ASHP on a low income: a cautionary tale
This is a 'cautionary tale' for anyone thinking of getting an ASHP who is on a fixed low income and/or uses their current means of heating very sparingly. I was lucky enough to get a Green Homes Grant which covered most of the installation cost and had expected the running costs to be simlar (or possibly even a little less) than a gas combi boiler. What I hadn't grasped though was the very different way it mean of heating my house. Previously, because my income is very small, I ran the heating only when absolutely needed (and generally less than was really needed for health); with the ASHP, the advice is to leave it on 24/7 at a constant (or near-constant) temperature. Even before the worst of the utility prices leap, this saw my bills tripling last winter. This winter, my plan is to keep the temperature as low as I can in order to minimise the risk of the house becoming damp and then to wear multi-layer thermals, hot water bottles, spend more time in bed, etc. This would have been so even if prices hadn't surged, but even at the heating level I'm now looking at, I have no idea how I'm going to cope financially from this point on. I'm not advising anyone else not to get an ASHP, but if you heat your house in a similar way to me pre-heat pump, think very carefully about what the 24/7 might mean in practice.
Thanks for sharing your experiences @zoomuno.
Was this (running the ASHP 24/7) explained to you when you purchased the heat pump, and did you get a breakdown showing comparative running costs between gas and the ASHP? Is your house well insulated?
Buy Bodge Buster – Homeowner Air Source Heat Pump Installation Guide: https://amzn.to/3NVndlU
From Zero to Heat Pump Hero: https://amzn.to/4bWkPFb
Subscribe and follow our Homeowners’ Q&A heat pump podcast
Thanks, Mars. The 24/7 things was explained to me when I purchased. I would say the breakdown made many assumptions about how the house would usually be heated (without making them explicit). I've refined my usage after reading a lot of posts here (thank you!) and taking advice from Midea. House is very well insulated. I'm not sure I can do much else (though open to suggestions).
Whilst I read up on heat pumps (pros and cons), I ultimately didn't grasp what it would mean in the day to day usage, and perhaps I couldn't have done fully without this practical experience. I do regret going ahead (and regret reaching that conclusion because I very much want to move towards more sustainable living). I'll see how this winter goes, but I might end up borrowing money to install a gas boiler again (and can hardly believe I'm having to consider this!). Obviously the dramatic increase in fuel tariffs has made things much worse (for everyone) and I wouldn't say to someone else in my position that they shouldn't go ahead. However, I'd advise them to be wary that there seems to be no information out there on the implications for people who are on low incomes (benefits/minimum wage/precarity, and with no possibility of improving their financial circumstances).
Posted by: @zoomunoThanks, Mars. The 24/7 things was explained to me when I purchased. I would say the breakdown made many assumptions about how the house would usually be heated (without making them explicit). I've refined my usage after reading a lot of posts here (thank you!) and taking advice from Midea. House is very well insulated. I'm not sure I can do much else (though open to suggestions).
Whilst I read up on heat pumps (pros and cons), I ultimately didn't grasp what it would mean in the day to day usage, and perhaps I couldn't have done fully without this practical experience. I do regret going ahead (and regret reaching that conclusion because I very much want to move towards more sustainable living). I'll see how this winter goes, but I might end up borrowing money to install a gas boiler again (and can hardly believe I'm having to consider this!). Obviously the dramatic increase in fuel tariffs has made things much worse (for everyone) and I wouldn't say to someone else in my position that they shouldn't go ahead. However, I'd advise them to be wary that there seems to be no information out there on the implications for people who are on low incomes (benefits/minimum wage/precarity, and with no possibility of improving their financial circumstances).
As long as you have correctly sized radiators it's a bit of a myth that you have to run an ASHP 24/7. (if you have underfloor heating it's different).
An ASHP does lose efficiency when you heat the water/let it cool repeatedly but it's not that much. My ASHP is off 12-5am and that is definitely cheaper than running it all night. My house heats up quite quickly in the morning. Having your heating varying by about 5 degrees, say between 15 and 20C is fine for an ASHP. If your heating cost tripled there might be something else going on.
Do you know how your ASHP is set up; for example, how is the radiator flow temperature controlled and what temperature is your hot water (and how much do you use)?
Thanks @kev-m. So would you switch off at night at any time of the year? In winter, my house would cool a lot if I switched off overnight, so I'm guessing the ASHP would have to work very hard during the day and might take most of the day to get to a reasonable temperature (and might take several hours if I lowered it as much as 5 degrees at night). Last winter, I most aimed for a daytime temperature of 16 or 17 degrees because of cost (not good with chronic health condition :-/ ) and 14-15 at night (but pump kept coming on during night and I found the temp too high).
The rads have been confirmed as correct size. Do you know how I can check rad flow temp control? Hot water temp is at 45 degrees. I use very little: wash up once or twice a week; shower less than average (chronic health again as opposed to bad hygiene!), but also keep hot water use to minimum (rinse hair on cold). Ridiculous really to be in this position! It would be lovely to find a way to keep the house warmer, but it's reducing the overall bill that's the priority in hopes I can avoid going back to gas.
Yes to switching off all year. My house drops from 20C or so to 15 overnight in the winter. My house is quite well insulated but only to 1990 standard with a bit extra loft insulation.
What make, model and kW rating ASHP do you have? If you tell us someone will probably be familiar with it. Also, what size and age is your house? Do you know if your ASHP is working on weather compensation? If it is then the rads will be hotter when it's colder outside. That's normally the most efficient way to run an ASHP. Are your radiators ever hot as in too hot to comfortably keep your hand on?
45C is about right for water for most people; ours is 47. Rinsing hair in cold is only going to save pennies; it's heating and/or lots of long baths and showers that rack up the pounds.
I do feel for you and hope you can at least be comfortable. If it's any consolation (and it probably isn't) at today's prices I doubt gas CH would be much cheaper to run.
@kev-m Wow, that's interesting (the switching off). I'll experiment with that come autumn.
The pump is a Midea monobloc model MHC-V10W/D2N8-B. Heating capacity says 10kW. House is three-bed semi (cavity wall insulated and well insulted loft), built 1948 but with 2022 timber built single-storey extension (insulated to max). Yes, pump is working on weather compensation. Radiators are never hot, at most luke warm in winter.
Thanks so much for your response. I'm wowed by the knowledge and generosity on this forum!
It sounds as if you have the basics right. Have a look at these threads that discuss Midea ASHPs.
There are some links/references that may be useful.
What does your EPC say for the energy and hot water consumption for your house? It can be useful to give a rough estimate of how many kWh your ASHP is likely to consume in a year.
I would be tempted if only for interest to work out how much your old mains gas boiler would have cost to run given the dramatic increases in gas prices, even higher in percentage terms than the increases in electricity prices.
Do you know what your annual consumption was for gas in kWh when you use to have a gas boiler?
Hi @jeff So my dual fuel costs for 12 months to October 2021 was £373. (My bills were extremely low compared to most households, but that kept it affordable.) My utility company (electricity only now) now wants to put my DD up to £165/month (I've resisted, but there's a debt building so I'm going to have to bite the bullet). That difference, if my maths is right and taking into account a price hike of 54%, has a little more than trebled the original costs, but I have a few additional costs since then that account for that extra.
- 21 Forums
- 1,751 Topics
- 37.5 K Posts
- 32 Online
- 2,040 Members
Join Us!
Latest Posts
-
RE: Samsung E911 intermittent issue
Will do and thanks for all the help!!
By NetDonkey , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Watch Where Your Installer Fits Motorised Valves
The irony of this entire situation isn’t lost on me @tr...
By Mars , 4 hours ago
-
RE: Getting the best out of a heat pump - is Homely a possible answer?
We've had our Homely for a couple of months now. Comple...
By benson , 6 hours ago
-
If all we cared about was cost per kwh of heat, we can ...
By Ringi , 6 hours ago
-
RE: Post Buffer Tank DUCA Circulating Pump Settings
@editor Hi, yes it does, thank you
By Potatoman , 7 hours ago
-
RE: Questions and comments about annual heat pump maintenance and servicing
@toodles mine went and it was cheaper to get another, i...
By David999 , 9 hours ago
-
RE: Agile: average import cost vs other tariffs?
I don't know if you've taken a look at all, @ianmk13, b...
By Majordennisbloodnok , 9 hours ago
-
RE: What is a considered a decent weather curve for running weather compensation?
So with a flow temp maxing at 42C, managed to get livin...
By Crimson , 10 hours ago
-
RE: Heat Pump Books For Beginners – Bodge Buster & From Zero To Heat Pump Hero
@editor I purchased both books from Amazon and read th...
By ASHP-BOBBA , 14 hours ago
-
RE: New Samsung 12KW Heat Pump Help
@mike-h Oh, I am not sure I can answer accurately, When...
By ASHP-BOBBA , 1 day ago
-
RE: Who's your electricity provider and what's your tariff?
Received an email today from British Gas informing me t...
By Mike Patrick , 1 day ago
-
RE: Mitsubishi Ecodan ASHP general set-up and efficiency
Maybe work out what brand they are and google the instr...
By Gary , 2 days ago
-
RE: The UK’s Heating Nightmare: Why Many Systems Fail Homeowners
"within a few years" is a pretty long timeframe within ...
By Transparent , 3 days ago
-
RE: The good, the bad and the not that great – my heat pump installation
@dunlorn Good shout that buddy will give it a go at ...
By Burtis , 3 days ago
-
RE: Aira Heat Pump: Stylish Scandinavian Heating
@bromide Thanks for the advice, doing it once but prope...
By ChandyKris , 4 days ago
-
RE: Grant 13kW Aerona3 - issues getting zones to temp
I've created a separate thread to discuss WC settings a...
By Crimson , 4 days ago
-
RE: Heat Pump SCOPs – The Truth Might Not Be What You Think
Thanks I will try that and look at results
By A E Deans , 4 days ago
-
RE: Excessive performance/system issues with GSHP
@johnr Thanks - the Buffer tank is in the integral gara...
By didjerama_uk , 4 days ago
-
RE: Do thick walls make for warm houses?
@robl Thanks, thats interesting 🙂
By bontwoody , 5 days ago
-
RE: Mitsubishi EcoDan ASHP Settings not saving.
@fez96 Who’d of thought.? 👍
By Westkent , 5 days ago
Latest Topics
-
Samsung E911 intermittent issue
By NetDonkey 3 days ago
-
Samsung HP secondary pump wiring
By Chris-in-Kemnay 7 days ago
-
Post Buffer Tank DUCA Circulating Pump Settings
By Potatoman 1 week ago
-
Baffled by heat pump size/ choice!
By zuluwarrior 1 week ago
-
Vaillant ASHP Weather Compensation with Octopus Cosy
By tom58l 2 weeks ago
-
By R0y124 2 weeks ago
-
Mitsubishi Ecodan 11kw Defrosting Issue.
By ThunderMink 2 weeks ago