We are really happy with the installation as a whole, the installer, and the equipment. Really happy.
I have used figures from the app to complete the spreadsheet so that may explain some differences. Going forward I am going to only use the vrc720f energy data so the data set is constant.
We have made some big changes over the year since it was installed first. Hopefully we have just completed the last upgrades now. When the system was first installed we had heat curves of 1.2 and 0.8 I think it was. These are now down to roughly 0.35, the adaptive heat curve appears to be working well. We are seeing a flow temp of 32-34c now. Our COP since install, taken from the VRC720F is 4.14 for the whole installation.
Like I said earlier we are extremely happy with the install. I have learned so much, both about the system, and to not be scared of the system and to try different things till you find what works for you and your system. A big thank you to everyone here for your help, and knowledge transfers.
Take care all.
- 26 Forums
- 2,183 Topics
- 48.1 K Posts
- 41 Online
- 5,756 Members
Join Us!
Podcast Picks
Latest Posts
-
RE: Testing new controls/monitoring for Midea Clone ASHP
I don't think it is that simple. From what you say, you...
By Tasos , 17 minutes ago
-
RE: Moving FIT array onto a Tesla Powerwall 3 possible?
What I’m trying to say is I want the solar inverter on ...
By AdamK , 44 minutes ago
-
RE: Samsung Gen 6 - Schedules not working
@old_scientist My feeling was that they might always ha...
By bontwoody , 47 minutes ago
-
RE: Which thermostat should I get (or do I need one?)
OK. It may be best to run it through the wint...
By JamesPa , 49 minutes ago
-
RE: Samsung 5kW R32 Monobloc Gen 6 ASHP
Hi @Nick Owens, welcome to the forum. My Sam...
By Old_Scientist , 2 hours ago
-
Is 15kWh to be regarded as particularly large @wully ? ...
By Transparent , 2 hours ago
-
RE: Heat Pump Installers: Competence, Illusion and the Hard Truth Homeowners Must Face
Some interesting comments here on buildhub. If SimonD ...
By JamesPa , 2 hours ago
-
Heat pump and wifi kit connection.
Currently trying to connect my Samsung MIM-B19N board t...
By Alfapat , 3 hours ago
-
RE: Heat Pump + Tado Setup: Smarter Control for Secondary Pumps?
I suspect this is one for @pirate-rich
By Mars , 3 hours ago
-
RE: Seal the Deal: Don't Let Your Heat Pump Leak Energy
Yuck, yuck and more! Others have pointed out lots alr...
By Judith , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Large heat pump options for church building
A few random thoughts: 1. Solar will mostly be produc...
By Tim441 , 5 hours ago
-
RE: DNO export limit problems.
So you're planning to add a PW3 to the existing setup (...
By Old_Scientist , 15 hours ago
-
RE: Do I just go with the lowest quote for my heat pump?
@toodles I have electric pet blankets 🙄 If req...
By Jancold , 16 hours ago
-
RE: Flexi-Orb Heat Pump Scheme: A Game-Changer for the UK's Heat Pump Industry
Signed
By Judith , 17 hours ago
-
@drei just a small detail on your table posted on the 2...
By Judith , 17 hours ago
-
RE: Say hello and introduce yourself
I've started a topic in the Heating Alternatives sub-fo...
By wully , 20 hours ago
-
@toodles Im trying my best but it is getting a tad tedi...
By bontwoody , 20 hours ago
-
RE: Clivet ASHPs and weather compensation
It sounds like weather comp may not be activated. Give ...
By Simon Wardle , 1 day ago
-
RE: Help me keep the faith with my air source heat pump installation
I just looked at mine. My flexis (which run horizontal...
By JamesPa , 1 day ago