ASHP as preheater for conventional electric boiler
Hi everyone,
I'm reaching out to this knowledgeable community in hopes of some collective wisdom regarding my heating conundrum. My situation is a bit unique, and I'd greatly appreciate any insights or alternative perspectives you might have.
The Setup:
- Large, 4-storey detached house with 6 bedrooms and 200 sq m of floor space.
- Currently reliant on an electric boiler and radiators (no underfloor heating).
- Existing 300L hot water cylinder.
- Professional heat loss calculation confirms a 12kW heating requirement.
Fuel Options:
- Solar: Unfortunately, solar isn't an option due to roof limitations and bay windows.
- Wind: Similarly, wind power isn't feasible for my property.
The Shortlist:
This leaves me with three main contenders:
- Biomass Boiler: While efficient, the prospect of fuel storage and additional maintenance isn't overly appealing.
- Air Source Heat Pump (ASHP): Intriguing for its renewable credentials and potential cost savings, but a 12kW unit seems quite hefty.
- Fuel Cell: An interesting concept, but I'm unfamiliar with its viability and long-term costs in the UK.
My Initial Thought:
Given my existing radiators and desire to avoid major upheaval, I was considering exploring a hybrid approach:
- Use a 12kW ASHP to preheat the water to 60-65°C in the existing cylinder.
- Utilize my electric boiler for a secondary boost to reach the desired 80°C when necessary.
Questions for the Community:
- Is a 12kW ASHP truly necessary for my situation? Would a smaller unit with electric backup be a more economical solution?
- Has anyone tried a similar hybrid approach with an ASHP and existing electric boiler? What were your experiences and any unforeseen challenges encountered?
- Is a fuel cell worth exploring for my needs? I'm open to new technologies, but practical details and cost analysis would be very helpful.
- Are there any other options I haven't considered that might be a better fit for my scenario? I'm open to all suggestions and keen to learn from your collective expertise.
I'm committed to finding a sustainable and cost-effective heating solution for my home, and I believe your combined knowledge and experience can be invaluable in guiding me on this journey.
Thank you for your time and any insights you may offer!
DropBear
Hi
12 kW isnt particularly large for a heat pump in a large property.
Can I ask why you are thinking of heating water to 80 C ?
I did try boosting water from a heat store with an instantaneous water heater when it started to be depleted. It worked but its flow rate wasnt as good as without so I switched it back.
House-2 bed partial stone bungalow, 5kW Samsung Gen 6 ASHP (Self install)
6.9 kWp of PV
5kWh DC coupled battery
Blog: https://thegreeningofrosecottage.weebly.com/
Heatpump Stats: http://heatpumpmonitor.org/system/view?id=60
It probably doesn't need to be 80deg C. That was what the radiators were built for in our house before we bought it.... right before energy prices sky rocketed. Essentially I don't want a solution that involves ripping a whole system out (rads, cylinders etc). It works very well, other than the cosy. I Thought a solution like this might work by taking the bulk of the heavy lifting off the electric boiler. I'm open to alternatives though.
Posted by: @dropbearIt probably doesn't need to be 80deg C. That was what the radiators were built for in our house before we bought it.... right before energy prices sky rocketed. Essentially I don't want a solution that involves ripping a whole system out (rads, cylinders etc). It works very well, other than the cosy. I Thought a solution like this might work by taking the bulk of the heavy lifting off the electric boiler. I'm open to alternatives though.
I would suggest that you measure the size and type of radiators and check their specified output at a Delta T of 50C. From the total value it should then be possible to calculate the probable required water temperature at different outside air and indoor air temperatures.
I'll do that, but in the mean time, can I validate that this is actually a potentially viable solution? We haven't turned heating on for 4 years now, because it's just insane
Posted by: @dropbearI'll do that, but in the mean time, can I validate that this is actually a potentially viable solution? We haven't turned heating on for 4 years now, because it's just insane
There are hybrid systems with normally a gas boiler along with a heat pump, so I would not see that it would be a problem. Please provide more information about your present system so that a more in-depth appraisal can be made.
@dropbear there's an element of confusion in your write up. you talk about the 300L cylinder being preheated to 65 and then heat with something else to 80C, then you talk about the radiators being designed for 80C. those are not the same thing.
does your electric boiler run at a flow temperature of 80C when heating the house? that isn't the water that comes from your 300L cylinder.
The cylinder water is to supply the hot water in the taps - and that definitely doesn't need to be at 80C.
your electric boiler must be on a separate circuit due to its power. what is the e-boiler's power rating? what does it actually use when heating your house? Is there a way you could put a CT clamp meter on it? By running your house on the electric boiler and monitoring the consumption, you have a potentially really accurate way of measuring the heat loss of your house, and therefore how big an ASHP you actually need. That is the single most important question to answer when designing an ASHP system.
that said, 12kw doesn't seem an unreasonable first approximation for a 200m2 house.
It worth adding this (It took me a while to get my head round it - if you know this already I apologies, but if not this might help)
a 12kw heat pump doesn't use 12kw of electricity. It produces 12kw of heat at maximum power - which is only needed on very cold - sub zero days. the usual design criteria for south of england is -2 or -3C. colder in the highlands of course, depends where you live . So at max heat output, the worst case with a very inefficient design it'll be using 6kw of electricity. In milder weather (approx 5-7c) with an efficient system design, it'll be using less than 1kw of electricity. This is where you save the run cost money.
you've said "Not had the heating on for 4 years due to insane" (I assume there's an implied "cost" on the end of that). Given that you are already familiar with the cost points of direct electric central heating, the transition from electric boiler cost to ASHP cost will be fairly easy estimate.
so I know you've said you don't use it, but I would say: switch it on, keep the house at a steady comfort temp (don't switch it on and off), measure the outside temp, and measure what it uses at a given outside temp. you need to know that number.
If your radiators are genuinely only able to heat your house with 80C water in the circuit and you don't change any of them , you'll be able to run an ASHP at an efficiency (a.k.a COP) of no better than 2 ish. Meaning you won't get better than halving the electricity input (that you would currently would need with the e-boiler, if you ran it). This is not what we'd recommend.
If you do the job properly and change out the radiators so the house can run with a lower water temp, efficiency of high 3's to low 4's is do-able with radiators. Meaning electrical input 1/3 to 1/4 of the e-boiler's level. then you will not feel like you're being robbed when you run the heating.
the other serious option to add into this, if you have the capital, is to get a storage battery. This doesn't have to be combined with solar. buy cheap off peak electricity, keep it in your battery use the stored electricity to run the heating when the tariff is peak.
My octopus signup link https://share.octopus.energy/ebony-deer-230
210m2 house, Samsung 16kw Gen6 ASHP Self installed: Single circulation loop , PWM modulating pump.
My public ASHP stats: https://heatpumpmonitor.org/system/view?id=45
11.9kWp of PV
41kWh of Battery storage (3x Powerwall 2)
2x BEVs
- 26 Forums
- 2,136 Topics
- 46.8 K Posts
- 18 Online
- 5,662 Members
Join Us!
Podcast Picks
Latest Posts
-
RE: Sanity check please. Battery storage and inverter sizing.
@old_scientist yes already have a 4kwp array on a vener...
By AdamK , 10 hours ago
-
RE: Rodents! A word of warning for heat pump owners
Thanks for this. My pipe insulation in my garage has...
By JamesPa , 11 hours ago
-
RE: Why so many sigenergi installer recommendations?
I've noticed lots of love for them on YouTube too - I w...
By Old_Scientist , 13 hours ago
-
@editor Something changed in this last 12 months, they ...
By ASHP-BOBBA , 14 hours ago
-
RE: Ecodan & MelCloud scheduling
I put the above question to Mitsu UK at the sme time as...
By DavidAlgarve , 23 hours ago
-
RE: Air source heat pump roll call – what heat pump brand and model do you have?
Forum Handle: EGP01 Manufacturer: Samsung Model: 8K...
By EGP01 , 2 days ago
-
Thanks for the heat geek info. I've fitted my own heat ...
By bontwoody , 2 days ago
-
RE: Does anyone have experience of a smart water meter?
Just to give a sense of scale, I've used the CCW water ...
By Majordennisbloodnok , 2 days ago
-
RE: Powerwall 3 or Myenergi or something else?
We have a Tesla Powerwall 3, recently installed, so I m...
By Old_Scientist , 3 days ago
-
RE: Mitsubishi PAR-WT60R-E Wireless Controller installation
@morgan They have been paired once but it was thought b...
By DavidAlgarve , 4 days ago
-
RE: Isolating the system for a planned power cut
A great many ground-mounted local substation transforme...
By Transparent , 4 days ago
-
RE: Heat Pump Servicing & Maintenance – Good Value or Rip-Off?
Having bit the bullet and paid £250 for a service, our ...
By Old_Scientist , 5 days ago
-
New heat pump heating system underperforming in Italy... Advice needed!
hi all, first post! I've just renovated a house in sout...
By robinlawrie , 5 days ago
-
RE: Anyone still weathering it out with Agile?
I went to Agile when I had solar installed July last ye...
By NJT , 5 days ago
-
RE: Mitsu Wireless Controller and MelCloud
Well it has now become obvious that the installation of...
By DavidAlgarve , 6 days ago
-
RE: Say hello and introduce yourself
Whilst you're busy installing services (pipes and wires...
By Transparent , 7 days ago
-
RE: New Vaillant aroTherm Plus in black - When will it come to the UK?
@editor I know it was formally announced at Ish the oth...
By PatrickVito , 1 week ago
-
@moman0311 welcome to the forums. I've received your em...
By Mars , 1 week ago
-
RE: Thermostat for Ideal Logic Air with 3 zone support
No harm at all in plumbing it as 3 zones, I would have ...
By JamesPa , 1 week ago
-
RE: ASHP heat output monitoring
@carlo I see there is a discussion in Facebook user gro...
By Tim441 , 1 week ago