Altherma 3 4kw - Overshoot
New to heat pumps and two issues.
1) when heating the leaving water the pump seems to be flat out until it reaches the required temp at which time is slows and consumption drops. That is all fine but it always heats the water beyond the target level - it overshoots - and this cannot be economical can it?
2) the Madoka controls the temp and turns on and off accordingly - it turns off at about 1.5 degrees over the target temp and once off it stays off until we are about 1 degree below the target. That means it is off for a couple of hours and the leaving water has cooled big time. The knock on effect is that when the pump kicks back in it is working very hard, especially during these very cold spells. I would have expected the pump to tick over at least keeping the leaving water at some sort of base temperature. Again, this does not seem economical.
I believe a part of this might be due to modulation but I do to understand that aspect.
Can I do anything to improve things or is an this just how it is?
Thank you, Colin.
Posted by: @colin-gNew to heat pumps and two issues.
1) when heating the leaving water the pump seems to be flat out until it reaches the required temp at which time is slows and consumption drops. That is all fine but it always heats the water beyond the target level - it overshoots - and this cannot be economical can it?
2) the Madoka controls the temp and turns on and off accordingly - it turns off at about 1.5 degrees over the target temp and once off it stays off until we are about 1 degree below the target. That means it is off for a couple of hours and the leaving water has cooled big time. The knock on effect is that when the pump kicks back in it is working very hard, especially during these very cold spells. I would have expected the pump to tick over at least keeping the leaving water at some sort of base temperature. Again, this does not seem economical.I believe a part of this might be due to modulation but I do to understand that aspect.
Can I do anything to improve things or is an this just how it is?
Thank you, Colin.
The problems you are experiencing are because you have an on - off type room thermostat controlling how the heat pump operates. If you wish to have the heat pump operate in a more consistent, more efficient manner, it will need to be adjusted for Weather Compensation operating mode, with the room thermostat set 1C above the desired indoor temperature.
@derek-m That is where I am trying to get to but something is wrong. Today the pump is drawing over 2kw in power to heat the house to 20 degrees. Consumption drops considerably once the leaving water has reached temperature but is back in ten minutes or so as the leaving water has cooled so much. There are those who say that is to be expected in extreme weather conditions like today (minus 1 at best a and freezing fog all day); the pump is less efficient when frosted up as air flow is more difficult. Counter intuitive really - a product designed to keep us warm is less efficient when it is cold. I note the booster heater was not turned on by the installer and wonder if this has anything to do with it?
Posted by: @colin-g@derek-m That is where I am trying to get to but something is wrong. Today the pump is drawing over 2kw in power to heat the house to 20 degrees. Consumption drops considerably once the leaving water has reached temperature but is back in ten minutes or so as the leaving water has cooled so much. There are those who say that is to be expected in extreme weather conditions like today (minus 1 at best a and freezing fog all day); the pump is less efficient when frosted up as air flow is more difficult. Counter intuitive really - a product designed to keep us warm is less efficient when it is cold. I note the booster heater was not turned on by the installer and wonder if this has anything to do with it?
All forms of heating systems are going to have to work harder and use more energy when the weather is cold.
Because heat pumps get most of there energy supply, free of charge, from the outside air, when the outside air is colder then there is less free energy available, so the heat pump has to work harder. Freezing fog is probably the worst operating conditions for an ASHP, lower free energy supply and increased likelihood of defrost cycling.
I cannot comment about the 2kW per hour usage, since I don't know the size of your heat pump, the type and size of your home, or the heat loss calculations and type and size of heat emitters.
@derek-mThank you. I can get that but what worries me is that it appears to be cycling. I am new to all this but the leaving water heats up to the desired temp and the pump then reduces its consumption significantly but only for 15 minutes or so as by that time then leaving water has cooled and the pump has to jump back in to heat it up. The house is not cold and this is happening when the indoor temp is 20 and the target is 21. Could that be the result if freezing fog? Certainly it was not doing this yesterday
Posted by: @colin-g@derek-mThank you. I can get that but what worries me is that it appears to be cycling. I am new to all this but the leaving water heats up to the desired temp and the pump then reduces its consumption significantly but only for 15 minutes or so as by that time then leaving water has cooled and the pump has to jump back in to heat it up. The house is not cold and this is happening when the indoor temp is 20 and the target is 21. Could that be the result if freezing fog? Certainly it was not doing this yesterday
During this cold weather I suspect the cycling will invariably be due to the heat pump defrosting. This is perfectly normal, and whilst undesirable, is nevertheless unavoidable.
@derek-m I haven't followed all this topic, but my Ecodan is defrosting once, or slightly more than once, per hour in this weather. I also thought it was cycling but after derek-m's posts, I checked and it is definitely defrosting (the Ecodan FTC controller shows this as the heating symbol turns white, and also per cathode-ray's post, the Flow temperature drops below the Return temperature).
@sliderule Yes it was defrost that was causing the concern. That was confirmed by my installer late last night and there is no evidence of that sort of behaviour this morning
- 21 Forums
- 1,869 Topics
- 40.8 K Posts
- 29 Online
- 2,189 Members
Join Us!
Heat Pump Dramas?
Thinking about installing a heat pump? Or already have one but it’s not performing as it should? Rob is here to help!
✅ Pre-Installation Planning
✅ Post-Installation Troubleshooting
✅ Performance Optimisation
Latest Posts
-
RE: How To Balance Radiators & the Role of the Lockshield Valve: A Homeowner's Guide
OAT -2C Output to RADS 37.9C Return 24.4c Flow fro...
By Alfapat , 41 minutes ago
-
RE: Controversial opinions - pure weather compensation, buffer tank, heat loss, oversized heat pumps
@uk_pete_2000 no worries I am really standing on the sh...
By Grantmethestrength , 52 minutes ago
-
RE: Is the Grant controller a thermostat?
@davidm06 a bit more detail here.
By Grantmethestrength , 1 hour ago
-
RE: Grant Aerona3 with Octopus Cosy tariff
@uk_pete_2000 to be honest we are still learning so try...
By Grantmethestrength , 1 hour ago
-
@robs I have "Eco" already, but it was suggested that I...
By DavidAlgarve , 2 hours ago
-
RE: Is My Midea Heat Pump Inherently Defective?
@cathoderay you're very welcome. If your living room ...
By BobTSkutter , 4 hours ago
-
Pipes and cables exposed on roof
Hi Hope someone can help. We've saved up and had a loca...
By MichelleC , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Baxi Air Source Heat Pump tips and tricks please
Yes, I think it is... I'm pretty sure someone on a rece...
By Mars , 4 hours ago
-
Best way to heat and store hot water with ASHP and Solar - am I being stupid?
We're about to start renovations and will be installing...
By nickmorgan , 4 hours ago
-
RE: New Project! ASHP, Solar PV + Battery, MVHR!
Totally agree. We had our MVHR pipes put in first (6i...
By Judith , 5 hours ago
-
RE: Not a good January? My heat pump used 840 KWh of electricity
Replying to the OP: Jan 2024 = 1034 kWh Jan 2025 = ...
By MikeFl , 6 hours ago
-
how can I find an installer? I can't see any register o...
By Damon , 7 hours ago
-
RE: Agile: average import cost vs other tariffs?
@broadsman That's a good shout. I can't see the flow da...
By ChandyKris , 9 hours ago
-
RE: Octopus intelligent Go, IOG. maximising slots
@gary wow! That's really impressive. Good tips. I was...
By Tim441 , 9 hours ago
-
RE: New Mitsubishi system, several concerns but just a newbie…..
I think you need to get your installer back, something ...
By Gary , 10 hours ago
-
RE: Say hello and introduce yourself
Hi looking to get ASHP this year been my goal since get...
By Silverkop , 10 hours ago
-
-
RE: Looking for some advice – no viable installer/system – I'm stuck
@james PA My kids do like a bath and have two a day ...
By Redguy17 , 13 hours ago
-
So the Financial Director as given the green light to g...
By Silverkop , 14 hours ago
-
RE: Air source heat pump roll call
User name: ASHP-AeronaASHP model: Grant Aerona3 13kW HP...
By ASHP-Aerona , 1 day ago
Latest Topics
-
Pipes and cables exposed on roof
By MichelleC 4 hours ago
-
By Silverkop 14 hours ago
-
Baxi Air Source Heat Pump tips and tricks please
By Cathyem1 15 hours ago
-
Octopus intelligent Go, IOG. maximising slots
By Tim441 1 day ago
-
Grant Aerona3 with Octopus Cosy tariff
By ASHP-Aerona 1 day ago
-
New Project! ASHP, Solar PV + Battery, MVHR!
By nickmorgan 1 day ago
-
By Curlykatie 1 day ago
-
ASHP & Radiator Sizing - Measuring Heat Loss
By IanMK13 2 days ago
-
By DavidAlgarve 3 days ago