Should I make my radiators smaller?
A deliberately provocative title, forgive me.
The question is really about how important it is to have equally sized radiators in each room, in relation to specific room heat loss.
I had a heat loss calculation done, and with my current radiatiors at a design temperature of 50C flow and -3 OT, some are clearly undersized, the worst being -47%. Okay that needs upgrading, no brainer.
But how much to upgrade it, just to 100% the heat loss of that room, or to match the most oversized radiator in any other room?
What if thats not possible, and room A is sized with 100% of power output to heat loss, and room B is sized to 158% of power output to heat loss; I assume room B is going to get much too hot?
The modern advice is not to have TRVs and to go as "open circuit" as possible, so how do we mitigate the oversized radiator in room B? Should we make it smaller? What % of size deviation can be handled without adding flow restrictions and controls?
Everyone seems to say bigger radiators are better, but should that advice come with the caveat that sizing needs to be equal throught the heating zone?
TIA
Bonus question; if you open up all the radiators in a reasonably balanced system, and let the heating come to equielibreum with OT, and measure the temperature within each room; is that a better way to calculate heat loss? Is there a method for that?
Posted by: @scalextrixWhat if thats not possible, and room A is sized with 100% of power output to heat loss, and room B is sized to 158% of power output to heat loss; I assume room B is going to get much too hot?
The modern advice is not to have TRVs and to go as "open circuit" as possible, so how do we mitigate the oversized radiator in room B? Should we make it smaller? What % of size deviation can be handled without adding flow restrictions and controls?
The deviations can be handled by
a) the lockshield valve. this restricts the flow rate through the rad in question which increases the deltaT for that rad which reduces the average temperature and hence the output.
b) the fact that rooms tend to share heat anyway because the thermal separation is poor.
I had mismatches of 150% plus, no problem
Posted by: @scalextrixBonus question; if you open up all the radiators in a reasonably balanced system, and let the heating come to equielibreum with OT, and measure the temperature within each room; is that a better way to calculate heat loss?
No, you wont leave it like that for long enough to overcome all the other variations that mother nature throws at us.
Posted by: @scalextrixIs there a method for that?
yes, (a) measure it over several weeks monitoring individual radiators and the heat pump, Adia Thermal make the kit to do this or (b) plot your gas/oil usage vs average OAT for several months or preferably a whole season, estimate the efficiency of your boiler, and work from there (gives you whole house only).
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
@jamespa thanks for the reply, so really in this case we have to reduce the flow to the radiator to achieve it.
In my specific case the oversize radiators are upstairs which isn't really the best from a heat sharing perspective, but I get your point.
Posted by: @scalextrix@jamespa thanks for the reply, so really in this case we have to reduce the flow to the radiator to achieve it.
In my specific case the oversize radiators are upstairs which isn't really the best from a heat sharing perspective, but I get your point.
Mine are also upstairs because I upgraded them before I realised how much the heat pump industry overestimates house losses. Still not a problem although the lack of 'valve authority' with the very old LSVs on a couple of the rads in question makes for a slightly tricky, but not impossible, adjustment . Of course that is my house, yours may be different. The 'excess' upstairs capacity helped my installer to be happy to leave the bathroom well under-provided for, thus I could retain my exiting towel rail rather than replace it.
That said if you can make the downstairs ones bigger go for it. Lower flow temperature = lower cost and greater comfort, as you clearly know!
4kW peak of solar PV since 2011; EV and a 1930s house which has been partially renovated to improve its efficiency. 7kW Vaillant heat pump.
- 26 Forums
- 2,255 Topics
- 50.3 K Posts
- 731 Online
- 5,918 Members
Join Us!
Podcast Picks
Latest Posts
- 
                        RE: When to use Octopus Intelligent Go tariff with my heat pump and battery Difficult to be completely prescriptive without more de... By JamesPa , 7 minutes ago 
- 
                          RE: Buying large amp bidirectional RCD and RCBO Quite possibly... ... and I've identified two more ab... By Transparent , 8 minutes ago 
- 
                        RE: Help Stop the MCS Heat Pump Monopoly Thats a thought. There is a contact point given. Hav... By JamesPa , 2 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Solar Power Output – Let’s Compare Generation Figures @allyfish It was going so well with month after month s... By Toodles , 2 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Electricity price predictions As that's an energy issue, it would need the DESNZ to p... By Transparent , 3 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Flexi-Orb Heat Pump Scheme: A Game-Changer for the UK's Heat Pump Industry Worth noting there’s a parallel discussion about this h... By Majordennisbloodnok , 3 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: UFH downstairs and radiators upstairs balancing question Have you tried turning up the stat and turning down the... By JamesPa , 4 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Help me keep the faith with my air source heat pump installation I have the same firmware. I have MyVaillant version HA... By JamesPa , 4 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Midea ASHP – how to set weather compensation @pash44pump - thank you By cathodeRay , 5 hours ago 
- 
                        
- 
                          RE: Mediation with RECC, what's your experience? Welcome to the forums @treewizard and sorry to hear abo... By Mars , 6 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: New build installation query That accounts for why you start with an overly-high DHW... By Transparent , 6 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Daikin Altherma 3 / HomeAssistant I would have thought that (instantaneous) power is a fa... By JamesPa , 7 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Are We Sleepwalking Into Another Race to the Bottom? Alright, I concede that the Toyotas are, as you say a v... By JamesPa , 10 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: When will fusion be producing energy? From the time I was a physics undergraduate it’s been 2... By Judith , 21 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: Is it mad to think there should be a minimum SCOP for UK heat pump installs? Sadly I think it is mad. If the BUS is not granted for ... By Judith , 21 hours ago 
- 
                          RE: Who has a V2G EV installation Perfect, @agentgeorge. I’m always up for some edificati... By Majordennisbloodnok , 22 hours ago 
- 
                        RE: My experience with 3 heat pump surveys: Heat Geek, British Gas & Octopus Yes but... The evidence is that many heat loss survey... By JamesPa , 23 hours ago 
- 
                          What Adam Chapman gets up to in his Spare Time. Ok, so this just appeared on YouTube (don’t blame me th... By Toodles , 23 hours ago 

 
 
 
                                 
                                 
                                 
                                 
                                
