Whilst Regs allow on-off simple thermostats (Nest, Hive, Heatmiser, Honeywell, etc) Installers should never be responsible for failing heat pumps!
It’s a class thing I guess..the worst aspect of the U.K, A heating engineer is always to blame for failures of what is world class technology, your heat pump!
Well, rumour has it, that a sales rep from a reputable global company has installed a heat pump with evohome and in his first year of operation only got a CoP of 2.4..with on-off controls
I know people are frustrated but the rot on the heating industry goes much deeper than the class bashed tradesman.
Regulations defined what you get offered, not good engineering.
keep it simple people one controller from your heat pump manufacturer, or their zonal control kit..
Professional installer
For those who don’t get it at the heart of the issue is a dichotomy in policy. Heat pumps, because they are kw restricted, have to deliver a stable state heating system, ie be available to deliver heat to stop things getting too cold. This is fine because houses have regular usage patterns.
U.K. policy works on the assumption that a heat generator is best off as it consumes no energy. An oversized boiler recovered the heat quickly because boiler fuel is energy intense.
On off controls shut down the heat generator.
Compensation controls wind up and down the heat generator changing flow temperature to satisfy demanded room temperature
Compensation controls deliver savings on gas boilers too, about 10-15% higher the warmer outside!
Weather compensation has been mandatory in Germany since 1985, and since 2001 in Holland Compensation controls have been mandatory, as far as I know Compensation control of heating appliances are used in Switzerland, Denmark, Scandinavian countries, and North Italy.
Your hapless installer has paid his dues for training and gets guided by policy and manufacturers. He too expects things to work. But between what the consumer wants (Nest,Hive, Heatmiser) and what is correct he defers to the customers..as you would too!
So installers are never to blame. Suited and salaried civil servants are who allow on-off controls on heat pumps are the baddies here.
Professional installer
Good morning Alec. My Ecodan system installed not long before xmas 2021 has Heatmiser on/off control. I have the stat set permanently at 24C and the control set at weather curve. The house is a lovely even 21/22C 24/7. The installer was apparently unable to source the Mitsubishi wifi receiver and room controller. I have now after some time sourced and am in possession of those two items. Awaiting the installer returning to swap them over for me. Once done I hope to have 'proper' weather compensation control.
Retrofitted 11.2kw Mitsubishi Ecodan to new radiators commissioned November 2021.
Posted by: @morganGood morning Alec. My Ecodan system installed not long before xmas 2021 has Heatmiser on/off control. I have the stat set permanently at 24C and the control set at weather curve. The house is a lovely even 21/22C 24/7. The installer was apparently unable to source the Mitsubishi wifi receiver and room controller. I have now after some time sourced and am in possession of those two items. Awaiting the installer returning to swap them over for me. Once done I hope to have 'proper' weather compensation control.
Hi Morgan,
You actually already have weather compensation control, by installing the additional equipment you will actually achieve auto adaptation control.
Indeed. But I will soon have ‘proper’ & full control with Mitsubishi components as opposed to third party. I won’t have to to set an artificially high temperature to achieve the aim.
Retrofitted 11.2kw Mitsubishi Ecodan to new radiators commissioned November 2021.
Posted by: @alec-morrowFor those who don’t get it at the heart of the issue is a dichotomy in policy. Heat pumps, because they are kw restricted, have to deliver a stable state heating system, ie be available to deliver heat to stop things getting too cold. This is fine because houses have regular usage patterns.
U.K. policy works on the assumption that a heat generator is best off as it consumes no energy. An oversized boiler recovered the heat quickly because boiler fuel is energy intense.
On off controls shut down the heat generator.
Compensation controls wind up and down the heat generator changing flow temperature to satisfy demanded room temperature
Compensation controls deliver savings on gas boilers too, about 10-15% higher the warmer outside!
Weather compensation has been mandatory in Germany since 1985, and since 2001 in Holland Compensation controls have been mandatory, as far as I know Compensation control of heating appliances are used in Switzerland, Denmark, Scandinavian countries, and North Italy.
Your hapless installer has paid his dues for training and gets guided by policy and manufacturers. He too expects things to work. But between what the consumer wants (Nest,Hive, Heatmiser) and what is correct he defers to the customers..as you would too!
So installers are never to blame. Suited and salaried civil servants are who allow on-off controls on heat pumps are the baddies here.
I'm not so sure. Anyone installing heat pumps should know how they work. If they do, they will know an ASHP running at 50C with 3rd party thermostats is not the most efficient set up. If they don't know this then they shouldn't be installing heat pumps. But they also know that this set up will work and will be familiar to customers and that they (the supplier) won't be paying the electricity bills. Setting up weather compensation takes time and is likely to need more after sales service, which costs the supplier time and money.
I agree about the lack of regulation and training but installers, some of whom are national companies, need to take some responsibility.
Posted by: @kev-mI'm not so sure. Anyone installing heat pumps should know how they work. If they do, they will know an ASHP running at 50C with 3rd party thermostats is not the most efficient set up. If they don't know this then they shouldn't be installing heat pumps. But they also know that this set up will work and will be familiar to customers and that they (the supplier) won't be paying the electricity bills. Setting up weather compensation takes time and is likely to need more after sales service, which costs the supplier time and money.
I agree about the lack of regulation and training but installers, some of whom are national companies, need to take some responsibility.
Agree with this 100%. One of the major selling points of ASHP is their "environmental friendliness", so installers should be required to leave any system they install running in the greenest, most efficient way possible.
Our installer, who claim to be "The No 1 heat pump installer in the country" left our system running at a fixed flow of 50C controlled by thermostats. When I queried this and mentioned changing to weather compensation, their response was that they "would advise against using weather compensation as it can throttle back the delivery of heat from the pump considerably resulting in a lower than desirable flow temperature" - that is a direct quote from an email from them. Every bit of their "expert advice" tells me to use a fixed flow temp of 50C. I have, of course, ignored them!
It's completely nuts. This is the compressor speed of my Grant (aka Chofu) ASHP, using the Honeywell Lyric on/off controller the installer supplied. The Lyric is doing TPI, which attempts to learn the dynamics of the house and run the ASHP for a variable length in each time period to keep the house at a constant temperature. It's impossible to turn off TPI and, on the longest period, it's doing this every 20 minutes. As installed it was doing it every 10 minutes.
The frustrating thing is the Chofu has a perfectly good room controller integrated into it, but the Grant instructions deleted that part from the setup guide. That means my setup has the pumps and valves wired to the Honeywell, as per the Grant instructions.
When I get some time and a cold day I plan to see if I can enable the room controller and bypass the Honeywell...
Posted by: @prunusIt's completely nuts. This is the compressor speed of my Grant (aka Chofu) ASHP, using the Honeywell Lyric on/off controller the installer supplied. The Lyric is doing TPI, which attempts to learn the dynamics of the house and run the ASHP for a variable length in each time period to keep the house at a constant temperature. It's impossible to turn off TPI and, on the longest period, it's doing this every 20 minutes. As installed it was doing it every 10 minutes.
The frustrating thing is the Chofu has a perfectly good room controller integrated into it, but the Grant instructions deleted that part from the setup guide. That means my setup has the pumps and valves wired to the Honeywell, as per the Grant instructions.
When I get some time and a cold day I plan to see if I can enable the room controller and
Professional installer
The issue is that an ASHP and boiler is part of a system for which there is no training in the U.K. People buy ASHPs and boilers with out fully comprehending how components interact.
Thats why compensation controls need to be mandated. In the absence of that using the controllers supplied by the pumps is a smart move.
Professional installer
Hi, new here and looking to get ASHP installed asap.
What should i be asking potential re on-off thermostats? Seems that those we've spoke to are looking to install Honeywell or equivalent...
Thanks in advance for any insight.
Professional installer
- 24 Forums
- 1,360 Topics
- 28.6 K Posts
- 39 Online
- 1,156 Members
Join Us!
Latest Posts
-
RE: Is this a bad installation and is there something wrong with my Samsung heat pump?
@david999 While it is not for your Samsung heat pump,...
By Derek M , 15 mins ago
-
RE: Assessing Heatmiser Neostat Accuracy: How and Why to Calibrate Them
Heatmiser Neostats are also used by Grant. Theirs are G...
By AllyFish , 22 mins ago
-
RE: Battle of the charging technologies
Thanks for that, @ianmk13. Although you've still a bit ...
By Majordennisbloodnok , 1 hour ago
-
RE: Aira Heat Pump: Stylish Scandinavian Heating
He said they have based the kit on existing technology,...
By IvanOpinion , 1 hour ago
-
RE: PAS_63100_2024 - BSI guidance on BESS (battery energy storage systems) in dwellings
@guthrie - don't worry. PAS_63100_2024 is not a retrosp...
By AllyFish , 3 hours ago
-
RE: Daikin Altherma noisy heat pump - help and advice needed
Hello, So we had another visit yesterday, two install...
By Clairelp , 3 hours ago
-
RE: Electricity price predictions
Or is refusal to burn wood when the market price is abo...
By Judith , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Forum updates, announcements & issues
Image and attachment uploads have been fixed.
By Mars , 5 hours ago
-
Design & Measurements of Heat Pump Performance? W...
By iantelescope , 5 hours ago
-
RE: Our Vaillant VWL year end review - North East Scotland
@neilhighland it won’t really matter what heat pump mak...
By Gary , 9 hours ago
-
@harriup thanks for your post it’s good to get a differ...
By SUNandAIR , 20 hours ago
-
RE: Smart meter installation – seamless or a potential nightmare?
@transparent I am particularly interested in how the...
By IanMK13 , 22 hours ago
-
RE: Say hello and introduce yourself
Given all the discussion on here I wonder if there is n...
By Systemsthinker01 , 1 day ago
-
-
RE: Installing a heat pump in a Grade II listed property
This is true not just of Heat Pumps, of course. Whenev...
By IanMK13 , 2 days ago
-
RE: Rate the quality of your heat pump design and installation
@editor Hi Mars, he is a sole trader who has installed ...
By TechnoGeek , 2 days ago
-
RE: New Fogstar 15.5kWh upright solution
@adrianmc thanks but I was also offering a solution, ie...
By MisterB , 2 days ago
-
RE: Homely vs TaDo for a heat pump. Does Homely only optimise twice per day?
Some more ‘refining’ has been carried out following a l...
By Toodles , 2 days ago
-
RE: Home automation - IFTTT recipes
@majordennisbloodnok Yup, that makes a lot of sense. OE...
By Toodles , 2 days ago
-
RE: Benefits of improved insulation.
Having watched this, I think it's a really useful posti...
By Majordennisbloodnok , 2 days ago
Latest Topics
-
Benefits of improved insulation.
By Derek M 3 days ago
-
By vala 3 days ago
-
Cheaper and Faster grid upgrades?
By Toodles 3 days ago
-
Ground Source Heat Pump Systems and Their Design
By Brendon Uys 4 days ago
-
By DavidAlgarve 4 days ago
-
By EcoBaker 6 days ago