Heatgeek and flow temperature YouTube

This is an excellent video that explains why lower flow temperature is the way to go. Balancing heat loss to heat input. I read Chemical Physics at Uni and I hadn’t thought about it like this. Good.
But how does this relate to electric spend?
Having a SCOP of 5+ is fabulous, but if you are spending more on electricity, then it’s of no benefit - except for the heat geeks 😊
So appreciate thoughts. I still plan to run my ASHP on Nest control for a year until April when I will switch to weather compensation for a year to compare.
Daikin Altherma 3H HT 12kWh ASHP with Mixergy h/w cylinder; 4kW solar PV with Solic 200 electric diverter; Honda e and new Hyundai Ioniq 5 N electric vehicles with Myenergi Zappi mk1 charger
drop the nest, you are on a hiding to nothing. it gives no feed back to the pump about required temperatures..
stick with the heat pumps own controller and app
Professional installer
@alec-morrow so I understand the logic, but need the data to confirm. Do you see my point. Running the ASHP at 5+ COP for 24hrs (even with step back) might cost more than How I am running now with Nest.
Where is your evidence for the “hiding to nothing” statement?
Daikin Altherma 3H HT 12kWh ASHP with Mixergy h/w cylinder; 4kW solar PV with Solic 200 electric diverter; Honda e and new Hyundai Ioniq 5 N electric vehicles with Myenergi Zappi mk1 charger
It’s understanding I defer to, I’m a heating engineer.
Turning things off and on inherently create inefficiencies in regularly used spaces. That was tolerable before variable flow temperatures became the optimum way to maintain comfort temperatures.
on-off necessitates a higher than necessary flow temperature to compensate for the off period
Professional installer
@alec-morrow understand your point. And I’m sure you are an experienced heating engineer. And know what you are talking about. But as an ex-scientist and now IT geek, I need the data. That’s why I’m comparing across two years with two different control systems. Not sure it’s statistically accurate though.
Daikin Altherma 3H HT 12kWh ASHP with Mixergy h/w cylinder; 4kW solar PV with Solic 200 electric diverter; Honda e and new Hyundai Ioniq 5 N electric vehicles with Myenergi Zappi mk1 charger
Posted by: @julianc@alec-morrow understand your point. And I’m sure you are an experienced heating engineer. And know what you are talking about. But as an ex-scientist and now IT geek, I need the data. That’s why I’m comparing across two years with two different control systems. Not sure it’s statistically accurate though.
Julian,
I fear your experiment will only work if the weather and temperatures are the same for each year. I suspect that they may not be. 🙃
@derek-m it’s a good point well made. Not sure what else to do?
Daikin Altherma 3H HT 12kWh ASHP with Mixergy h/w cylinder; 4kW solar PV with Solic 200 electric diverter; Honda e and new Hyundai Ioniq 5 N electric vehicles with Myenergi Zappi mk1 charger
Posted by: @julianc@derek-m it’s a good point well made. Not sure what else to do?
You can look up degree days for both your years and adjust. There are a couple or three sites but this one will do it.
You could also plot outside temp vs energy consumed on a scatter diagram and compare the two years. Like I did here to compare using thermostats with weather comp.
Posted by: @julianc@alec-morrow understand your point. And I’m sure you are an experienced heating engineer. And know what you are talking about. But as an ex-scientist and now IT geek, I need the data. That’s why I’m comparing across two years with two different control systems. Not sure it’s statistically accurate though.
oh dear… I feel for you!
There have been comparisons done by people here, savings of not using an On-Off has been seen here to be around 20-25%
Professional installer
Posted by: @julianc@alec-morrow so I understand the logic, but need the data to confirm. Do you see my point. Running the ASHP at 5+ COP for 24hrs (even with step back) might cost more than How I am running now with Nest.
Where is your evidence for the “hiding to nothing” statement?
Hi Julian,
The problem with any home based test is that there are so many variables that are not being measured and hence cannot be taken into account in the final results.
Since you believe in maths and physics, maybe I can prove to you that what Alec is saying is actually true.
Looking at the data for Kev's system, the heat demand at an outdoor air temperature of 7C is 4304W at a water flow temperature of 34.3C, and a COP of 4.6, which would require an electrical energy input of 936W. So if his heat pump runs constantly for 1 hour then the energy used would be 936Wh.
If instead of running continuously for the full hour, the heat pump runs for 40 minutes and then stops for 20 minutes, then the heat emitted into the property would be 2689W at the above water flow temperature. So the indoor air temperature would start to fall.
To maintain the indoor air temperature requires that 4304W is emitted during the 40 minute period, which would equate to a heat energy output of 6456W from the heat pump. To achieve this level of output the heat pump would need to operate at a water flow temperature of 39.2C, at a COP of 3.93 and electrical energy input of 1642W. Because the heat pump is only running for 40 minutes, the power used is 1095W.
So if running the heat pump at a higher temperature but for a shorter length of time uses 1095Wh, and running it continuously at a lower water flow temperature uses 936Wh, then the energy consumption is almost 17% greater with the on-off method.
I hope this answer your question.
@derek-m thank you Derek. Fantastic explanation. I do take your point about all the variables too.
I will think on this more. But it suggests I need to end my annual Nest control trial and move over to weather compensation sooner.
Thank you
Daikin Altherma 3H HT 12kWh ASHP with Mixergy h/w cylinder; 4kW solar PV with Solic 200 electric diverter; Honda e and new Hyundai Ioniq 5 N electric vehicles with Myenergi Zappi mk1 charger
@julianc I think I remember you saying you'd bought a Daikin maintenance and service pack. Which one did you get and has it proved to be a good investment ?
- 26 Forums
- 2,158 Topics
- 47.4 K Posts
- 40 Online
- 5,736 Members
Podcast Picks
Latest Posts
-
RE: Midea ASHP – how to set weather compensation
I noticed that too and thought the same thing, but then...
By cathodeRay , 24 minutes ago
-
RE: Ya can’t win! It is S*d’s Law!
@old_scientist If IOF is still running next late spring...
By Toodles , 36 minutes ago
-
So after asking the technical department for an update ...
By bontwoody , 40 minutes ago
-
RE: Testing new controls/monitoring for Midea Clone ASHP
Interesting. The minute data previously showed very di...
By JamesPa , 49 minutes ago
-
RE: Electricity price predictions
Those of you on Agile will do well tomorrow; there are ...
By Toodles , 1 hour ago
-
RE: Who’s Caved and Switched the Heating On Already?
We've been running our Ecodan system, installed in June...
By Sheriff Fatman , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Big Changes Coming to Our Heat Pump System
@jamespa The dormitories at my boarding school (in Exet...
By Toodles , 7 hours ago
-
Ok. Two schools of thought. The first is to run the ...
By JamesPa , 23 hours ago
-
@drei Willing as I am to help, I don't think I'm yet ...
By JamesPa , 23 hours ago
-
RE: Is Your Broadband Router the Weak Link in Your High-Tech Home?
I hear you on the locality issue @transparent, and I ag...
By Scalextrix , 1 day ago
-
Selling 5 year old ASHP & Gas Combi Boiler - £590
Selling a 5-year-old Daikin Altherma Hybrid Air Source ...
By Paul G , 1 day ago
-
RE: Help me keep the faith with my air source heat pump installation
Er true, it should have read l/hr!
By JamesPa , 1 day ago
-
RE: Is a Valliant Inline 6kW heater a BUS buster?
Much of that is true in principle, but its not likely t...
By JamesPa , 3 days ago
-
RE: Heat Pump Servicing & Maintenance – Good Value or Rip-Off?
@dgclimatecontrol I attach the responses from 2 potenti...
By pash44pump , 3 days ago
-
RE: Buffers, hot water and cooling
@dgclimatecontrol thanks, that's helpful.
By JamesPa , 4 days ago
-
RE: Failing heat pump system - seeking thoughts on a rebuild
I realise im overdue an update on my situation. first...
By Cleardene-ashp , 4 days ago
-
RE: Replacing Worcester oil boiler with an ASHP
@toodles thanks. I was told by the engineer that this h...
By JulianC , 4 days ago
-
RE: What crazy nonsense are inverter limits and why are they imposed?
A week later, I'm finally picking up this comment... ...
By Transparent , 4 days ago
-
RE: COP is not the only measure of efficiency
We keep all our TRVs fully open using the whole house a...
By Old_Scientist , 4 days ago