Creative trials on Night-time Setbacks to @ faster recovery, improved comfort and even greater energy reductions.
@morgan yes, I don’t know why it reads hourly temperature when it should read “temperature history”. I hope you are now seeing the correct graph lines. I guess it may say hourly temperature because it is divided in to 24 hourly divisions.
The Ecodans just do not have a meter-grade electricity monitoring capacity. There is an over-estimation of the daily consumption that is not consistent, so not easily accountable for. I have a record of accurately measured values of the consumption of my Ecodan, a meter on the supply to the outdoor unit which also then feeds through to the packaged cylinder. If I take the daily measured values and chart them against a calculated value for the difference to the reported consumption figures from MelCloud it produces the following:
Although there is a broad trend for the overestimation to increase as the consumption increases, the linear cluster on the left shows there is a similar range of overestimation even when the actual consumption is only the 600Wh or so that the FTC itself is using when no heat is being generated. Overall for 2023 the difference between measured and estimated consumption is 664 kWh - or 17% of my total energy usage.
My example might be usefully typical, or it might not; I have read others' estimations which are different. So although there is an option in the settings to increase or decrease the value recorded for the energy input in percentage terms, without a benchmark measurement to derive that difference it would just be guesswork. And there would still be a varying amount of inaccuracy day to day.
I don't think there is a simple setting adjustment or mis-programming where controller is applying a spurious correction factor for pumps that may not exist, there are plenty of adjustments that can be made in the settings to account for what hardware is attached to the unit. But Mitsubishi themselves state if you want accurate energy measurements you have to add an external meter - they have not added the electronics to do it within the unit.
Mitsubishi EcoDan 8.5 kW ASHP - radiators on a single loop
210l Mitsubishi solar tank
Solar thermal
3.94kW of PV
@harriup thanks for your post it’s good to get a different perspective on this consumption challenge. You have done a lot of work in gathering MELCloud vs actual data it’s very relevant to my question. Thanks for the post.
you are right I was hoping for a magic variable and in many ways that’s what you’ve posed in your graph. But as you suggest in your post this may or may not be comparable with other ecodan setups.
My motive for this line of thought is that there are many people who come to this website and who don’t have any metered data and are only looking at Ecodan estimates. Very often puzzled and a little panicked by the perception of unreliable information.
With practise and experience I am happy that you can interpret efficient operation from problematic signs just from the raw MELCloud data but I think this is a big ask to a new owner to do the same when there are signs of inconsistent data.
I apologise for the late reply but have been away for a few days.
thanks again for your post.
@sunandair Hi there, really interesting experiment! So if I understand correctly, your conclusion is that nightly setbacks actually save energy (and therefore money assuming fixed tariffs) for your specific property? And on some days quite a bit actually! All these experiments were run in in Auto Adaptive mode?
Have you ever tried to write some code to automate the optimisation?
CEO and co-founder at HavenWise
Posted by: @hcas@sunandair Hi there, really interesting experiment! So if I understand correctly, your conclusion is that nightly setbacks actually save energy (and therefore money assuming fixed tariffs) for your specific property? And on some days quite a bit actually! All these experiments were run in in Auto Adaptive mode?
Have you ever tried to write some code to automate the optimisation?
Hi HCas
yes, I’m glad you’ve found it interesting. There appears to be a roughly 3 kw saving per night on a 10kwh day and a similar saving on a 15 KWh day but when the auto defrost is operational and freeze stat function is active the savings become quite large. This I believe, is because the set back period overnight doesn’t have any, or so many, defrost cycles. Even when the auto reheat kicks in the freeze stat function is a gentler output so often doesn’t evoke a frosting up of the fins and usually finishes before a full defrost is begun.
The earlier tests up to 14th January were mostly weather compensation mode Andy after 14th January we switched the trial so over to Auto Adaptive mode.
I haven’t looked at coding anything since the reason for these trials was to help people with minimal knowhow and basic factory fitted technology. This imo should be everyday products for everybody’s access. But you’re probably right there needs to be improvements in what’s delivered.
Thanks SUNandAIR!
3 kWh on 10 or 15 kWh is substantial, and more than I expected to be honest. So I guess for you the setbacks are now the default?
Is your Ecodan wifi enabled?
CEO and co-founder at HavenWise
@hcas yes we are pretty much settled with a 3 C setback each night now. There could be several reasons for saving energy on a night time set back; not least because night times generally are colder, especially on clear sky nights, so operating a heat pump at night is the most costly time to operate a heat pump. Regarding the Ecodan connectivity, it does have wireless connections and the MELCloud app is part of the Ecodan connectivity. But I also think Mitsubishi somehow control what third party devices can access the op system and appear a little guarded in what parts are accessible.... I think so anyway? There appears to be a bit of technological rivalry between manufacturers which may spill over into limited integration of new devices.
You may have heard of the Homely system? It is interesting that it isn’t accessible with Mitsubishi and their Ecodan HeatPumps as yet. But I’m not sure if that is Homely being selective or if it is Mitsubishi trying to monopolise how their systems are controlled.
It would be good to know how open and progressive these heat pump manufacturers really are.
@sunandair Yes good point on the temperature during the night and impact on the heat pump efficiency! I've seen similar effects in some simulations I've done. In some instances for instance, if temperature is expected to drop, sometimes it's better to pre-heat a little bit when temperature is still high.
Yes I've come across Homely. Not sure why they are not compatible with Ecodan. Could be a lot of different reasons... Not the least because they need hardware and a bunch of installer resources so installers can actually install them. I'm checking if there is a way around that actually. I sent you a DM as well on this.
On openness, I've spoken to a company which entire business is integrations with all kinds of manufacturers (batteries, EV chargers, and heat pump manufacturers). They are saying manufacturers are increasingly open, also in part because they are forced by EU regulation.
CEO and co-founder at HavenWise
Posted by: @harriupAlthough there is a broad trend for the overestimation to increase as the consumption increases, the linear cluster on the left shows there is a similar range of overestimation even when the actual consumption is only the 600Wh or so that the FTC itself is using when no heat is being generated. Overall for 2023 the difference between measured and estimated consumption is 664 kWh - or 17% of my total energy usage.
Your graph shows some interesting correlations. Simple question- Can you confirm if the 17% difference in estimated consumption is of your total HP measured or total household. (I’m presuming it’s HP)
While your graph shows the Ecodan estimations are quite variable and may well not show any proportional way it has been calculated it does at least show you’re measured consumption over a large number of days use. If I’m reading your comments correctly you’re findings does, at least, give you an average over estimation from the Ecodan system.
Do you think that from this information you would be able to correct your cop figures in a viable way? To the point where you could simply remove a percentage from your daily or monthly stats to correct your CoP stats?
I’ve put a copy of your graph here.
I have a meter on the dedicated HP circuit, so I know exactly what the HP is consuming. It is that that enables me to make the comparison with values provided by the EcoDan itself.
I keep a spreadsheet of daily data values for the HP and PV - a bit tedious to update every now and again, perhaps one day I'll find out if it is possible to automate in some way. But obviously I use the metered data as I have it along with the EcoDan's generated energy data to calculate COP values.
If that meter was to fail I could fudge a COP based on the EcoDan's own usage figures – but I would use a deduction of 1.8kWh each day to modify them. There would be a margin of error of about 1.2kWh either way given the spread of the variation I have recorded on my system.
Using a percentage change would over-reduce the winter figures giving me a much better COP but leave the summer figures not changed enough, in fact it would probably double the value of the summer consumption and halve the resulting COP.
Mitsubishi EcoDan 8.5 kW ASHP - radiators on a single loop
210l Mitsubishi solar tank
Solar thermal
3.94kW of PV
Posted by: @harriupperhaps one day I'll find out if it is possible to automate in some way
It is certainly possible, using a modbus connection. If your dedicated HP circuit meter has modbus (or you get one that does have a connection, if your current one does not), then it is a simple two wire connection to something that can collect modbus data eg a mini PC running a python script (or possibly Home Assistant, though I don't know the details, others do). Likewise, if your ASHP has modbus, or can be made to have modbus, you can also collect data from it. See my Real world connection to a heat pump over modbus thread for some details (still not complete, but enough to get you started). Here's my data for the last month (interval can be changed at will), readings taken every minute, all done automatically, just needs double click from me on a desktop icon to get the data displayed like this:
Midea 14kW (for now...) ASHP heating both building and DHW
- 21 Forums
- 1,695 Topics
- 36.5 K Posts
- 59 Online
- 1,980 Members
Join Us!
Latest Posts
-
RE: Distance from house issue - Samsung 5kW ASHP
The heat loss differs depending on the pipe diameter (a...
By dorkypark , 2 mins ago
-
RE: Ecodan high pressure at 3 bar
Something similar happened to me once with a gas system...
By dorkypark , 7 mins ago
-
My Octopus Cosy 6 Heat Pump Journey: From Quote to Completion
The Full Installation Service Octopus provides a co...
By wreckguru , 3 hours ago
-
RE: Moving from two zone to single (open) / how to select a circulation pump - advice please
Thanks @heacol Brendon - helps as well as creating more...
By rhh2348 , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Heat pump efficiency v Outside Air Temperature
@glpinxit I have a secondary pump on the emitter side o...
By Toodles , 4 hours ago
-
-
RE: Air source heat pump roll call
Manufacturer: Octopus Model: Cosy6 Type: ASHP Arr...
By wreckguru , 7 hours ago
-
RE: In the middle of an ASHP installation - a few questions (and issues)
@benson good that you are fine on the BUS payment. Di...
By wreckguru , 8 hours ago
-
RE: Agile: average import cost vs other tariffs?
Thanks, @mike-h. Just a bit of clarification if you d...
By Majordennisbloodnok , 8 hours ago
-
It would be interesting @mars to hear what the argument...
By JamesPa , 8 hours ago
-
RE: Do I accept an ASHP and Solar Panel retrofit under the HUG 2 scheme?
Can you provide some photos of the proposed position an...
By Judith , 9 hours ago
-
RE: Inverter control of power from batteries
I've discussed the issue with LED chip manufacturers. ...
By Transparent , 9 hours ago
-
RE: Midea ASHP – how to set weather compensation
It is not either or, you can use both weather compensat...
By cathodeRay , 10 hours ago
-
RE: Octopus Cosy 6 installation (fan boy video)
@editor cool, let me know if you need anything else. ...
By wreckguru , 11 hours ago
-
Hello, Unfortunately, they haven’t answered my email ye...
By Frits , 12 hours ago
-
RE: Private messaging working?
That's a good shout, Major; one to validate On the su...
By rhh2348 , 1 day ago
-
RE: Bad COP? Long Pipe Run on Cosy6 Saga Continues.
@toodles the installation is now turning into a cani...
By Lucia , 1 day ago
-
A further thought. The 21.5p per kWh was with my attemp...
By Martin53 , 1 day ago
Latest Topics
-
By @sand 24 mins ago
-
Distance from house issue - Samsung 5kW ASHP
By jswhite 7 hours ago
-
Smart Meter connectivity and features
By Transparent 1 day ago
-
Bad COP? Long Pipe Run on Cosy6 Saga Continues.
By Toodles 2 days ago
-
Quiet mode: Samsung air source heat pump
By Profzarkov 2 days ago
-
By rhh2348 3 days ago
-
By Potatoman 3 days ago
-
By Westkent 4 days ago
-
LG Therma, Controller settings help needed
By bontwoody 4 days ago